Skip to content
problem genome

One of 592 unsolved problems in the Problem Genome, a collection written up for student design and engineering teams.

health

forty-two degrees feels like thirty-nine

Japan advises older people to warm the changing room, keep bath water at 41 °C or less, soak no more than ten minutes and check with a thermometer and timer, but in laboratory tests older bathers felt no difference between 39 °C and 42 °C water, surveys found bathroom heating in only 3% to 24% of homes, and the water-heater remotes that watch the bath, whether they alert family or tell the bather when to get out, are described only for particular heater models

Source: Tochihara et al., “日本の冬季における高齢者の入浴死について” Open ↗source: primaryLast updated: 2026-11-17

Problem statement

Most Japanese older people bathe almost every day by soaking to the shoulders in hot water, and in winter they do so in bathrooms and changing rooms that are often barely heated. The problem this page is about is bath deaths (drowning and sudden death in the tub, which the review links to cold rooms, hot water and long soaks); burns in the bath are a separate, smaller harm noted below. How those deaths happen is now argued over: the classic account blames "heat shock" from a cold changing room, while a 2026 Japanese opinion article argues that overheating in the water during long hot soaks may play the larger part. Either way, the quantities that matter are ones older bathers do not feel well. Japan's Consumer Affairs Agency reports that 5,824 people aged 65 or over died in baths at home or in residential facilities in 2022. Its advice is to warm the changing room and bathroom first, keep the water at 41 °C or below, soak for no more than 10 minutes, and "use a thermometer or timer to make the water temperature, bathing time and so on visible" (our translation). That advice depends on the bather noticing temperature and time, and a 2021 Japanese review of the physiology shows why older bathers cannot rely on feel: in laboratory tests, young bathers clearly felt the difference between 39 °C and 42 °C water while older bathers reported none, and older bathers at 41 °C mostly reported feeling "nothing in particular" and comfortable throughout (our translation). The review reports that people who find the bathroom cold run the water hotter and stay in longer, yet the surveys it cites found bathroom heating in only 3% to 24% of homes. Some water heaters already detect a bather and time the soak. In the Noritz (2021) and Corona (2020) functions the alert goes to a family member's smartphone; a 2019 Tokyo Gas and Purpose remote calls out to the bather by chime and voice when it detects no movement, then alerts family at the kitchen remote, and a 2023 Noritz system tells the bather by voice when to get out, timed from bathroom and water temperature. Each is described for particular heater models and remotes, and none of the articles reports a test with older bathers. The unsolved problem is keeping a bather who cannot feel a long soak or a cold room within safe limits, without relying on the sense that has faded or on someone else watching, in the bath and heater a household already has.

Why this matters

Deaths. The Consumer Affairs Agency counts 7,900 drowning deaths of people 65 and over in 2022, of whom 5,824 died in bathtubs at home or in facilities, more than twice the 2,154 older people killed in traffic. Death certificates record many bath deaths as heart or stroke deaths rather than drowning, so the review's abstract estimates that winter bathing deaths of older people reach about 18,000 a year; its body reports national estimates of about 14,000, 17,000, 18,000 and 18,717 a year from different extrapolations of ambulance data. These are estimates, not counts. Burns (a separate harm). In one hospital's series of ten patients aged 65 or over burned in their own bathtubs over five years, all were independent in daily life before the injury, eight needed surgery, two died, and the other eight were transferred to another hospital still needing rehabilitation or care (abstract only). The page uses the burns series only for its point about controls, not for the scale of the problem.

