Skip to content
problem genome

One of 592 unsolved problems in the Problem Genome, a collection written up for student design and engineering teams.

arts

one label, many needs

Relaxed classical concerts were advertised by only 20 of 96 UK classical organisations over 2012–2022, with features that varied from one to the next, and Canadian relaxed-performance practitioners doubt one format can meet every access need at once

Source: Abbott et al., “Relaxed performances: supporting aural diversity and…” Open ↗source: primaryLast updated: 2026-11-12

Problem statement

A "relaxed performance" (RP) loosens the rules of a concert or play for people who find them a barrier, especially autistic people and others with differences in sensory processing: audiences may make noise, move and leave, house lights stay partly up, sound and light effects are softened, and a quiet space is available. Theatre and cinema have used RPs since about 2009; classical music came later. A systematic web search of the 96 professional classical-music organisations active in the UK in 2022 (orchestras, opera and ballet companies, ensembles, choirs) found evidence that only 20 had staged an RP in the previous ten years, and only 14 had advertised more than one; the yearly number rose from a single RP in 2014 to 19 in 2022. Even where they exist, RPs mean different things: a relaxed attitude to noise, a breakout space and an open-door policy were fairly common, but performance familiarisation, sound and lighting adjustment and picture communication were advertised by fewer than half of the organisations that ran RPs, under inconsistent names. The deeper design problem, which the authors argue from their observations rather than measure, is that RP audiences can have needs that pull in opposite directions; as they put it, "a relaxed attitude to noise suitable for parents of babies and young children could prove distracting to those who experience hyperacusis or difficulties with auditory streaming." The unsolved problem is a concert format, and a way of describing it, that lets each listener know in advance which sensory conditions an event will have and find one that suits them, rather than one "relaxed" label covering incompatible needs. Pieces of this exist at single events and venues (an autism arts festival, two Aural Diversity concerts, a venue-specific sensory guide; see below), but none has become a shared description that classical organisations use, and none has been evaluated for whether listeners can predict the conditions from it.

Why this matters

The research that exists is mostly positive about what RPs offer: an evaluation of the 2017 Autism Arts Festival in Canterbury (a self-selected sample: 21 pre-festival responses, 34 post-festival) found that 58% of pre-festival respondents disagreed that "mainstream" arts are easily accessible to them, that the most wanted accommodations included plot summaries in advance (92%), quiet areas (92%) and lists of sensory triggers (85%), and that 100% of post-festival respondents rated the festival "accessible" or "very accessible". The Sound Studies authors note that atypical responses to sensory input "are thought to affect up to 90% of autistic people," so loud or unpredictable sound is a real barrier for many. But classical concerts depend on silent, seated listening, which the authors argue excludes "aurally-diverse and neurodiverse" listeners, and the scarcity and inconsistency of RPs make it hard for those listeners to know what they will find. Interviews with practitioners trained in RP in Canada show the same concern from the provider's side: most "did not endorse the idea that it was possible or even desirable to have RP meeting all access needs at once."

