Skip to content
problem genome

One of 592 unsolved problems in the Problem Genome, a collection written up for student design and engineering teams.

social · education · digital

a seat kept warm by a robot

Small avatar robots let long-sick pupils sit in on class from home, but in a Norwegian interview study of 37 users the researchers judged about a quarter's experiences mostly negative, mainly because of weak school networks and school resistance, and small German and Japanese studies still report slow approvals, privacy refusals and, in Germany, consent rules that can block use

Source: Johannessen et al., “Kan en robot hjelpe langtidssyke barn? Erfaringer med…” Open ↗source: primaryLast updated: 2026-11-17

Problem statement

Children who miss months of school through cancer, chronic fatigue or surgery lose touch with their class, and the longer they are away the harder it is to come back. A small avatar robot (AV1 in Norway, Denmark and Germany; OriHime in Japan) sits on the absent child's desk and streams the classroom to the child's tablet; the child can look around, speak and "raise a hand" with a light, but is not seen. Where it works, children and parents describe less loneliness and an easier return. But in a Norwegian interview study commissioned by the foundation that lent the robots (141 interviews, including 37 children who borrowed robots free from it), the researchers' own judgement-based count was 16 mostly positive, 11 mixed and 10 mostly negative experiences, and attribute the negative and mixed ones mainly to the robot's surroundings, such as weak school networks and schools that refused it or opened long privacy reviews; some children were also too ill, or too well, to use it. Later, a small German and Japanese interview study (2022–2023) and a 2025 German teacher survey report the same gatekeeping: in Germany, approvals that take months, opt-in consent where one classmate's refusal stops use, and access that depends on how hard a family can push; in Japan, school districts that refuse the robot on privacy grounds. The unsolved problem is getting the robot into the classroom, and kept in use there, without each sick child's family having to clear the path alone.

Why this matters

By the figures of No Isolation, the maker, as cited by the Norwegian researchers, about 6,000 long-sick children in Norway could use AV1 (500,000 in Europe), and it counted around 890 active robot users across the countries where it sold in August 2019. A German teacher survey frames the stake: school belonging is a protective factor, and childhood cancer survivors are at higher risk of repeating a school year (Grabowski et al., citing earlier work). A German hospital coordinator warned that the high consent threshold "further exaggerates" unequal access, because well-connected families can push their way through (Spoden and Ema 2024).