What’s been tried and why it hasn’t worked

(1) Advice to the bather. Several agencies and researchers publish the same list, which the review reproduces: warm the changing room and bathroom; water not hot (41 °C or less); no long soaks (10 minutes or less); half-body rather than full immersion; stand up slowly; drink water; call out to older bathers often; do not bathe when unwell or after drinking. The review shows why the temperature and time items run against what older bathers feel. Older people's ability to tell temperatures apart at the fingertip falls from about 0.5 °C before 50 to 1.0–5.0 °C after 65. In bathing tests, older people rated 40 °C water "slightly hot" where young people rated it "hot" (8 of each); at 39 °C and 42 °C (11 older and 10 young bathers, 8 minutes) older bathers reported no difference in sensation and, unlike the young, no discomfort at 42 °C; at 41 °C for 15 minutes (10 of each) older bathers felt "nothing in particular" and comfortable throughout while young bathers went from "slightly warm" to "hot." The authors connect this lack of sensitivity to older people's preference for long, hot baths in winter. Half-body bathing, they add, is uncomfortable and unrealistic unless the room is fairly warm. The field measurements the review cites cut both ways: average winter water temperatures measured in homes were about 40–41 °C (40.8 °C in 42 older people's homes in northern Kanto; 40.1 °C measured for ten bathers), at or just under the 41 °C line, while bathing time for those ten bathers averaged 20.2 minutes (the review does not say how much of that was spent in the tub; a questionnaire of 216 older club members in Tokai that it also cites reported about 11 minutes in the tub), and most of those bathers said the room was "not especially cold" although it was 20 °C or below. So the cold room looks like a larger gap than water temperature alone; the home figures do not settle how long older bathers soak. The Consumer Affairs Agency's own column adds an instrument to the advice: use a thermometer or timer to make water temperature and bathing time visible. No evaluation of whether older bathers use them was found. Bath thermometers that warn by themselves are already sold: on its maker's page, Dretec's O-238, which floats in the bath and is sold for bathing babies, flashes a lamp when the water is 39 °C or above, and the manual of a retailer's own-brand model (Nishimatsuya TEM-900-Y) says it starts measuring once put in the water and lightly shaken, flashes red and sounds an alarm at a preset 39 °C (adjustable from 37 °C to 40 °C), and counts up the time in the water. Neither page mentions older bathers or bath accidents, the adjustable range stops below the 41 °C line in the adult advice, and on the second model an alarm at a set soak time sounds only if the bather sets a countdown. (2) Warming the room. The review argues that the hot-water, long-soak and half-body items are mostly solved by warming the changing room and bathroom, recommends 20 °C or more and 25 °C for older people, and notes that where bath deaths are low the rooms are warm (in Asahikawa the living room, changing room and bathroom at bath time were all 21 °C or more; in Sapporo the bathroom averaged 22 °C). It also reports a case-control study of short (four-hour) heating in which older people's living-room temperature rose 2.1 °C and systolic blood pressure fell 4.4 mmHg compared with controls (a living-room study, not a bathroom one). But bathroom heating is uncommon: about 11% of detached houses in Kinki, 3% of older people's homes in Fukuoka, and 24.3% in a national internet survey of adults; 39% of houses were uninsulated; and average night-time changing-room temperature in detached houses outside Hokkaido is below 15 °C. Older people are also more tolerant of cold bathrooms: in a national survey, they rated a bathroom or toilet at about 12 °C "just right." (3) Water heaters that watch the bath. Monitoring is already built into some gas water heaters and their bath remotes. Noritz's GT-C2462 series (announced in January 2021 for release on 1 March; 426,000 and 437,000 yen before tax) detects entry and bathing with a motion sensor in the bath remote and a water-level sensor in the heater, sends an alarm to a smartphone app "when the set bathing time has passed" (our translation), and lets the person holding the phone make the bath remote call out to the bather, who answers by pressing a button. Corona's 2020 app for its EcoCute heaters sends a "long-bath notice" to a smartphone. Both are built around a second person: the alert goes to a family member's phone, so it helps only if someone else receives it and acts (both articles pitch it for watching over family from somewhere else; the Corona article names an elderly parent), and the articles describe it only for these heater models with their wireless-LAN remotes. Neither article mentions any limit on water temperature. No evaluation of these functions was found. Two other functions speak to the bather directly. Tokyo Gas and Purpose's "safe bathing support function" (安心入浴サポート機能; our translation), in a bath-and-kitchen remote set sold from August 2019, combines a motion sensor (developed from joint research with the Kyushu Institute of Technology), a door sensor and a water-level sensor; if the sensors detect no movement from the bather for a set time, for example when dozing, the bath remote calls out to the bather with a chime and voice, and if the bather does not respond the kitchen remote alerts family living in the home. The makers' release lists the heater models the remotes work with and says the function does not detect every accident. Noritz's 2023 ホッと湯上りモード, in its GT-C72 gas heaters sold as a set with the RC-K001W remote from 3 July 2023 (431,860 to 586,630 yen for the heater and 71,940 yen for the remote), detects when the bather gets into the tub from the change in water level, estimates the rise in core body temperature from the bathroom temperature and the water temperature (a body-heat model, HIITO, from joint research with Kobe and Kyushu Universities), and tells the bather by voice at the bath remote when to get out, between 5 and 20 minutes after getting in; Noritz does not publish how the time is worked out, calls it a guide, and says it does not necessarily prevent bathing accidents. Neither article, nor the makers' releases, reports a test with older bathers. (4) Water heaters and taps as a source of burns. In a review of ten patients aged 65 or over admitted for burns sustained in their own bathtubs over five years, the authors write that misoperation of the water heater or tap "stood out" (our translation), while also noting that how a bath burn began is often unclear because it rests on the patient's account. They call for better bathroom environments, monitoring tools for older people, and local government and welfare involvement (abstract read; the full text is behind a subscriber login). (5) Newer work on the mechanism (full texts read). Tai and colleagues (2026), in a forum (opinion) article rather than a new study (the authors disclose advisory contracts with the companies 日本中央住販 and 大和ハウス工業 and joint-research funding from 株式会社カネカ), argue that prevention has focused too much on "heat shock" from room-temperature gaps: by the reports they cite, heart attacks, strokes and similar diseases probably account for less than half of fatal bath accidents, and fewer than 10% of people rescued after being unable to get out of the tub had such a disease, while the rest recovered from impaired consciousness, high body temperature and fast heart rate once taken out of the heat. They call for strategies that prevent overheating in the bath and detect early when a bather can no longer get out alone. Where no one can watch, as for someone living alone, they suggest an automatic safety device as one example: it would recognise that someone is in the tub, play a voice prompt at set intervals, and drain the tub automatically if the bather does not answer; they add that whether it can be fitted to existing baths and what it costs are open questions, and this opinion article does not say that such a device has been built or tested. Tochihara and colleagues' 2026 English review keeps the cold-room account but adds that older bathers "do not perceive it as too hot and often bathe for long periods, resulting in hyperthermia." Both readings put soak time and water heat at the centre, both point to older bathers' weaker sense of temperature (Tai and colleagues say an age-related decline in temperature perception adds to the danger), and both call for warmer rooms before the bath; Tai and colleagues add early detection of a bather who cannot get out.

