education · health
the phone ban that lives in the backpack
Brazil's 2025 law restricts students' phones in every school; a year on most schools keep the phone in the student's backpack, public high schools report storage as a top difficulty, and studies in England and Iceland found no wellbeing gain from school phone restrictions
Source: Ministério da Educação, “Pesquisa Nacional — 1º ano da Lei nº 15.100/2025…” Open ↗source: primaryLast updated: 2026-11-17
Problem statement
Since January 2025, Brazilian law (Lei nº 15.100/2025, signed on 13 January and in force from its publication in the official gazette on 14 January) restricts students' use of personal phones in every school of basic education, public and private, during classes, recess and breaks, with exceptions for teaching purposes, accessibility, inclusion, health conditions and the guarantee of rights. The law leaves it to each school to decide what to do with the phones. A year later, the Ministry of Education's national survey of school heads (2,469 valid answers from a probability sample of 8,189 schools, March–April 2026) found that 92% of schools say they are implementing it. The most common way of storing phones is "também a mais simples: guardar o celular na mochila do estudante" ("also the simplest: keeping the phone in the student's backpack"; our translation): 62% of schools overall and 75% of public schools that offer upper-secondary (ensino médio). Dedicated storage is rare (individual lockers outside the classroom 10%, a box or cabinet in the classroom 15%). In 21% of schools overall, and 28% of public upper-secondary schools, the phone stays in the student's pocket or on the desk; the report says this share means that for part of the schools "a restrição de uso não se traduz necessariamente em separação física entre o estudante e o aparelho" ("the restriction on use does not necessarily translate into physical separation between the student and the device"; our translation). Heads of public schools that offer upper-secondary most often rate winning students' adherence (55%) and storage infrastructure (52%) as high difficulties. In Brazil itself, a study of Rio de Janeiro's 2023–24 municipal ban found that, in middle schools that had no strict rule before, in-school phone use fell and test scores rose (by 0.06 standard deviations, compared with similar schools that already had strict rules), even though in most schools students who brought phones kept them in their backpacks or pockets; two of the five principals interviewed said container boxes their schools adopted after the ban helped cut use further. Studies abroad add a second problem. In England and Iceland, schools with restrictions showed no better wellbeing than comparison schools (in England even where phones were out of reach); in South Australia, ban schools did no better than non-ban schools on problematic phone use, engagement or belonging after one month; and in the Netherlands whole-grounds bans did no better on wellbeing than classroom-only bans. The unsolved problem is what a poorly resourced public high school can physically do with a classroom's worth of phones, every day, in a way older teenagers accept, and whether separation of that kind changes anything that matters to them.
Why this matters
Brazil applies one national phone rule across a very large school system (the ministry survey's estimated universe is about 116,600 schools, about 91,100 of them public), and the difficulties are heaviest in the public schools. Public school heads rate storage infrastructure as a high difficulty far more often than private ones (45% against 18%), and among public schools the share rises with age: 31% (early primary), 46% (lower secondary), 52% (upper secondary). Winning students' adherence follows the same climb (25%, 46%, 55%), as does continuous enforcement during classes and breaks (18%, 33%, 47%). In public schools whose heads say implementation is not yet consolidated, 72% report high difficulty with storage and 70% with adherence. Behaviour has moved: the share of 9–17-year-old internet users who went online at school fell from 51% in 2024 to 37% in 2025 (TIC Kids Online Brasil, which places the fall in the context of the law without testing cause). The heads' own views of the law are very positive (97% see more participation in class, 86% less anxiety), but the report itself warns that these are "avaliações declaradas por gestores, sem mensuração objetiva de indicadores de aprendizagem, saúde mental ou convivência" ("assessments stated by school heads, without objective measurement of learning, mental-health or social indicators"; our translation). A recorded measure comes from São Paulo state: cases of phone use logged by the state education secretariat on its Conviva-SP platform fell from about 24,000 in February 2025 to under 6,000 in October (75%), as reported in the press; this counts incidents logged, not learning or wellbeing.
