health · manufacturing
the pack left open on the washer
Packaging rules for laundry detergent pods were followed by fewer child poisonings, but eye injuries from detergent packets rose as a share of child eye-injury emergency visits at Canadian sentinel hospitals (about 17% a year, 2012–2022); a latched lid added in Italy showed no detectable effect, and an in-home study written and funded by Procter & Gamble found adults often did not reclose child-impeding packs
Source: Zutrauen et al., “Pediatric injuries and poisonings associated with detergent…” Open ↗source: primaryLast updated: 2026-11-17
Problem statement
Laundry detergent pods are small, soft, brightly coloured packets of concentrated detergent in a film that dissolves when wet. Young children mistake them for sweets or toys, bite or squeeze them, and get detergent in the mouth, airway or eyes. After the first serious cases, Italy required opaque outer packs with a child-impeding closure from 2013, and Europe made rules in 2014: opaque outer packs, an aversive agent to put children off, and a film that holds its liquid for 30 seconds in water and resists a set squeeze. North America adopted a voluntary standard (ASTM F3159) in 2015. Ingestions did fall. In Canada's sentinel hospital network, packet poisonings fell by about 15% a year from 2015 to 2022. In the US, serious outcomes in children under 6 fell by 44% and hospital admissions by 69% from 2014 to 2018. But in the same Canadian network, eye injuries from detergent packets rose by about 17% a year from 2012 to 2022, counted as a share of all children's eye-injury visits recorded there, and packet cases overall kept rising. In the US, the exposure rate in children under 6 rose again from 2018 to 2020 before easing. In Italy, an extra latch on the lid and a safe-storage campaign were followed by no detectable change. An in-home study written and funded by Procter & Gamble argues that child-impeding packs have become harder for adults to open. With sensors hidden in the packs, it found that most adults with young children did not always close them again within a minute. The unsolved problem is a pack and a pod that stay safe in the way busy carers actually do laundry, and that do not squirt into a child's eye when squeezed.
Why this matters
In Canada's hospital injury surveillance system (CHIRPP), 904 emergency visits by children and youth for detergent-packet injuries were recorded between April 2011 and October 2023. Of these, 86.5% were children aged 4 and under and 65 (7.2%) were admitted to hospital. Poisonings were 58.8% of diagnoses and eye injuries 30.6%. Eye injuries were on record early: a 2014 US report described 10 children seen in nine months with corneal injuries from liquid detergent pods (Gray and West 2014, abstract read). Squeezing or breaking a packet caused 32.3% of cases, and it was the most common way children aged 5 to 9 were hurt (73.3% of their cases). In Italy's national poison control centre series (September 2010 – June 2015), children under 5 exposed to pods were far more likely than those exposed to ordinary detergent to need hospital care (68% against 42%) and to have moderate or severe outcomes (13% against under 1%). Ten had severe outcomes, against none with ordinary detergent. The Canadian authors (all three at the Public Health Agency of Canada) also cite reports of exposures among older adults, including adults with dementia, and a US study in which detergent-packet exposures among older adults rose nearly fivefold, from 46 cases in 2012 to 219 in 2020 (the study's abstract calls this "over 400%"; by its own counts the rise is 376%).
What’s been tried and why it hasn’t worked
- Opaque packs: the measure with the clearest effect. In Italy, exposures to the main brand's pods fell sharply four months after it moved to opaque outer packs in August 2012: from 1.03 to 0.36 cases a day, and from 1.88 to 0.86 cases per million units sold. Exposures to other brands, counted in cases a day, fell again after opaque packs with a child-impeding closure became compulsory; counted per million units sold, no change was detected in the other brands' rate over the whole period. The authors conclude that hiding the pods may be an effective preventive measure. In the same series, the earlier measures, a harder-to-open latch added to the lid in January 2012 and a newspaper and magazine campaign in mid-2012, "were not followed by any detectable effect on exposure frequency".
