Skip to content
problem genome

One of 592 unsolved problems in the Problem Genome, a collection written up for student design and engineering teams.

health · social · education

when the peer campaign drifts

A peer-leader programme that builds teenagers' ties to trusted adults did not reduce suicide attempts overall in a 40-school US trial, lost its first-year gains as schools ran fewer core campaigns in year two, and showed signs of harm among 9th graders, most markedly in schools that followed it poorly; an Australian trial found no change in help-seeking

Source: Wyman et al., “Impact of the Sources of Strength Peer Leader Program on…” Open ↗source: primaryLast updated: 2026-11-17

Problem statement

Sources of Strength trains a diverse group of students in each high school as peer leaders, who then run school-wide campaigns: naming trusted adults, classroom talks on "sources of strength" and similar messages. The idea is that connection spreads through students' own networks and pulls more teenagers toward adults they can turn to. In a two-year cluster trial in 40 mostly small-town and rural high schools in New York State and North Dakota (17,280 students took part in at least one survey wave), the programme raised students' communication with adults and help-seeking in year 1, but did not reduce suicide attempts overall. In year 2 schools drifted from the core campaigns ("drift" is the authors' own word), and the year-1 gains disappeared; the authors say the two coincided and call the link suggestive, not proven. Ninth graders did not benefit: across all 20 programme schools, students who were in 9th grade at the start were more likely than 9th graders in control schools to report a new suicide attempt (13.3% vs 7.5%; odds ratio 1.78, 95% CI 1.36 to 2.32, statistically significant), and the programme showed no effect for them on the adult ties it aims to build. In a post hoc analysis of the seven schools that followed the programme poorly, including by ignoring the guidance on whom to pick as peer leaders, students overall were more likely to report a new suicide attempt than in matched control schools, and the excess was concentrated in ninth graders (the 9th-grade estimate alone was imprecise; in the schools that kept to the programme more closely the 9th-grade estimate leaned the same way, less strongly, and did not reach significance: odds ratio 1.48, 95% CI 0.95 to 2.29); the authors' most persuasive explanation is that the youngest students were especially vulnerable to poorly followed delivery. The authors call these effects "potentially iatrogenic", but say other explanations cannot be ruled out: 9th graders in programme schools may have been more willing to disclose attempts, attempts were self-reported with no health records to confirm them, and unmeasured differences between schools may remain. A 13-school Australian trial found no effect on help-seeking intentions or behaviour. This page does not question school connectedness as a target: a broad review of social connection (Holt-Lunstad 2024) says there is strong evidence that interventions to increase school connectedness can improve student outcomes, including reduced suicidality. The unsolved problem is narrower: keeping a peer-led connection campaign on its core message through a second year, and in larger schools, once the research team's attention fades.

Why this matters

Peer-led programmes are attractive because they reach a whole school through students' own friendships, and schools are seen as a cost-effective setting for reaching young people. The trial authors call their study the largest to date of a universal school-based suicide prevention programme. Their conclusion is double-edged: delivered with high adherence, the programme can strengthen protective ties to adults, but with low fidelity it "has the potential for accelerating negative peer influences," particularly among younger students. In this trial, how closely a school kept to the programme separated likely benefit from possible harm to the youngest students, and adherence fell from year 1 to year 2.