What’s been tried and why it hasn’t worked
(1) A national rule without a storage method. Brazil's law leaves the method to each school. The national education council's guidelines (Resolução CNE/CEB nº 2 of 21 March 2025, published 24 March 2025) list three accepted forms: with the student, in an individual locker, the student's backpack, or a bag or similar item that can be sealed, "desde que fique inacessível pelo estudante durante todo o período de permanência na escola" ("provided it stays inaccessible to the student for the whole time at school"; our translation); lockers, collection boxes or compartments in the classroom under the teacher's supervision; or the same elsewhere in the school on arrival. The choice is left to school systems and schools according to "sua infraestrutura, cultura institucional e as necessidades dos estudantes" ("its infrastructure, institutional culture and students' needs"; our translation), and signal blocking is advised against. The resolution sets no storage funding, and the ministry's report does not say whether the backpacks it counts are sealed or out of reach. São Paulo's state law asks schools to keep phones away from pupils, and Rio Grande do Sul's state order leaves storage procedures to each school community; neither page mentions money for storage. Schools mostly chose the simplest, low-cost option, the backpack, and the report links the low-control storage to the difficulties it records with enforcement and adherence. Schools that prepared more (updated rules, listened to families and students, trained staff) reported more consolidated implementation. (2) Restrictions where phones stay in bags, abroad. In England's SMART Schools study (1,227 pupils aged 12–15 in 30 schools), pupils in restrictive schools spent about 40 minutes less on phones and about 30 minutes less on social media during the school day, but wellbeing did not differ (adjusted mean difference −0.48 on WEMWBS, 95% CI −2.05 to 1.06), nor did total weekday or weekend use. Most restrictive schools there also required phones to be kept off in bags, and the authors found no difference even where phones were inaccessible (lockers, pouches, reception). In Iceland, schoolwide bans in 22 of 70 schools were not associated with meaningful changes in depressive symptoms, anxiety, hostility or mental wellbeing (23,938 observations from 70 schools, difference-in-differences); the authors conclude that bans "implemented in isolation may be insufficient" to improve adolescent mental health. In South Australia, ban and non-ban schools did not differ on problematic phone use, engagement or belonging after one month, and older students and heavier social-media users complied less. In the Netherlands, where a national ban started in January 2024, full bans (whole school grounds) showed no wellbeing or bullying benefit over classroom-only bans, and were linked to lower student–teacher connectedness and, for girls, lower school belonging. (3) Physically binding storage. In the United States, lockable magnetic pouches (Yondr) cut on-campus phone activity by about 30% in GPS pings by the third year. But suspensions rose by about 15% in the adoption year (fading later), student-reported wellbeing dipped in the adoption year and then rebounded, turning positive by the second year (a pattern the authors call suggestive), test-score effects were close to zero on average (modest gains in high schools, small losses in middle schools), and there was no clear gain in attention or online bullying. An Australian study notes that such pouches "cost schools many thousands of dollars." (4) Brazil's own forerunner, Rio de Janeiro. Rio banned non-pedagogical phone use in classrooms in August 2023 and school-wide in February 2024, with phones stored "in dedicated container boxes, where available, or in students' backpacks." Comparing middle schools (grades 6–9) that had no strict rule before with similar schools that did, Lichand and colleagues found that in-school phone use fell substantially in the former and that an index of maths and Portuguese test scores rose there by 0.06 standard deviations relative to the latter (significant at the 5% level), a positive finding that stands; the authors note the design does not measure a ban against no ban, and their phone-use measures are principals' retrospective reports. Enforcement stayed imperfect: when students brought phones, they usually kept them in backpacks or pockets (95.1% of treatment schools, 87.3% of control), and 83.4% of principals reported implementation difficulties, especially during breaks. One principal said many students kept phones in pockets rather than backpacks and asked to go to the restroom to use them; two said their schools adopted container boxes after the ban, which helped reduce use further (interviews with five principals).