- Rules on the pod and the pack. The EU's 2014 rules and the voluntary North American standard ASTM F3159 (2015) cover the pack (opaque in both; child-resistant in the ASTM standard) and the pod (an aversive agent or taste property, delayed dissolving, resistance to compression). The voluntary standard lets makers meet the child-resistant requirement in six different ways. It was updated in March 2022, and the update "did not substantially change its scope" (Nationwide Children's Hospital, 2024). The US Consumer Product Safety Commission's page for the standard still lists ASTM F3159-15 and "N/A" for rulemaking. A Health Canada market survey in 2018 found that the vast majority of products met it. Canadian poisonings from packets fell by 15.3% a year from 2015 to 2022, which the authors say may be partly due to awareness and these standards. Eye injuries rose by 16.6% a year from 2012 to 2022. These Canadian rates are per 100,000 injury cases in the CHIRPP hospitals (the eye-injury trend is per 100,000 eye-injury cases), not per head of population, and the eye-injury trend covers all detergent packets (81% of cases were laundry packets, 15% dishwasher). The US shows a similar split. Exposures relative to sales fell, but units sold tripled between 2012 and 2018, and one US poison-centre report found the population rate in children under 6 up 6.4% by 2020. A US national poison-centre analysis (Zhang et al. 2023, abstract only) found the rate in children under 6 rose 16.8% from 2018 to 2020, then fell 6.8% by 2022. Exposures in older children, teenagers and adults rose. US poison-centre calls about eye exposures to laundry packets rose 1,960% from 2012 to 2016 (Kamboj et al. 2020), but those years are when the product was spreading through the US market.
- Closures that adults leave open. The P&G study was sponsored and carried out by Procter & Gamble. Seven of its eight authors are P&G employees, and the eighth was paid a consultancy fee. It is the only read source on closing behaviour, so its claims are held to what its own sensor data show. It notes that since 2018 makers have been invited to adopt an industry agreement to meet a child-impeding closure certification. The authors write that such packs "also have become more difficult and time consuming for adult users to open as well", and that this "may actually lead to an increase in packs that are left open". That is the authors' argument; the study did not compare child-impeding packs with ordinary ones. They tested a new "Press & Lift" pack with an audible click against the existing "Pinch & Lift" pack. Study 1 had 99 adults in Germany, self-reported; Study 2 had 87 adults in the UK, with hidden sensors in the pack. The new pack did better: 41% of users closed it within a minute after every opening, against 15%. But that means most users did not always close even the new pack within a minute. The authors also cite a study of consumers who had had an incident. In it, children reached a pod about equally often from a pod left out, from a pack left open and from a closed pack. A better closure addresses only the second route.
- Advice to carers. Health Canada issued an advisory in 2012 and has also put out information through a webpage and social media. The Canadian authors find that, where the context was recorded (491 of the 904 cases), most children got to packets while playing, for example in a cupboard or under the sink, climbing onto a table, counter or shelf, or because a packet was left out or within reach. They conclude that these injuries remain "a persisting issue".
What would unlock progress
Several fixes are already built, and each leaves a gap. Opaque packs, an aversive agent or taste property, and delayed-dissolving film are in the EU rules and ASTM F3159; child-impeding closures are in ASTM F3159, in Italy's rules and in an industry agreement makers have been invited to join since 2018. Ingestions fell after them. But all of them assume the pack is closed and the pod is put away. A child-impeding closure does nothing while the pack is open. The P&G "Press & Lift" pack makes closing easier, and most users still did not always close it within a minute. The US poison-centre authors propose wrapping pods one by one and making them harder to burst (Kamboj et al. 2020). In the hospital's press release on the 2014–2022 US trends study (Nationwide Children's Hospital, 2024), the release and one of the study's authors, Gary Smith, ask for packs that meet the US child-resistant packaging law (the Poison Prevention Packaging Act), not the six-option voluntary standard, and, again, for each pod to be wrapped. Child-resistant packs that close with a click are also on offer to brands: Graphic Packaging's CleanClose paperboard box with ChildBlock (2025) is certified child-resistant under US 16 CFR 1700.20, and "an audible 'click' lets consumers know it is properly closed". Two big brands' own packs work the same way: Tide's Child-Guard tub has a "twist-and-click lid" that the adult twists back on "until you hear it click and lock into place", and Ariel's SECURECLIC box is closed "until you hear the 'click' sound". Like Press & Lift, each of these is safe only once the adult closes it. A P&G patent for a pinch-to-open tub lock (US 10,934,064) even allows a biasing system, such as an elastic member, that "biases the lid towards the open position". A one-pod-at-a-time childproof dispenser has been patented by an individual inventor (US 10,961,042, 2021): the user presses a handle to unlock it and turns it, a rotor dispenses a single pod, and springs return the lock to the locked position once the handle is released. No source read here shows that it is sold. None of these packs and dispensers touches the pod left out on the counter mid-load, or a pod squeezed by an older child. Wrapping each pod, as the US authors propose, could also protect a pod left out; no source read here reports a test of it. Two separate fixes follow. First, a pack whose safe state does not depend on the adult remembering to close it: for example, one that closes itself or will not stay open, and still opens quickly with wet hands. The P&G study shows that ease of closing changes behaviour, but only part of the way. Second, a pod or pod film that does not spray its contents when a child squeezes or bites it. The rules already set a compression requirement. No source read here tests whether it matches how children squeeze or bite pods, but eye injuries kept rising after it came in, so that is worth testing. Both need testing against how laundry is actually done: in kitchens (as in many UK homes in the P&G study), with pods left on the machine mid-load.