What’s been tried and why it hasn’t worked

(1) The 40-school trial (New York State n = 31 schools, North Dakota n = 9). 828 students were trained as peer leaders over two years. In year 1, 11 of 20 implementing schools trained at least 10% of students as peer leaders; in year 2, 8 of 20. None of the schools with more than 500 students reached 10%. Peer-leader attendance at planning meetings averaged 59.8% in year 1 and 53.1% in year 2. The campaign inviting students to name trusted adults was completed by 18 of 19 reporting schools in year 1 and by 8 of 15 in year 2; campaigns were increasingly replaced by peer leaders' own content. Help-seeking gains present at 6 months were absent at 18 months, and the authors found an indirect effect reducing suicide attempts through more adult help with emotions in year 1 that was lost in year 2. At 18 months, programme students were also less positive than control students about getting help for suicidal friends. (2) Australia (13 schools, 1,633 students). No significant effect on help-seeking intentions or behaviour at post-intervention, 6 or 18 months; staff and students said the programme raised awareness, and staff said it gave the school a common language. The authors suggest it may suit schools in disadvantaged areas with fewer existing ties to trusted adults (full text read). (3) A better-supported version (in Colorado). The Colorado trial (Wyman et al., Am J Prev Med 2025, full text read) randomised 22 schools; two control schools dropped out before baseline, leaving 6,539 students in 20 high schools, and the programme lowered the odds of a new suicide attempt by 29% (odds ratio 0.71, 95% CI 0.55 to 0.93; 9% of programme students and 11% of control students reported a new attempt). The 40-school authors summarise the same trial as about 6,400 students and 24% less likely to report a new suicide attempt; the 24% figure is not in the trial paper. As they describe it, the trial used much expanded training for adult advisors and online campaign templates, found no difference across grades 9–11, and saw peer-leader participation rise in year 2. So expanded support is the attempt already made; what it leaves open is whether that support reaches schools without a research team, large schools that could not train 10% of students, and the youngest students. Aguilar et al. (2023), as cited in the trial paper, list further barriers: time constraints in schools, low peer-leader engagement, poor communication between peer leaders, need for more guidance from programme staff, and school buy-in. (4) An implementation toolkit (Marraccini et al. 2026, full text read). Focus groups with 16 school staff and a co-design session with nine of them produced implementation strategies, such as several ways of choosing peer leaders and recruiting more adults to share leadership, and a toolkit for Sources of Strength and similar programmes. It is built from staff views; the paper reports no test of whether it keeps schools on the core campaigns or changes student outcomes (the authors say the strategies still need testing), and its description of the toolkit does not include a measured drift check. The programme's own Adult Advisor Field Guide does carry a self-scored one: a "Fidelity Markers" checklist with thresholds (a peer-leader team of at least "5-10% of the student population", meetings at least "2x per month", campaigns and messaging that are "Hope, Help, Strength focused") and a form on which advisors enter a date, "Items completed" and a percentage for each section. The guide presents the checklist as a resource "in planning, implementation, and course-correcting", and teams sustaining the programme complete it "at the end of the year". No source read here says how many schools fill it in, how often, or whether it catches drift in time. Positive findings stand: year-1 increases in help-seeking, and a pooled analysis of three trials in 78 schools in which a state-level test showed fewer suicide deaths in programme schools while a stricter matched-pair test found no difference.

What would unlock progress

A way for a school to see drift while it is happening, and campaign tools light enough that a busy adult advisor and a changing group of peer leaders can keep to the core message in year 2. The trial authors name the measurement problem themselves: a peer-led programme can fail at either stage (leaders not taking up the message, or passing it on badly), and "a major methodological challenge will be to operationalize implementation targets." Large schools need a route to enough peer leaders, or an alternative to the 10% target. Ninth graders, new to the school and the age group where signs of harm appeared, may need their own design rather than the general campaign.

How we’d know it’s being solved

(a) Year-2 completion of the core campaigns at or above year-1 levels (trusted-adult campaign: 18 of 19 schools in year 1, 8 of 15 in year 2); (b) share of students trained as peer leaders in schools over 500 students; (c) students' reported help from adults with emotions at 18 months, the mediator the trial found; (d) for 9th graders specifically, no excess of new suicide attempts relative to control schools. Attendance at peer-leader meetings or "a campaign ran" are proxies; the trial shows campaigns can run with the core content replaced.

Where to start

This page discusses suicide. If the topic is hard for you or for someone you know, talk to someone you trust or to your campus counselling service, or contact a local crisis line or emergency number; in the United States you can call or text 988 at any time.