What would unlock progress
A way of separating students from phones that a public school with no budget for lockers can run daily, that older students accept rather than evade, and that still allows the uses schools permit (emergencies, health, a teacher's planned lesson). A US interview study of 30 students aged 16–19 (Bisom-Rapp et al. 2026) found that phone access felt protective in unsafe schools and that some students met their need for autonomy by defying the rules, so quick, visible emergency access is part of acceptance, not an extra. In Rio the rule went with lower phone use and higher test scores relative to comparison schools while phones mostly stayed in backpacks or pockets, though use stayed relatively high, and two principals said boxes cut use further; that study did not compare storage methods. The evidence from abroad says separation alone may not improve wellbeing, so the honest target is narrower: make the rule the school has adopted workable and fair (less policing by teachers, fewer conflicts, no theft or damage worries), and make it possible to test whether physical separation, not just the rule, changes attention and conflict in Brazilian classrooms. The Dutch finding suggests the design should keep, not spend, the student–teacher relationship.
How we’d know it’s being solved
(a) Fewer public upper-secondary heads rating storage, adherence and enforcement as high difficulties in the ministry's next round (against 52%, 55% and 47%). (b) Fewer schools where the phone stays in the pocket or on the desk (against 28% of public upper-secondary schools). (c) Measured, not perceived, outcomes: time lost to phone conflicts per class, disciplinary incidents in the first year (the US pouch study shows a first-year rise to watch for), and students' own ratings of fairness and autonomy. (d) Only after that, attention and wellbeing measures against comparison schools. Beware the proxy: "schools implementing the law" (92%) is the easiest figure to grow and says nothing about whether phones are out of reach.
Where to start
Facility-free door: using only the ministry's report (its storage charts 2.3a–b, difficulty chart 2.5a and priorities in 4.1), the Rio de Janeiro study and the studies from abroad, build a comparison of the storage options schools already use (backpack, handing in at reception, a classroom box, individual lockers, lockable pouches) on cost, staff time per day, control, student autonomy, theft and damage risk, and emergency access. Then write a one-page storage guide a Brazilian public upper-secondary school head could follow with no new budget, with a plain account of what the evidence from Rio and from abroad does and does not promise. No contact with schools or students is needed. Make door: design and build a low-cost classroom phone store that students operate themselves, for one class at a time: each student can see their own phone is safe, a teacher can release one phone fast for an emergency or a planned lesson, and the unit can be made from cheap local materials. Already built and sold: classroom pocket organisers and boxes (15% of Brazilian schools use a box or cabinet in the room), classroom phone cabinets with a separately keyed slot for each phone, individual lockers (10%), reception hand-in (33%), and lockable magnetic pouches that are opened at magnetic bases around the school. A student-run store has also been reported: a 2012 Associated Press story carried by Education Week describes a Philadelphia high school where "students operate a cellphone-storage room where phones can be dropped off in the morning at no charge and picked up after school"; that is a single storage room at the school, not a store inside each classroom, and the story says nothing on how well it worked. In Brazil, numbered steel phone cabinets with a key per door are sold online (a 32-door unit listed at R$2,048, about R$64 a phone by our own division of the listed price; a 10-door unit listed at R$1,435, out of stock when checked), and a 2023 Brazilian press account put lockable pouches at US$15–30 each (about R$75–150). Far cheaper wall units are on offer through a wholesale import marketplace in Portuguese: a 24-slot wall-mounted phone case with a single lock at US$7–9 (minimum order 100), 24- or 36-slot classroom phone lockers at US$12.91–14.71 (minimum 300), and numbered hanging pocket organisers at US$3.51–4.54 a set (minimum 4); these are wholesale listings, not prices a Brazilian school