What’s been tried and why it hasn’t worked

(1) Adapted RPs: an existing production with access adjustments (all opera and ballet companies in the survey used this style). These typically "made adjustments to improve disabled access, but made minimal changes to the aesthetic content." (2) Bespoke RPs: specially curated concerts with short extracts, participation, commentary, and embedded audio description or British Sign Language (most orchestras and choirs; 55% of RP-offering organisations overall). (3) Big-venue RPs. The authors' observations of three RPs (Graeae's The Paradis Files, English National Opera's The Cunning Little Vixen, the BBC Relaxed Proms) found the format offered listeners multiple ways of listening but was limited by the buildings: in the Royal Albert Hall not all seats had a sufficient view of the BSL interpreter, and the London Coliseum's steeply raked seating limited wheelchair places; for a touring production, accessibility requirements were different for every location. The authors suggest that being unable to meet some physical needs may have deterred organisations from attempting RPs at all. (4) Training. British Council Canada had trained upwards of 200 arts workers in RP; trainees found it valuable, but they reported that delivering a good RP "requires advanced planning, forethought, and communication," and that marketing RPs is hard because non-disabled audiences assume they are "not for" them, which risks segregating disabled audiences. (5) One label for everyone. The common thread is the "for all" framing. The Sound Studies authors argue (they did not measure it) that the noise welcomed at an RP suited to families with young children could distract listeners with hyperacusis or auditory-streaming difficulties; a relative interviewed for the Autism Arts Festival study put it as "you can't please everybody. You'll find some who say, 'It wasn't loud enough' or 'It was too loud'." The authors propose, as an unlock rather than a tested solution, a consistent categorisation with symbols akin to Universal Access symbols. Their three example categories (Relaxed Adaptation, Relaxed Original, Relaxed Venue) distinguish how the event is made, but each definition repeats the same sensory conditions (no requirement to stay silent or seated, a quiet space, sudden sound and lighting changes removed), so the scheme as drafted does not yet separate conflicting sensory needs. (6) Information that lets listeners choose. This has been built at single events. The Autism Arts Festival gave "detailed information about all performances, so that those who wished to avoid loud noises or triggers like drums or balloons could do so," an approach its authors call facilitating self-regulation; they concluded there is "no single 'one-size fits all' solution" and that more detailed analysis of which features were used by whom is still needed. The Aural Diversity network's 2019 concerts, designed for hearing types "from hyperacusis to profound deafness," set conventions of dim lighting, minimal ambient noise, no applause, and a programme "laid out like a menu" giving each piece's loudness, contrasts and recommended ways of listening; no evaluation is reported. A 2024 Sensory Access guide to one production at The 5th Avenue Theatre gives a peak decibel level for each ten-minute interval, from an audit by a neurodivergent, hyperacusic team member, but warns that its information "should not be relied on for performances at other venues." What these leave unsolved is a description that works across organisations and venues, and evidence that it lets a listener choose correctly.

What would unlock progress

Two linked pieces, starting from what the single-event examples above already do. First, a shared, specific vocabulary for sensory conditions at a concert: not "relaxed: yes/no" but what the noise policy, sound level, lighting, seating, movement, quiet space and pre-visit information will be, communicated in a form listeners can scan. This extends the Sound Studies authors' recommendation of a consistent categorisation with symbols (their draft categories describe delivery type, not sensory conditions) and borrows the per-piece programme of the Aural Diversity concerts and the decibel-by-interval format of the Sensory Access venue guide, made comparable across venues. Second, formats that separate conflicting needs instead of combining them: for example, a series in which some events welcome noise and movement and others guarantee low volume and few sudden sounds, or a single concert space with zones of different sensory intensity. One orchestra already runs two separate formats: the Minnesota Orchestra offers "Sensory-Friendly Concerts" with "individual musicians or small ensembles" in an atrium and separate relaxed family concerts with "the full Orchestra in the main auditorium". Its page does not say how noise rules or sound levels differ between the two and reports no evaluation, so whether a split series serves listeners whose needs conflict is untested. Adjacent practice the authors point to includes flexible community venues with tactile stimuli and vibrating floors (the Aural Diversity network; US sensory-friendly concerts) and Touretteshero's "Relaxed Venue" approach at Battersea Arts Centre, which applies RP principles across the centre's entire programme rather than to single performances.

How we’d know it’s being solved

Listener-side measures: before booking, can a listener with a given sensory profile correctly predict the conditions they will meet (a comprehension test of the labelling system), and after the event, did the conditions match and did they stay to the end. Provider-side measures: the number of organisations offering events described in the shared vocabulary, and the spread of event types (not just family-noise RPs). Beware the proxy: "number of relaxed performances" counts events, not whether the right listener could find the right one.

Where to start

Facility-free door: repeat and extend the published method on current data: search the websites of UK classical organisations (the paper names the three lists it used to find them; whether each is openly available was not checked) for RPs advertised since mid-2022, code the features each one names, and measure how much the descriptions vary. Then design, starting from the Aural Diversity programme conventions and the Sensory Access guide format, a labelling scheme (symbols plus a short structured description) and test it with autistic and hyperacusic volunteers for comprehension. Design door: design a concert-space layout or event series that separates conflicting sensory needs (zones, timed quiet sections, wearable sound-level options), and evaluate it with simulated sound-level measurements and user walkthroughs. Partner door (design the trial, don't run it): with an orchestra that already runs RPs, design a study comparing its current RP description with the new labels, measuring whether audiences' expectations match their experience. Access note: work with autistic and neurodivergent participants requires ethics review; the first door's website survey needs none. Relevant skills: information design, acoustics, inclusive design, qualitative research.