What’s been tried and why it hasn’t worked

(1) Foundation loans to families (Norway, 2018–2019). Gjensidigestiftelsen funded 100 free AV1 loans and had lent robots to 141 recipients by the end of 2019, 121 of them private users. The foundation had hoped schools and organisations would apply; mostly families did, and it lacked the staff to follow them up ("we would have needed a whole army," a staff member said; our translation). Parents had to apply, then persuade the school. 11 of 37 users met a sceptical school; a maker's support employee described a municipality where the decision on two pupils' robots passed between the school, the school chief and the mayor for six months and then came back as no, for the time being; one mother, unable to find out who decided, gave up and sent the robot back. The authors recommend shifting loans to schools and municipalities, citing Stavanger, which bought 10 robots to lend to its schools. (2) Technical fixes. Of 33 users who could judge it, 6 had few or no network problems, 25 moderate problems and 2 gave up; a girl with cancer stopped talking through it because the stutter broke conversations. A second version with a better network chip and an on/off button came in 2018, and the maker made a teacher app and a poster explaining the light signals. Teachers still found the signals unintuitive, and with no screen they could not tell when the child's stream had frozen. (3) Privacy safeguards built into the device (live stream only, no recording, one paired device, a light when someone is logged on). These reassured many schools but not all: some teachers feared parents watching their lessons or the stream being filmed from a phone, and some municipalities' lawyers required signed opt-in consent, which in practice confined the robot to the classroom. (4) Hospital-run programmes (Germany) and education-board rental (Japan). In Germany, where hospitals distribute AV1 and donations or non-profits often pay for it, opt-in written consent is required from every teacher and every classmate or guardian; coordinators report implementations that failed for lack of consent, approvals that took months, and a waiting list. In Japan, OriHime rentals must be renewed every year and are paid from prefectural or school budgets (often after a foundation-backed pilot); budgets vary, some districts refuse it on privacy grounds, and one school had to collect the device from the board and return it every day it was used. Spoden and Ema conclude that equal access needs board rules, budgets, privacy standards "that are adequate, yet do not create implementation hurdles that are too high," and teacher training. (5) A coordinator who delivers the robot to the school (Denmark, 2020). A charity project gave 21 children with muscular disease robots, with a coordinator visiting each school; its own evaluation, written by the project coordinator, reports good results (72% of the children, in a survey 20 of the 21 answered, said they were in school more) but concludes that Danish school law does not accommodate the technology. (6) Still, in studies published in 2026: 298 German teachers rated "responsibility for the telepresence avatar" the highest barrier (3.60 of 5), ahead of internet connectivity and data protection, and two of three interviewed parents described slow data-protection and consent procedures, and in one case teachers refused it in their lessons (Grabowski et al.); Scandinavian municipal staff called compulsory-education law a barrier, and one in Sweden said it was "written before this technology existed" (Skoubo et al.). Positive findings stand: all three German parents described the avatar as valuable, and in Norway several sceptical teachers said their worries faded as they got used to the robot. How strong the evidence is: every source here is small or close to the robot's makers or funders. The Norwegian report was commissioned by Gjensidigestiftelsen, the foundation that lent the robots, and its 16/11/10 split is the authors' own judgement-based count; the Danish evaluation is a charity self-evaluation by its coordinator; the Scandinavian municipal study (25 staff) was funded by No Isolation, the maker, and the Research Council of Norway, and its first author, Sofie Skoubo, has the same name as the Danish charity evaluation's author and coordinator (Sofie Sejer Skoubo) and works on the same topic in Denmark, so she is probably the same person; the German–Japanese study's two authors say they work together on OryLab's OriHime robot and declare no commercial conflict, and its Japanese interviews began with OryLab, OriHime's maker, and some interviewees were introduced by the makers (OryLab and No Isolation). The German teacher survey (298 teachers, no declared conflict) is the one sizeable independent source, and it measures perceived barriers, not use. (7) Already built for a different device (Flanders, Belgium): synchronous internet teaching for pupils expected to need it for at least four weeks (or 36 half-days, if often absent) is run by Bednet, a non-profit subsidised by the Flemish education ministry, free to pupil and school, with Bednet supplying the ICT kit to both (Flemish government page). The page describes an internet link between class and home, not a robot; no evaluation of what it leaves unsolved was read for this page.

What would unlock progress

A delivery model in which an institution, not the family, carries the setup: who owns the robot, who answers for damage, who tests the network before the first lesson, and how classmates are told. In Norway the most problem-free case was the one school that had applied for the robot itself. Flanders' Bednet already runs such an institution-carried model for internet links (see (7)), so a team should start from it and ask what a robot adds that its model does not cover: classmates' consent to a moving camera, and taking the device out of the classroom. Municipal pools alone do not remove the hurdles: Skoubo et al. interviewed 25 Scandinavian municipal staff who organise telepresence robots for schools, and they describe long implementations because ethical and data-protection permissions had to be in place first, compulsory-education law that is not explicit about the robots, and consent rules that differ from school to school (some schools asked other pupils' parents to consent; at others, informing was enough). In England, councils already own the robots and rent them to schools: a 2023 Schools Week report says "Fifty councils now have the devices" and "Most councils allow schools to rent the devices", and that schools now use them to help pupils struggling with anxiety back into school, not only sick pupils. The same report says "Some teachers have expressed their concerns about their use, including over privacy, safeguarding and workload", and that a 2021 evaluation of AV1 robots in the Department for Education's alternative provision innovation fund pilot found "lots of people feared that it would be recording" (as Schools Week reports it; the evaluation itself was not read). The report does not say who sets the robot up or who pays for damage. The consent question also needs a standard answer. The Norwegian authors point to a government report proposing that the Education Act's duty to provide teaching and social belonging can be the legal basis, which would remove the need for every classmate's signature; the German sources, published in 2024 (from interviews in 2022) and in 2026, show opt-in consent still in use. The maker tells Norwegian schools they are not legally obliged to collect consent from classmates' parents (an undated No Isolation brochure hosted on NAV's assistive-device database; a maker's claim, not a ruling). On the classroom side, the robot depends on classmates to carry it (it has no wheels), and fear of paying for damage kept some schools from taking it to breaks and play, where the social contact happens.