would pay delivered. The case for a new store rests on two documented things: heads of public upper-secondary schools rate storage infrastructure a high difficulty (52%), and in Rio two principals said container boxes adopted after the city's ban helped reduce use further. It does not rest on the backpack failing outright: in Rio phone use fell and test scores rose relative to comparison schools while phones mostly stayed in backpacks or pockets, though the authors add that use stayed relatively high and implementation highly imperfect; and the national council's guidelines accept the backpack where the phone stays out of the student's reach. Start from what each leaves unsolved, and design against those gaps: pouches and lockers cost money, and public school heads rate storage infrastructure a high difficulty far more often than private ones (45% against 18%) (an Australian study notes pouches "cost schools many thousands of dollars"; a 32-pupil class would need R$2,048 for the cabinet above) and US pouch schools saw a first-year rise in suspensions; and the backpack keeps the phone with the student, where the report sees a self-control challenge for older students in the phone's mere presence and persistent notifications. Three further gaps are design targets for the team, not findings from the sources: hand-in at a front office can make a queue at the start and end of the day; an open organiser can leave students worried about theft and mix-ups and still needs a teacher to police it; and a keyed slot for each phone means a key per student to hand out and keep. The new store must cost well under the lockable options (below about R$64 a phone, our division of the 32-door cabinet's listed price per slot) and stay close to what an open or single-lock wall organiser costs, since such organisers are already listed at under US$10 per 24-slot unit at wholesale, so the team's gain must come from trust and handling, not price alone; it must also empty faster than a front-office queue, be trusted more than an open organiser, and need no key per student, with deposit and retrieval in students' hands inside the classroom. Test it with university students in a seminar or lecture, recruited openly on campus, as stand-ins: time to deposit and retrieve a full class, mix-ups, how safe people feel leaving a phone, and whether they would rather keep it in the bag. What carries over: handling time, errors, perceived safety. What does not: how 15–17-year-olds who object to the rule would behave, or how a teacher in a Brazilian public school would run it day to day; school pupils are not tested at this stage; any test with pupils is designed, not run, under the ethics line in the partner door. Partner door (design the trial, don't run it): with a public upper-secondary school that now uses the backpack method, design a comparison of backpack storage against the classroom store across matched classes, with pre-registered outcomes (conflicts, teacher time spent enforcing, students' fairness ratings). Access note: any study with school students is with minors and needs ethics review, parental consent and the school's agreement. Relevant skills: product and service design, low-cost fabrication, education policy, survey methods; Portuguese for the primary source.
Genes
Related problems
Stuck the same way, in other fields.
field: making & materialsthe fire hiding in the recycling binLithium batteries hidden inside everyday products are burning down recycling facilities — and no sorting line can reliably find them before the shredderbuilt without the people who'd live with itsource: primaryfield: health & medicinethe noise inside the boxIncubators are meant to shield preterm babies from neonatal-unit noise, but respiratory support inside the incubator can be among the loudest sources, and in a simulation study jet CPAP peaked in the band where preterm hearing is most sensitive — while ward-level quieting rarely lastsbuilt without the people who'd live with itsource: primaryfield: making & materialssolar glass no furnace wantsSixty to seventy percent of a solar panel is glass, and the antimony added to make it clearer keeps that glass out of float furnaces — so "recycled" glass goes to lower-quality usesbuilt without the people who'd live with itsource: secondaryfield: health & medicinetwo weeks in the freezerMailed frozen meals are a lower-cost way to feed homebound people with dementia, but the person must store, pick and reheat two weeks of them; in a US pilot trial, daily delivered meals did not significantly lower nursing-home placement compared with frozen meals, and interviews with nine recipients and seven caregivers found problems storing the boxes and knowing when they would arrivebuilt without the people who'd live with itsource: primarySources