How we’d know it’s being solved
The primary measures are emergency visits and poison-centre calls for detergent-packet exposures in children under 5, split by ingestion and eye injury, as CHIRPP and national poison centres already count them. Where poison-centre data allow, report them per head of population as well as per unit sold, since sales have grown. CHIRPP counts are a share of sentinel-hospital cases and cannot give population rates. For smaller tests, the measures are the sensor-measured share of openings followed by closing within a minute, measured in homes and not by self-report; time to open and close with wet hands; and, on a bench rig, how much liquid a pod releases, and how far it travels, when squeezed or bitten the way children do. Self-reported closing is a weak stand-in: in the P&G study it agreed only modestly with the sensors (ρ = 0.34).
Where to start
Facility-free door (where pods actually sit): with adult volunteers in shared or student housing, do laundry-day observation diaries. Photographs record where the pack and loose pods are at the start, middle and end of each load: on the machine, the counter, an open pack. Map the moments when a child could reach a pod. This uses no product and no special facility, and it shows which of the three access routes a design would have to close.
Make-and-test door (a pack that will not stay open): child-impeding laundry packs are already sold; P&G has tested a "Press & Lift" pack in homes; a certified child-resistant paperboard box is offered to brands. The last two click when closed. All of them still depend on the adult closing them. A one-pod-at-a-time childproof dispenser whose springs relock it when the handle is released is patented (US 10,961,042), but no source read here shows it on sale, and in the patent the dispensed pod waits behind a hinged cover that the patent does not describe as locking or closing by itself. Make a pack or dispenser whose resting state is closed: for example, a spring-return lid, or a one-pod-at-a-time dispenser that relocks itself and, unlike that patent, also keeps the dispensed pod shut away until the adult takes it. State in one line how it differs from Press & Lift, from the click-closing paperboard box, from the click-closing tub and box that two brands already sell (Tide's Child-Guard tub, Ariel's SECURECLIC box) and from that patent. A web search in November 2026 did not find a sold pod pack whose lid closes by itself; the first week repeats the product and patent search, including in the countries where it will be tested. Test it with adults only: adults who do laundry, reached through campus laundry rooms, student family housing and staff who are parents of young children, or a local laundromat, with testing in a makerspace or a laundry room. Measure time to dispense with wet hands, failures, and whether it is still closed when left. Use empty pods or water-filled or gel-filled stand-ins, never detergent. No child takes part. Whether children can open it is a child-resistance panel test, which is a test lab's job: the team writes the protocol only, and any test involving children needs ethics review.
Bench door (squeeze and splash): on a bench rig with a load cell, compare how commercial pods (handled with gloves and eye protection, by a supervised team) and candidate film or pod geometries burst under a slow squeeze and a sharp pinch. Measure peak force, how far liquid sprays and the spray pattern, against the standard compression test the rules use. Set up and practise the rig with water-filled or gel-filled dummy pods; burst real pods only inside a closed clear enclosure, never toward anyone, with everyone present in eye protection. Have an eyewash station within reach, and check the plan with the lab's safety officer first. No person, and no child, is ever the squeezer.
Relevant skills: packaging and mechanical design, human factors, materials testing, injury epidemiology.