Facility-free door (design the check): from the trial's own adherence indicators (Table 2 of the open full text: share of students trained, meeting attendance, which campaigns ran), design a five-minute monthly drift check an adult advisor could fill in, with a rule for when a school should call for help. Start from the Marraccini et al. 2026 toolkit and from the programme's own Field Guide, whose fidelity checklist the advisors score themselves (teams sustaining the programme complete it at the end of the year), and add what neither has: a short monthly check tied to the trial's indicators, including whether each core campaign ran with its core content. Test it for clarity and time with education and counselling students on campus using invented school scenarios. No partner school, pupils or data beyond the paper are needed. Campaign-kit door (printed materials): design a printed campaign kit for the trusted-adult campaign (cards, a display, a script) that peer leaders can run in one lunch period with little adult preparation and that records whether it ran as designed. What exists: the programme's own online campaign templates and expanded advisor training used in the Colorado trial; the kit differs by needing no advisor preparation time and by leaving a record. Test it with campus peer educators or residence-hall student leaders in a mock run; they are stand-ins, and what carries over is the time and setup burden, not effects on teenagers. The mock run stays among these stand-ins; it is not a campaign aimed at residents. The mock run uses invented content only, and anyone taking part who is distressed is pointed to the campus counselling service. Design-the-test door: with a local high school, design (do not run) a one-year pilot comparing the kit and drift check against usual delivery, with a pre-registered plan; minors and a suicide-related topic mean ethics review is needed, and outcome surveys belong with the trained research team; because the 40-school trial found more reported attempts among 9th graders in programme schools, the design must say how 9th graders are followed and when the pilot would stop. Access: this door needs a partner school willing to host the design work; the team designs the pilot and does not survey pupils. Relevant skills: implementation science, education, graphic and service design.

Genes

Related problems

Stuck the same way, in other fields.

field: society & learningsubtitles on a tuesday afternoonFew UK captioned cinema screenings fall on Friday or Saturday evenings (3% in one 2022 count), deaf filmgoers say the daytime slots don't fit working lives, and exhibitors report small audiences; personal caption glasses have only begun to reach cinemasbuilt without the people who'd live with itsource: secondaryfield: making & materialsfactory data in a thousand locked drawersManufacturing data trapped in proprietary silos blocks smart manufacturing adoption by small and medium manufacturersbuilt without the people who'd live with itsource: secondaryfield: water & energywinter halves the batteryElectric vehicle batteries lose range and charge speed in cold weatherbuilt without the people who'd live with itsource: primaryfield: society & learningone label, many needsRelaxed classical concerts were advertised by only 20 of 96 UK classical organisations over 2012–2022, with features that varied from one to the next, and Canadian relaxed-performance practitioners doubt one format can meet every access need at oncebuilt without the people who'd live with itsource: primary

Sources

  • Wyman PA, Cero I, Pisani AR, Brown CH, Schmeelk-Cone K, Pickering T, Valente T, Gould M, Petrova M, Keller-Elliott C. "Impact of the Sources of Strength Peer Leader Program on Suicide Attempt Rates in 40 High Schools: A Cluster Randomized Controlled Trial." School mental health 2026;18:509-525, doi:10.1007/s12310-025-09802-w, accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • Calear AL, McCallum SM, Christensen H, Mackinnon AJ, Nicolopoulos A, Brewer JL, Werner-Seidler A, Morse AR, Kazan D, Farrer LM, Kampel L, Batterham PJ. "The Sources of Strength Australia project: A cluster randomised controlled trial of a peer-connectedness school-based program to promote help-seeking in adolescents." Journal of affective disorders 2022;299:435-443, doi:10.1016/j.jad.2021.12.043 (record; full text read at the publisher's article page through library access), accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • Wyman PA, Cero IJ, Espelage DL, Reif T, Mintz S, LoMurray S, Nickodem K, Schmeelk-Cone KH, Delgado A. "RCT of Sources of Strength Testing Impact on Suicide Attempts and Tests of Moderation by Sexual Violence Victimization and Perpetration." American Journal of Preventive Medicine 68(3):465-474, 2025, doi:10.1016/j.amepre.2024.11.008 (full text), accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • Marraccini ME, Gutman M, Wetherbee LA, Jacobs JR, Fisher DC, Espelage DL, McGlothin SH, Williams DY, Lanier P. "Sources of Strength for School‐Based Suicide Prevention: Key Implementation Strategies Based on School Professional Perspectives." Psychology in the Schools 63(11):1549-1568, 2026, doi:10.1002/pits.70184 (full text read through library access), accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • Holt-Lunstad J. "Social connection as a critical factor for mental and physical health: evidence, trends, challenges, and future implications." World Psychiatry 23(3):312-332, 2024, doi:10.1002/wps.21224 (school-connectedness passage), accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • Sources of Strength, Inc. Adult Advisor Field Guide, Second Edition, 2021 (file dated September 2022; "Fidelity Markers" section), accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
Revision notes