- Ministério da Educação, "Pesquisa Nacional — 1º ano da Lei nº 15.100/2025. Relatório técnico sobre a implementação da lei que restringe o uso de aparelhos eletrônicos portáteis pessoais para fins não pedagógicos nas escolas da educação básica. Gestores." (Ministério da Educação (SEB/MEC), Inep, Instituto Alana, UNESCO), 2026, accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
- Goodyear VA, Randhawa A, Adab P, Al-Janabi H, Fenton S, Jones K, Michail M, Morrison B, Patterson P, Quinlan J, Sitch A, Twardochleb R, Wade M, Pallan M. "School phone policies and their association with mental wellbeing, phone use, and social media use (SMART Schools): a cross-sectional observational study." Lancet Reg Health Eur 2025, doi:10.1016/j.lanepe.2025.101211, accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
- Bonilla Aparicio E, Sigmarsdottir B, Haskell E, Sirotina U, Sveinbjornsdottir B, Asgeirsdottir BB, Valdimarsdottir HB, Odgers CL, Sigfusdottir ID, Allegrante JP, Halldorsdottir T. "School Phone Bans and Adolescent Mental Health in Iceland." JAMA Netw Open 2026, doi:10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2026.40893, accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
- Vanluydt E, van den Eijnden R, Vonk L, Putrik P, van Amelsvoort T, Delespaul P, Levels M, Huijts T. "Disconnect To Reconnect: How Variations between Types of Smartphone Bans Influence Students' Well-being and Social Connectedness in Dutch Secondary Education." J Youth Adolesc 2026, doi:10.1007/s10964-025-02313-6, accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
- Allcott H, Baron J, Dee T, Gentzkow M, Duckworth AL, Jacob B. "The Effects of School Phone Bans: National Evidence from Lockable Pouches." Working paper, August 2026, accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
- King DL, Radunz M, Galanis CR, Quinney B, Wade T. "“Phones off while school's on”: Evaluating problematic phone use and the social, wellbeing, and academic effects of banning phones in schools." J Behav Addict 2024;13(4):913-922, doi:10.1556/2006.2024.00058, accessed 2026-11-17; Núcleo de Informação e Coordenação do Ponto BR (NIC.br). TIC Kids Online Brasil 2025: Pesquisa sobre o uso da Internet por crianças e adolescentes no Brasil. Comitê Gestor da Internet no Brasil, São Paulo, 2026, ISBN 978-65-6165-007-6, accessed 2026-11-17; Ministério da Educação/Conselho Nacional de Educação/Câmara de Educação Básica. "Resolução CNE/CEB nº 2, de 21 de março de 2025. Institui as Diretrizes Operacionais Nacionais sobre o uso de dispositivos digitais em espaços escolares e integração curricular de educação digital e midiática." Diário Oficial da União, 24/03/2025, Edição 56, Seção 1, p. 34 (copy of the DOU page), accessed 2026-11-17; Lichand G, Moreno-Louzada L, da Costa T, Gentzkow M. "The Educational Impacts of School Phone Bans: Evidence from Brazil." Working paper, May 13, 2026, accessed 2026-11-17; Bisom-Rapp E, Otmar CD, Potes C, Nayak S, Engle K, Ganson KT, Nagata JM. "The Need for Autonomy, Safety, and Structure: A Qualitative Study of Adolescent Perspectives on School Phone Restrictions." Academic Pediatrics 26(5):103333, 2026, doi:10.1016/j.acap.2026.103333 (full text read through library access), accessed 2026-11-17; Metrópoles. "Em 8 meses, ocorrências por uso de celular caem 75% em escolas de SP", 8 December 2025, accessed 2026-11-17; Governo do Estado do Rio Grande do Sul. "Governo orienta escolas sobre implementação da lei que restringe uso de dispositivos eletrônicos no ambiente escolar", accessed 2026-11-17; Fast Company Brasil. "Que tal essa? Bolsas impedem o uso de smartphones em eventos e escolas", accessed 2026-11-17; MadeiraMadeira, shop listing "Armário para Celular 32 Portas Numerado 100x83x28 Cm com Chave", accessed 2026-11-17; The Associated Press. "N.Y.C. Teens Pay Valets to Store Cellphones During School Hours." Education Week, 16 October 2012, accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗ Link 2 ↗ Link 3 ↗ Link 4 ↗ Link 5 ↗ Link 6 ↗ Link 7 ↗ Link 8 ↗ Link 9 ↗
Revision notes
This brief gets checked against its sources and contains the following revisions. Future revisions get added here.