What would unlock progress

A way to keep the bath and the room within safe limits that does not depend on the bather's own sense of heat, cold or time, and does not depend on a second person watching. The review's evidence points to three things the bather cannot feel: water above about 41 °C, time in the water, and a cold changing room; the home measurements point most clearly to the cold room. A fourth problem, from the burns series, is controls that older people misoperate. Start from what is already sold: monitoring heaters already time the soak, and some speak to the bather (the Tokyo Gas and Purpose remote calls out when the bather stops moving; Noritz's 2023 system says when to get out, timed partly from bathroom temperature), but all are described only for particular heater models and remotes, none of the articles reports a test with older bathers, and none warms the room; a kitchen timer and a bath thermometer are what the agency suggests, with no evidence they are used. A fix might be a cheap, installation-free way to warm the changing room, a retrofit cue at the tub that the bather notices without a phone or a carer, or a simpler control, but each has to be usable by a person who feels no difference between 39 °C and 42 °C water.

How we’d know it’s being solved

(a) Measured water temperature and soak time per bath in older people's homes in winter, compared with the 41 °C and 10-minute guidance; (b) changing-room temperature at bath time compared with the 20–25 °C the review recommends; (c) in a usability test, the rate of correct operation of the bath controls by older users. Bath deaths and burns are the outcomes that matter but are too rare to measure in a small study.

Where to start

Facility-free door: survey what is already sold in Japan, starting from the Noritz, Corona and Tokyo Gas and Purpose monitoring functions above (water-heater control panels and their manuals, floating bath thermometers, bathroom and changing-room heaters, bath-monitoring sensors), noting for each who receives the signal (bather or family) and score each against the three things the review says older bathers cannot feel (water above 41 °C, soak time, room cold) and the burns series' misoperation finding; this tells a team where a new object would add something and where one already exists. Object door: design an object for the bather, not the carer, that makes temperature or soak time noticeable to someone who does not feel heat (for example, a cue at the tub edge, or a simpler control). It must differ from what the page and the survey show already exist: not a thermometer or timer the bather has to set and read (the agency already suggests those, with no evidence they are used), not a floating thermometer that flashes or beeps when the water is hot (already sold for babies' baths, with the warning preset at 39 °C; what these leave open is a warning set for an adult's bath, time in the water without setting a countdown each time, and the cold room), not an alert to a family member (the 2021 Noritz and Corona functions do that), and not another voice cue built into a heater's bath remote (the Tokyo Gas and Purpose remote and Noritz's 2023 get-out cue already speak to the bather). Start from what those leave open on the page's own evidence: they are described only for particular heater models and remotes (the Noritz 2023 system is sold as a heater-and-remote set), and none of the articles reports a test with older bathers; so the aim is a cue that works in an existing bath, without a new water heater, at low cost. Nor should it repeat the tub-draining device Tai and colleagues propose, which acts only once the bather has stopped answering; what that proposal leaves open is a cue that reaches the bather earlier, before they can no longer get out, and one that fits an existing bath at low cost (the fitting and cost questions the authors raise). It should work on its own once the bather is in, without a phone or a carer, and run on batteries; nothing mains-powered goes near water. Check that it works on a basin or bath of water with no one in it. Test it with people only as a dry mock-up and a dry role-play of the bath routine (no water, no cold room), with older adults reached through a senior centre near campus, for whether they notice and understand the cue; nobody gets into water to test it, and nothing goes home. What carries over from a US or European senior centre: the age-related loss of heat and temperature sense the review describes, and whether a cue is noticed and understood. What does not: the daily shoulder-deep winter soak and Japanese bath remotes, so a team should say that its testers do not bathe this way. Trial-design door: design, do not run, a winter home study that logs bath water temperature, soak time and changing-room temperature in older people's homes, with ethics review and a partner such as a municipal health office. Relevant skills: product and interaction design for ageing users, thermal sensing, building physics.