This brief gets checked against its sources and contains the following revisions. Future revisions get added here.

Worth knowing

  • The authors call the link between drift and the lost gains suggestive, not proven, and the comparison of schools by how closely they followed the programme was done after the fact
  • The signs of harm among ninth graders may have other explanations the authors cannot rule out: more willingness to report in programme schools, attempts that were self-reported, and differences between schools

Full check

Sources read

  • Wyman et al., Sources of Strength trial in Colorado high schools (American Journal of Preventive Medicine, 2025): full text (its online appendix was not read)
  • Wyman et al., 40-school trial of Sources of Strength (School Mental Health, 2026): full text
  • Calear et al., Sources of Strength Australia trial (Journal of Affective Disorders, 2022): full text
  • Marraccini et al., implementation strategies from school professionals (Psychology in the Schools, 2026): full text
  • Holt-Lunstad, review of social connection and health (World Psychiatry, 2024): full text (only its passage on school connectedness was read)

What changed

  • Stated more strongly than the source: the section on what would unlock progress called ninth grade the age group where harm appeared; it now says where signs of harm appeared, as the authors do not rule out other explanations.
  • Numbers: the page said only that ninth graders gained nothing; the 40-school trial reports that across all programme schools, ninth graders were more likely than ninth graders in control schools to report a new suicide attempt (13.3% against 7.5%), with no gain in the adult ties the programme aims to build; the page now gives this with the authors' explanation and their cautions; the Colorado trial's 29% is a cut in the odds of a new attempt, not in attempts; the page now gives the odds ratio and the share in each arm (9% against 11%); the 24% figure is now marked as the 40-school paper's summary; it does not appear in the Colorado trial paper.
  • Title: the full title placed the signs of harm among ninth graders only in schools that followed the programme poorly; it now says 'Most Markedly in Schools That Followed It Poorly' (display title unchanged).
  • Entry points: a safety line was added to the campaign-kit door: the mock run uses invented content only, and anyone taking part who is distressed is pointed to the campus counselling service.

Left open

  • the pooled analysis of three trials and a list of barriers from a 2023 study (given only as the 40-school paper reports them; not opened)
  • the expanded adviser training and online templates in the Colorado trial (described by the 40-school authors; not in the trial paper)

Separate check of specific claims: A line on where to get help now opens the entry points, and two sentences were reworded so they read clearly.

Separate check of specific claims: The programme's own self-scored fidelity checklist was added as an existing attempt, the ninth-grade estimate in schools that kept to the programme (leaning the same way, less strongly, not significant) was added, and the trial-design entry point now has to say how ninth graders are followed and when a pilot would stop.

Earlier full check: The Colorado trial's own figures were added, the Australian trial's 'common language' finding was credited to staff only, an unsupported cost claim and a ranking of a review were removed, a result showing programme students less positive about getting help for friends was added, and a safety line keeps the campaign-kit mock run among campus stand-ins.

Separate check of specific claims: The make door was relabelled as a printed campaign-kit door, and the real users are reached only through the trial-design door, behind a partner school and ethics review.

Earlier full check: The full title was toned down from a link to more attempts to signs of harm, the link between drift and lost gains is now called suggestive as the authors do, an unsupported claim of harm in year two was removed, and an implementation toolkit and the evidence on school connectedness were added.