Worth knowing
- the national survey heard only from school heads; their very positive views of the law are their own assessments, which the report says were not measured against learning or wellbeing
- the Rio de Janeiro result compares schools that had no strict phone rule before the ban with schools that already had one, not a ban against no ban
Full check
Sources read
- Ministry of Education, Inep, Instituto Alana and UNESCO, national survey of school heads on the first year of Lei 15.100 (2026): full text (read in Portuguese, in the sections the page draws on)
- Lei nº 15.100/2025: full text
- National education council, Resolução CNE/CEB nº 2/2025: full text (the storage articles read word by word)
- NIC.br, TIC Kids Online Brasil 2025: full text (the passage on internet use at school)
- Lichand et al., school phone bans in Rio de Janeiro (working paper, 2026): full text (read in the parts the page draws on)
- Allcott et al., school phone bans with lockable pouches (working paper, 2026): full text
- Goodyear et al., SMART Schools study (Lancet Regional Health Europe, 2025): full text
- Bonilla Aparicio et al., school phone bans in Iceland (JAMA Network Open, 2026): full text
- Vanluydt et al., types of phone bans in Dutch secondary schools (Journal of Youth and Adolescence, 2026): full text
- King et al., phone ban study in South Australia (Journal of Behavioral Addictions, 2024): full text
- Bisom-Rapp et al., interview study of adolescents on school phone rules (Academic Pediatrics, 2026): full text
- Goodyear et al., SMART Schools case study (Social Science & Medicine, 2026): abstract only (abstract and methods; not used on the page)
- Metrópoles, report on phone-use cases in São Paulo state schools (2025): full text
- Rio Grande do Sul state government, guidance to schools on the law: full text
- O Liberal, report on the council's three storage forms (2025): full text
- Fast Company Brasil, report on lockable pouches (2023): full text
- Two Brazilian shop listings for phone cabinets and one wholesale listing for phone organisers: full text
- Agência Brasil, report on the ministry survey (2026): full text
What changed
- Not found in the sources, replaced with what they say: the make project said public schools lack the money for pouches and lockers; no source says so, and the project now gives the report's figure instead: storage is a high difficulty for 45% of public school heads against 18% of private ones.
- Stated more strongly than the source: the backpack was called the cheapest option; the report calls it the simplest, among low-cost options, and does not rank options by cost; the make project said the report finds a phone in a backpack still pulls at students; the report speaks of a self-control challenge for older students in the phone's mere presence and persistent notifications, and the project now says that.
- Entry points: the make project now says what the case for a new classroom store rests on (52% of public upper-secondary heads rate storage a high difficulty, and two Rio principals said container boxes cut use further) and that it does not rest on the backpack failing outright, since in Rio phone use fell and test scores rose relative to comparison schools while phones mostly stayed in backpacks or pockets, though use stayed relatively high; the make project adds that any test with pupils is designed, not run, under the partner project's ethics line; the guide-writing starting point now draws on the Rio de Janeiro study as well as the national report and the studies from abroad.
- Other: What Would Unlock Progress now carries the Rio result, with the authors' remark that use stayed relatively high and that the study did not compare storage methods, so that it agrees with the problem statement.
Left open
None noted in this check.
Separate check of specific claims: A student-run phone storage room reported at a Philadelphia high school was added to the make project as an earlier attempt, with a note that the report gives no outcome, and citations for the interview study and the Brazilian press, government and shop pages the page already used were added to the source list.
Earlier full check: Fourteen fixes: the law's start now follows the official gazette record, the Rio result is given in full relative to comparison schools, an unsupported claim about the make-up of Brazil's school system was replaced with the ministry's school counts, the council's storage options are quoted exactly, per-phone prices are marked as our own division, and the long title no longer sets the backpack against the law (display title unchanged).
Separate check of specific claims: A search for existing products added Brazilian prices for phone cabinets and pouches and wholesale prices for wall organisers, the national council's storage guidelines, the positions of São Paulo and Rio Grande do Sul states, a logged fall in phone-use cases in São Paulo schools, and the study of Rio de Janeiro's own phone ban.
Separate check of specific claims: The make project now names classroom phone cabinets with a keyed slot per phone as already sold, states its design targets as targets rather than findings, and says what testing with university students cannot show.
Earlier full check: Every survey figure was checked against the ministry's report; a causal claim that the law changed behaviour was softened, the screen-time, Icelandic and pouch-study results were stated more exactly, and the long title was narrowed so that only the English and Icelandic studies are said to have found no wellbeing gain (display title unchanged).