Genes

Related problems

Stuck the same way, in other fields.

field: society & learningthe senior gym few older australians useAustralian councils install park exercise equipment built for older people, but in two Melbourne parks under 3% of older visitors were seen using it, a randomised trial of QR codes and guided sessions did not raise use among people over 60, and the council programme that did raise it runs on weekly volunteer sessionsbuilt without the people who'd live with itsource: primaryfield: the built worldhydrogen at $5–7 a kilo, against a $1 targetThree hydrogen truck companies collapsed within four months, with clean hydrogen at $5–7 a kilogram against a $1 target and limited refuelingbuilt without the people who'd live with itsource: secondaryfield: food & the living worldthe machines exist, the burning continuesIndia subsidizes the machines to end crop residue burning — but 44,000-98,000 people still die annually because equipment access was never the only barrierbuilt without the people who'd live with itsource: secondaryfield: food & the living worldthe kilns changed, the workers didn'tIndia's 50,000 brick kilns must convert to cleaner technology by mandate — but 43% of converted kilns surveyed in bihar operate inefficiently because the workforce transition was never designedbuilt without the people who'd live with itsource: secondary

Sources

  • Tochihara Y, Hashiguchi N (栃原裕, 橋口暢子). "日本の冬季における高齢者の入浴死について" [Sudden Death during Bathing of the Elderly in Winter in Japan](総説). 人間と生活環境 28(2):53-64, 2021, doi:10.24538/jhesj.28.2_53, accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • 消費者庁「コラムVol.4 冬に増加する高齢者の事故に注意! ー 入浴中の溺水事故」, accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • 古荘晶子, 久保陽介, 吉野雄一郎. 「自宅浴槽で受傷した高齢者熱傷――自験例と過去5年間の集計――」. 西日本皮膚科 85(5):387-393, 2023, doi:10.2336/nishinihonhifu.85.387 (abstract), accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • 津田昌宏「ノーリツ、見守り機能を強化したふろ給湯器。長時間入浴すると離れた家族のスマホに通知」 家電 Watch, 2021-01-07, accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • 「コロナ、外出先から湯はり、家族の見守りができるスマホアプリ」 家電 Watch, 2020-05-14, accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • Tai Y, Obayashi K, Yamagami Y, Saeki K. "[Preventing Bathing-Related Accidents without Overemphasizing "Heat Shock": toward Prevention Strategies Centered on Heat-Related Illness]." Nihon eiseigaku zasshi. Japanese journal of hygiene 2026;81, doi:10.1265/jjh.25012 (citation via Europe PMC; full text read from the J-STAGE PDF), accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • Tochihara Y, Hashiguchi N, Loh PY. "Why do many elderly Japanese die suddenly during winter bathing?" International journal of biometeorology 2026;70:126, doi:10.1007/s00484-025-03086-0 (citation via Europe PMC; full text read through the library), accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • 株式会社ドリテック, product page "O-238デジタル湯温計「ガーくん」", accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • 株式会社 西松屋チェーン, "あひるの湯温計(時計付き)取扱説明書" (model TEM-900-Y), accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • 吉川朝彦「ノーリツ、業界初の除菌技術を備えた新給湯システム - 「のぼせ」を防ぐ機能にも注目!」 マイナビニュース, 2023/04/05, accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • ノーリツ ニュースリリース「業界初技術、除菌水を生成する"AQUA OZONE(アクアオゾン)"を用いたオゾン水除菌ユニットを搭載した高効率ガスふろ給湯器を7月3日発売」, 2023/04/05, accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • 加藤綾「入浴中の居眠りを感知してお知らせ。東京ガスとパーパスの給湯器リモコン」 Impress Watch, 2019年7月12日, accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • 東京ガス ニュース「「AXiS smart ステルスリモコンシリーズ」における安心入浴サポート機能を搭載した給湯器リモコンの共同開発について」, 2019年7月11日 (the list of compatible heater models is in the release's overview table, an image), accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
Revision notes

This brief gets checked against its sources and contains the following revisions. Future revisions get added here.