Genes
Related problems
Stuck the same way, in other fields.
field: making & materialsthe fire hiding in the recycling binLithium batteries hidden inside everyday products are burning down recycling facilities — and no sorting line can reliably find them before the shredderbuilt without the people who'd live with itsource: primaryfield: the built worldcalibrated, but is it right?After a repair, shops have no settled way to prove the car's crash-avoidance sensors work as designed again — about half of owners who had these features repaired report problems afterwardbuilt without the people who'd live with itsource: secondaryfield: society & learningthe phone ban that lives in the backpackBrazil's 2025 law restricts students' phones in every school; a year on most schools keep the phone in the student's backpack, public high schools report storage as a top difficulty, and studies in England and Iceland found no wellbeing gain from school phone restrictionsbuilt without the people who'd live with itsource: primaryfield: water & energywhere the sludge goes, nobody counts43% of the world uses pits and septic tanks, but data on whether the sludge is ever treated covers only 1% of the global population — the faecal-sludge accounting gapbuilt without the people who'd live with itsource: primarySources
- Sarah Zutrauen, James Cheesman, Steven R. McFaull, "Pediatric injuries and poisonings associated with detergent packets: results from the Canadian Hospitals Injury Reporting and Prevention Program (CHIRPP), 2011–2023", Injury Epidemiology 11: 31, 2024, doi:10.1186/s40621-024-00513-5, accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
- Laura Settimi, Felice Giordano, Laura Lauria, Anna Celentano, Fabrizio Sesana, Franca Davanzo, "Surveillance of paediatric exposures to liquid laundry detergent pods in Italy", Injury Prevention 24(1), 2018, doi:10.1136/injuryprev-2016-042263, accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
- Annalise Richmond, David C. Schwebel, Clara Ng Pak Leung, Elke Vallez, Heidi Lesage, Raf Degeyter, Zhiwu Liang, Gerard Stijntjes, "Comparing closure compliance and ease of use for consumer product packs designed to reduce access to children", PLoS One 19(4): e0284346, 2024, doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0284346, accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
- Alisha Kamboj, Henry A. Spiller, Marcel J. Casavant, Sandhya Kistamgari, Thitphalak Chounthirath, Gary A. Smith, "Household cleaning product-related ocular exposures reported to the United States poison control centres", Eye 34(9): 1631–1639, 2020, doi:10.1038/s41433-019-0691-9, accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
- Zhang AM, Smith GA, Casavant MJ, Kistamgari S, Gaw CE, "Longitudinal trends in liquid laundry detergent packet exposures: 2014-2022", Clinical Toxicology 61(11): 990–998, 2023, doi:10.1080/15563650.2023.2287977, abstract only, accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
- Aldy K, Du T, Weaver MM, Roth B, Cao DJ, "Seniors and single-use detergent sacs (SUDS): a review of the National Poison Data System from 2012 to 2020", Clinical Toxicology 60(9): 1039–1043, 2022, doi:10.1080/15563650.2022.2074856, abstract only, accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
- Gray ME, West CE, "Corneal injuries from liquid detergent pods", Journal of American Association for Pediatric Ophthalmology and Strabismus 18(5): 494–495, 2014, doi:10.1016/j.jaapos.2014.05.006, abstract only, accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
- Nationwide Children's Hospital, "New Study Finds Liquid Laundry Detergent Packet Exposure Burden among Young Children Remains; Increase in Exposures among Older Children, Teens, and Adults" (news release, January 22, 2024), accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
- US Consumer Product Safety Commission, voluntary standards page for liquid laundry packets (read in an archive copy of 2026-06-15), accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
- Graphic Packaging, "Graphic Packaging Achieves Child-Resistant Certification for CleanClose™ Paperboard Laundry Detergent Pod Packaging with ChildBlock™" (press release, August 13, 2025), and product page "CleanClose™ Laundry and Dish Detergent Packaging", accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗ Link 2 ↗
- US 10,934,064 B2, "Consumer product that includes a container and unit dose articles" (The Procter & Gamble Company; granted 2021-03-02), accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
- US 10,961,042 B1, "Laundry detergent pod dispensing container" (Julius K. Nganga; granted 2021-03-30), accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
- Tide (Procter & Gamble), home safety tips page with the Tide PODS® Child-Guard™ Tub, accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
- Ariel (Procter & Gamble), SECURECLIC® box page, accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
Revision notes
This brief gets checked against its sources and contains the following revisions. Future revisions get added here.