How we’d know it’s being solved

(a) Days from a family's first request to the first lesson through the robot; (b) share of loaned robots that reach regular use (the nearest figure is the Norwegian study's 10 of 37 mostly negative experiences; it did not count regular use); (c) share of use outside lessons (breaks, trips), since social contact is the aim and classroom-only use gave "limited social benefit" (our translation); (d) whether access depends on family resources, for example by comparing approval times across schools in one area. Beware the proxy: robots shipped or loaned are not robots used.

Where to start

Facility-free door (design the paperwork): build the one-school starter pack the sources say is missing: a responsibility sheet (who carries, charges, pays for repairs), a classmates' briefing, and a consent letter. Write two versions, one for an opt-out (passive) consent regime like the Norwegian schools that used it and one for the German opt-in regime, and test them as paper prototypes with teachers and education students on campus for clarity and time to complete. No partner, robot or restricted data is needed. Make door: design a protective carry cradle or sling that lets a classmate take a small table-top avatar robot (about 27 cm tall, about 1 kg, no wheels) to breaks, play and trips, aimed at the barrier the Norwegian report names: teachers and parents, unsure who would pay for repairs, restricted use in "risky" (our translation) situations such as breaks and play, where play could be rough and outdoor use depended on the weather. It should guard against drops, knocks and rain while leaving the camera, speaker and head light free. What exists: the robot itself; a German class carried one on a night hike in a rucksack with its head peeking out, so a plain rucksack is the baseline the cradle must beat; wheeled robots the pupil drives from home (the Danish project tested one) are the other route. The cradle will not fix the stream: Norwegian users found the connection often worse when the robot was moved. Test the cradle against the rucksack with campus student volunteers carrying a same-size, same-weight dummy through a mock break and a stair route, timing set-down and counting knocks. What carries over from that test is handling and protection only; whether classmates and teachers then take the robot out of the classroom needs the design-the-test door below. Design-the-test door: the real users are the long-sick child, the classmates who carry and talk to the robot, and their teachers. Reached through a nearby school that has a long-sick pupil, design (do not run) a study of approval time and out-of-class use, with an instrument and analysis plan handed to the school; children are involved, so ethics review is needed before anything is run. Relevant skills: product design, service design, education, law.

Genes

Related problems

Stuck the same way, in other fields.

field: water & energythe worst air conditioners go southInefficient air conditioners are dumped into markets without testing capacity to verify claimsbuilt without the people who'd live with itsource: secondaryfield: food & the living worldtraced on many platforms, connected on fewCross-platform interoperability failure fragments food supply chain traceabilitybuilt without the people who'd live with itsource: primaryfield: the built worldthe helmet stops at the handlebarsVietnam got 90–99% of adults into motorcycle helmets within a year of its 2007 law — its children are still riding bareheaded, and a national campaign's gains in Hanoi mostly faded within eight months of the police blitz endingbuilt without the people who'd live with itsource: primaryfield: digital & spacethe account she can't openWomen are 36% less likely than men to own a mobile money account — and the gap is widening despite a decade of programs to close itbuilt without the people who'd live with itsource: secondary