Worth knowing

  • No measure on this page has a controlled test; the case rests on laboratory perception data, how few homes heat the bathroom, and products with no reported test with older bathers.
  • How bath deaths happen is debated: one 2026 opinion article argues overheating in the water may matter more than a cold room.

Full check

Sources read

  • Tochihara and Hashiguchi, review of winter bath deaths of older people in Japan (2021): full text (read in Japanese)
  • Consumer Affairs Agency, column on bath drowning of older people: full text (read in Japanese)
  • Kaden Watch, Noritz bath-monitoring water heater (2021): full text (read in Japanese)
  • Kaden Watch, Corona bath-monitoring app (2020): full text (read in Japanese)
  • Mynavi News and Noritz's own release, bather-facing get-out cue (2023): full text (read in Japanese)
  • Impress Watch and Tokyo Gas's own release, safe-bathing support remote (2019): full text (read in Japanese)
  • Tai et al., opinion article on preventing bathing accidents (Japanese Journal of Hygiene, 2026): full text (read in Japanese)
  • Tochihara, Hashiguchi and Loh, review of sudden deaths during winter bathing (International Journal of Biometeorology, 2026): full text
  • Furusho, Kubo and Yoshino, bath burns in older people, hospital series (2023): abstract only (read in Japanese)
  • Dretec, product page for a digital bath thermometer: full text (a maker's page, read in Japanese)
  • Nishimatsuya, instruction sheet for a duck-shaped bath thermometer: full text (a maker's sheet, read in Japanese)

What changed

  • Not found in the sources, replaced with what they say: that both heater articles pitch the family alert for watching a parent; only one names an elderly parent, the other speaks of family living apart; that the monitoring heaters need a new heater; the articles say only that the functions are described for particular heater models and remotes; that both 2026 papers say the bather does not feel the water's heat; the opinion article says an age-related decline in temperature perception adds to the danger.
  • Contradicted by the source, corrected: that existing heaters send their alert only to a family member; two systems speak to the bather directly (one calls out when the bather stops moving, one says when to get out), and both are now on the page; where eight burns patients went after treatment: they were transferred to another hospital still needing rehabilitation or care.
  • Numbers: the home bathing measurements were from ten bathers, not a ten-home sample.
  • Dates: the Noritz heater was announced in January 2021 for sale from 1 March, not released in March.
  • Title: the long title's last clause now says the water-heater remotes that watch the bath, whether they alert family or tell the bather when to get out, are described only for particular heater models; it had said they alert a family member's phone (display title unchanged).
  • Entry points: the build starting point no longer asks for a bather-facing cue as if none existed; it rules out another voice cue built into a heater remote and aims at a low-cost cue for an existing bath.

Left open

  • the burns series' figures and its finding that misoperation of heaters and taps stood out [abstract only; the full text is behind a subscriber login]

Separate check of specific claims: The sizes of the three laboratory bathing tests behind the titles are now given: 8 to 11 older bathers in each.

Separate check of specific claims: Two bath thermometers that warn by themselves at 39 °C were added (one floats and is sold for babies' baths), the build starting point now rules them out, and the 2026 opinion article's funding disclosures were added.

Earlier full check: Nine details were corrected, including two swapped web addresses, the 2026 Japanese paper now called an opinion article, a 20-minute figure that was total bathing time rather than time in the tub, and a tub-draining device the opinion article proposes, now named and ruled out in the build starting point.

Separate check of specific claims: The build starting point now rules out a thermometer or timer, a family-phone alert and anything needing a new heater, and adds safety lines: the device is checked in water with no one in it, people handle only a dry mock-up, and nothing mains-powered goes near water.

Earlier full check: Both titles changed (display title 'Forty-Two Degrees Feels Like Nothing' → 'Forty-Two Degrees Feels Like Thirty-Nine'), bath deaths and burns were separated, home measurements pointing to the cold room as a larger gap were added, and water heaters that alert family were added as products already sold.