Worth knowing
- The Canadian rises and falls are shares of visits recorded at a set of sentinel hospitals, not rates per head of population.
- The only study of whether adults close the packs again was written and funded by Procter & Gamble.
Full check
Sources read
- Zutrauen et al., detergent-packet injuries in Canada's hospital surveillance (Injury Epidemiology, 2024): full text
- Settimi et al., pod exposures in Italy (Injury Prevention, 2018): full text
- Richmond et al., closing child-impeding packs (PLoS One, 2024): full text (written and funded by Procter & Gamble)
- Kamboj et al., eye exposures to household cleaning products (Eye, 2020): full text
- Zhang et al., laundry packet exposure trends 2014–2022 (Clinical Toxicology, 2023): abstract only
- Aldy et al., older adults and detergent pods (Clinical Toxicology, 2022): abstract only
- Day et al., UK poison-service exposures (Clinical Toxicology, 2019): abstract only (no figure from it is used)
- Nationwide Children's Hospital, news release on the US trends study (2024): full text
- Graphic Packaging, child-resistant paperboard pod box release and product page (2025): full text
- US patent 10,961,042, one-pod dispensing container: full text (the pages used)
- US patent 10,934,064, Procter & Gamble pod container: full text (the pages used)
- US CPSC, voluntary standards page for liquid laundry packets: full text (from an archived copy; the live page refused access)
What changed
- Not found in the sources, replaced with what they say: in the bench starting point, a 'single compression figure' in the rules; no source gives one, so it now refers to the standard compression test the rules use.
- Stated more strongly than the source: that the Italian authors conclude hiding the pods works; they say reducing visibility 'may be an effective preventive measure'.
- Numbers: how children got to the packets: 'most' now refers to the 491 of 904 cases with a recorded context, in which most children were playing; a cupboard, climbing and a packet left out are the paper's examples, not most cases; the further fall in other brands' exposures in Italy is now given in cases a day only; per million units sold, no change was detected.
- Credit: the Canadian paper's authors are now given as the Public Health Agency of Canada, not Health Canada.
Left open
- the US trend figures for children under 6 and the rise among older adults [taken from study abstracts; the full papers could not be read]
- the 2014 report of ten children with corneal injuries [abstract only]
Separate check of specific claims: The bench entry point now asks for an eyewash station within reach and a check of the plan with the lab's safety officer, and the page now says the Canadian paper's three authors work at the Public Health Agency of Canada.
Separate check of specific claims: Two click-closing packs sold by Procter & Gamble brands (Tide's tub and Ariel's box) and a 2014 report of ten children with corneal injuries were added; the older-adult figure now gives the study's own counts, 46 cases in 2012 and 219 in 2020; two sentences now say the eye-injury rise is a share of children's eye-injury visits; a claim about wrapping pods was toned down to what the authors say; and citations were added to the source list.
Earlier full check: Eleven details were corrected, including which packaging rules were Italy's and which Europe's, the age group most often hurt by squeezing a packet, who called for wrapped pods and stricter packaging, the first author's name, that a pack described as sold has only been tested in homes, and that the patented one-pod dispenser relocks itself when its handle is released, which the build starting point now builds on.
Separate check of specific claims: A search for existing products added a certified click-closing paperboard pod box, two patents for pod containers, the 2022 update to the US voluntary standard and the US regulator's page showing no rulemaking, with matching items in the build starting point.
Separate check of specific claims: Entry points: adult testers and how to reach them were named, stand-in pods replace detergent, child-resistance testing is left to a test lab with the team writing the protocol only, and safety lines were added to the bench test.
Earlier full check: The long title was rewritten to what the sources support: it names Procter & Gamble as writer and funder of the in-home study and gives the eye-injury rise as a 'Share of Child Eye-Injury Emergency Visits' at Canadian sentinel hospitals (display title unchanged); a quotation was corrected, what fell is now given beside what rose, and US poison-centre figures replaced a general claim about the US.