Sources

  • Johannessen LEF, Haldar M. "Kan en robot hjelpe langtidssyke barn? Erfaringer med AV1 i skolen." OsloMet Skriftserie 2020 nr 5, OsloMet – storbyuniversitetet, ISBN 978-82-8364-243-8, accessed 2026-11-17 (Norwegian, read in the original) Link ↗
  • Spoden C, Ema A. "Staying connected: implementing avatar robots at schools in Germany and Japan." Frontiers in digital health 2024;6:1273415, doi:10.3389/fdgth.2024.1273415, accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • Grabowski FC, Dördelmann J, Exner B, Frielitz FS. "Telepresence avatar use for children with cancer in schools: a study on barriers and facilitators." Frontiers in digital health 2026;8:1867390, doi:10.3389/fdgth.2026.1867390, accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • Skoubo S, Larsen HB, Willard MW, Handberg C. "Community Care Stakeholders' Reflection on Using Telepresence Robots as a Tool to Reduce School Absence for Children and Young People with Chronic Illness in the Scandinavian Municipalities." International journal of environmental research and public health 2026;23:743, doi:10.3390/ijerph23060743, accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • Skoubo SS. "Evaluering af 'robotprojektet 2020': En evaluering af robotteknologi for 21 børn og unge med muskelsvind." Muskelsvindfonden, 2020, accessed 2026-11-17 (Danish, read in the original) Link ↗
  • Vlaamse overheid. "Synchroon internetonderwijs (SIO).", accessed 2026-11-17 (Dutch) Link ↗
  • No Isolation. AV1 product sheet "For lærere og foresatte", hosted on NAV FinnHjelpemiddel, accessed 2026-11-17 (Norwegian; maker's material) Link ↗
  • Booth S. "How robots are helping anxious pupils go back to school." Schools Week, 6 October 2023 (read in the Internet Archive copy), accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗ Link 2 ↗
Revision notes

This brief gets checked against its sources and contains the following revisions. Future revisions get added here.

Worth knowing

  • every source is small or close to the robot's makers or funders; the page says which, and the one sizeable independent source is a survey of teachers' views, not of use

Full check

Sources read

  • Johannessen and Haldar, AV1 robots for long-sick children in Norway (OsloMet report, 2020): full text (read in Norwegian)
  • Spoden and Ema, avatar robots at schools in Germany and Japan (Frontiers in Digital Health, 2024): full text
  • Grabowski et al., telepresence avatars for children with cancer in German schools (Frontiers in Digital Health, 2026): full text
  • Skoubo et al., Scandinavian municipal staff on telepresence robots (International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 2026): full text
  • Muskelsvindfonden, evaluation of its robot project (2020): full text (read in Danish from an archived copy)
  • Flemish government page on synchronous internet teaching: full text (read in Dutch)
  • No Isolation, AV1 brochure for teachers and parents: full text (the maker's own material, read in Norwegian)

What changed

  • Quotations: the words 'written before this technology existed' were given as what municipal staff said of school-absence law; they are one Swedish participant's words about the legislation, and the page now says staff called compulsory-education law a barrier; two translated quotations, including 'risky' in the make door, are now marked as our translation.
  • Credit: in Germany, hospitals choose the pupils and hand out the robots, while donations and charities pay for them; the page had charities handing them out.
  • Dates: opt-in consent was said to be in use 'in 2024 and 2026'; those are publication years, and the German interviews ran in 2022; a heading saying 'Still in 2026' now says 'in studies published in 2026', since the survey and interviews ran the year before; the maker's consent advice is no longer said to be current; the brochure carries no date.
  • Citation details: the website hosting the maker's brochure is now given by the name it uses.
  • Other: a sentence now says that municipal staff who already organise these robots still meet hurdles: permissions that must come first, a school law that does not mention the robots, and consent rules that differ from school to school.

Left open

None noted in this check.

Separate check of specific claims: A news report that councils in England already own the robots and rent them to schools was added, the six-month refusal story is now credited to a maker's support employee, and the count of mostly negative experiences is no longer read as a count of robots not used.

Earlier full check: Nine details were brought in line with the sources, among them that one classmate's refusal (not anyone's) stops use in Germany, two parents rather than three described slow approvals, the higher risk applies to childhood cancer survivors, and the authors' ties to a robot maker are now given as the paper states them.

Separate check of specific claims: The make door's carry cradle was re-aimed at the worry over who pays for repairs, since moving the robot makes the connection worse rather than better, and the real users and an ethics line were named.

Earlier full check: The full title was toned down to the researchers' own judgement-based count, an unsupported claim that the Norwegian study was the largest was removed, funders were named, and a paragraph on how strong the evidence is and an existing Belgian service were added.