Genes

Related problems

Stuck the same way, in other fields.

field: water & energythe worst air conditioners go southInefficient air conditioners are dumped into markets without testing capacity to verify claimsbuilt without the people who'd live with itsource: secondaryfield: food & the living worldthe kilns changed, the workers didn'tIndia's 50,000 brick kilns must convert to cleaner technology by mandate — but 43% of converted kilns surveyed in bihar operate inefficiently because the workforce transition was never designedbuilt without the people who'd live with itsource: secondaryfield: health & medicinethe exercise rarely handed outHome balance exercises help chronic dizziness and have been packaged as booklets and free websites, yet primary care still rarely prescribes them, many trial patients did not report finishing them, and GPs keep prescribing anti-vertigo drugs with weak evidencebuilt without the people who'd live with itsource: primaryfield: health & medicinethe floor as a disease vectorSealing a dirt floor cuts childhood diarrhea in half — but the only proven fix is cement too many families can't affordbuilt without the people who'd live with itsource: primary

Sources

  • Abbott EHR, Critten A, MacGregor EH. "Relaxed performances: supporting aural diversity and neurodiversity among classical concert audiences in the United Kingdom." Sound Studies 12(1):89–112, 2026 (published online 2024), doi:10.1080/20551940.2024.2333622, accessed 2026-10-22. Link ↗
  • LaMarre A, Rice C, Besse K. "Letting Bodies be Bodies: Exploring Relaxed Performance in the Canadian Performance Landscape." Studies in Social Justice 15(2):184-208, 2021, doi:10.26522/ssj.v15i2.2430, accessed 2026-10-22. Link ↗
  • Fletcher-Watson B, May S. "Enhancing relaxed performance: evaluating the Autism Arts Festival." Research in Drama Education: The Journal of Applied Theatre and Performance 23(3):406-420, 2018, doi:10.1080/13569783.2018.1468243 (accepted manuscript; summary), accessed 2026-10-22. Link ↗ Link 2 ↗
  • Aural Diversity network, "Aural Diversity Concerts: Conventions" and concert pages, accessed 2026-10-22. Link ↗ Link 2 ↗ Link 3 ↗
  • Sensory Access, "5th Ave Clue Sensory Guide," 2024, accessed 2026-10-22. Link ↗
  • Minnesota Orchestra, "Relaxed Family & Sensory-Friendly Concerts (all ages)" (read in the Internet Archive capture of 29 October 2026), accessed 2026-11-12. Link ↗

Also cited in the brief

  • Enhancing relaxed performance evaluating the Autism Arts Festival (kar.kent.ac.uk) Link ↗
Revision notes

This brief gets checked against its sources and contains the following revisions. Future revisions get added here.

Worth knowing

  • The main paper's split of 55% bespoke and 45% adapted relaxed concerts does not match its own counts, which would make 13 of 20 bespoke; the page repeats the paper as printed.
  • The paper's 2022 count of 19 relaxed concerts comes from data collected by mid-2022, so it may undercount that year.

Full check

Sources read

  • Abbott, Critten and MacGregor, relaxed performances at UK classical concerts (Sound Studies, 2024): full text
  • LaMarre, Rice and Besse, relaxed performance training in Canada (2021): full text
  • Fletcher-Watson and May, evaluating the Autism Arts Festival (Research in Drama Education, 2018): full text (the accepted manuscript)
  • CultureCase, summary of the Autism Arts Festival study: full text
  • Aural Diversity, concert conventions and two concert pages (2019): full text
  • Sensory Access, sensory guide to one production at The 5th Avenue Theatre (2024): full text
  • University of Edinburgh, Quiet Concerts news page (2023): full text
  • Minnesota Orchestra, Relaxed Family and Sensory-Friendly Concerts page: full text (read from an archived copy)

What changed

  • Stated more strongly than the source: that Sensory Access publishes venue guides with sound levels, each audited by a hyperacusic auditor; only one guide was read, so the page now describes that one guide, in three places.

Left open

  • that no shared way of describing concert conditions is used across classical organisations, or has been tested with listeners (rests on searches, not a source)

Separate check of specific claims: An orchestra that already runs two separate relaxed formats was added to the unlock, and a statement about how one article was read was brought up to date.

Earlier full check: The most wanted festival accommodations now include quiet areas, and two descriptions of relaxed events were brought back to the papers' words.

Separate check of specific claims: The long title was narrowed and the display title changed from One Room, Opposite Needs to One Label, Many Needs; a festival finding was replaced with the paper's own figures, a start date was sourced, and existing per-event sound guides were added as earlier attempts.