play · education · health
convinced, but not yet changed
Online risk-reframing training raised mothers' and childcare educators' tolerance of risky play in two Canadian trials but showed no significant effect on their self-reported goal attainment, and a four-part pilot programme in eight Greater Vancouver childcare centres found no change in children's outdoor play participation
Source: Brussoni et al., “Evaluation of the Web-Based OutsidePlay-ECE Intervention to…” Open ↗source: primaryLast updated: 2026-11-12
Problem statement
Adults decide how much risky outdoor play young children get: climbing high, going fast, playing out of sight, using tools and loose materials. A qualitative systematic review of nine studies found that adults' attitudes and beliefs about adventurous play, health-and-safety worries and concerns about legislation are key barriers in schools. A Canadian research group built "risk-reframing" tools to change those adult attitudes, tested them in randomised trials, and then built the fuller fix — a four-part programme for childcare centres. The results show the gap between persuading adults and changing what children do. The web-based OutsidePlay tool raised mothers' tolerance of risky play (451 mothers randomised) and early childhood educators' tolerance (563 participants), with the web-version effect in mothers and the educator effect both still present at 3 months; but neither trial's authors found a significant effect on whether participants reported achieving the concrete practice goal they had set themselves (a yes/no self-report). The PRO-ECO trial (eight YMCA childcare centres in Greater Vancouver; 217 children aged 2.5 to 6) then added a centre outdoor-play policy, educator training, yard changes designed by graduate students from a university school of architecture and landscape architecture, and parent engagement. In this pilot, children's observed outdoor play participation (play versus non-play) showed no change between or within groups; the intervention group's non-significant rise at 6 months (OR 1.28, 95% CI 0.97–1.70) is the authors' main positive signal, alongside one significant term in a second model, a time-by-group interaction (OR 1.51, 95% CI 1.05–2.16), with neither group's own change significant. A separate Australian trial in 84 childcare services that changed centre routines rather than beliefs raised scheduled outdoor free-play time by about an hour a day at 6 months, but the between-group difference was gone at 18 months. The unsolved problem is turning adults' changed beliefs about risky play into durable changes in children's actual outdoor play in childcare, where staff turn over and yards have to be maintained.
Why this matters
Over half of Canadian children under six are in a child care arrangement, most of them in a centre or preschool, which makes childcare centres important settings for outdoor play; the PRO-ECO authors describe early childhood education centres as a way to "provide equitable access to outdoor play." The attitude tools are cheap to scale: OutsidePlay-ECE is fully automated, open access and free to users, and the educator training used in PRO-ECO was being rolled out to YMCA centres across Canada. If the evaluated outcome stays at the adult-attitude level, programmes can scale without anyone knowing whether children play differently. The PRO-ECO authors' own conclusion is that "future considerations for comprehensive outdoor play interventions are required to successfully influence children's outdoor play behaviour" in childcare.
What’s been tried and why it hasn’t worked
Attitude change online (two RCTs). OutsidePlay walks adults through self-reflection exercises grounded in social cognitive theory and ends with a personal goal for change. Mothers using the web version had higher tolerance of risky play at 1 week and 3 months; the in-person workshop version only at 1 week; no mediator explained the effect and no other outcome changed. For goal attainment, the authors report no significant difference; their regression table does show a web-versus-control main effect (OR 3.36, 95% CI 1.32–8.54) alongside null treatment-by-time terms, so the mothers' result is less clear-cut than the educators'. Educators using OutsidePlay-ECE had higher tolerance at 1 week and 3 months, but goal attainment did not differ (intervention-versus-control OR 2.046, 95% CI 0.740–5.655; intervention-by-time OR 1.124, 95% CI 0.335–3.774), and only 48.4% of those randomised to the tool completed its baseline requirements, against 78% of controls. The authors' explanations: goals that were too ambitious or not actionable, a tool that "opened their minds" without building enough self-efficacy, and barriers that, the authors say, would take complex intervention at several organisational levels to address (the individual, relationships with colleagues, licensing regulations). The multi-level programme (PRO-ECO cluster RCT). Every component ran into a delivery problem the authors document. The policy component was delayed by COVID-19 and reached intervention centres only as follow-up began, and its top-down drafting by YMCA management may have limited ownership. Parent engagement was curtailed by pandemic restrictions. Training differed between groups (a full in-person day versus a 4-hour online session). Yard changes (CAD $4,000 plus $2,000 for shade per site) needed upkeep — planting, mulch, storing loose parts under cover — that fell to each centre, and staff turnover and extreme weather made both training and maintenance hard to sustain. The outcome measure also limited what could be seen: children were already playing in about 79–84% of observations at baseline, so a play-versus-non-play outcome had little room to rise. Positive signals are real but uneven: one centre whose large open space received a natural climber saw play rise and stay up at 12 months, the authors report observing educators more willing to stay outside longer in all weather, and one centre began allowing children to ride tricycles down a steep slope. Changing routines instead of beliefs (GOGA RCT, New South Wales). Services supported over 6 months to modify their routines (more outdoor and indoor-outdoor free play) increased outdoor free-play opportunities by 61.3 minutes a day (95% CI 2.5 to 120.01) at 6 months, with no difference in injury reports; the quality of the movement environment did not differ, and at 18 months the between-group difference was no longer significant: control services had also increased their outdoor time (the intervention services' own gain was largely kept), and the officers who delivered the strategy reported, anecdotally, some fatigue among intervention services, which the authors say may explain higher dropouts at 18 months; the audit tool meant to support performance feedback was often not fully completed. Its outcome was scheduled time outdoors, not what children did or how much risk adults allowed. In a related Canadian childcare trial, an outdoor loose-parts intervention (PLEY, 19 Nova Scotia centres) raised children's accelerometer-measured physical activity at 3 and 6 months, so environment changes can move children's behaviour on some outcomes.
What would unlock progress
An intervention aimed at the moment of decision rather than at belief — what an educator does when a child climbs higher than usual — and that survives staff turnover, for example a centre-level routine or physical cue rather than training held by individuals. Routine change alone has been tried (GOGA) and moved scheduled outdoor time but did not hold its between-group difference at 18 months once support was withdrawn, and was not designed to change what risks adults allow; the open part is a routine that shapes supervision decisions and keeps working without outside support. On the environment side, yard changes designed to need little upkeep: PRO-ECO's authors point to low-maintenance native plants, self-sufficient irrigation, budgeting for maintenance and involving educators in the design so they take ownership. A companion PRO-ECO analysis gives a starting point for design: gardening areas, playhouses, sandboxes, stages and fixed water features were associated with exploratory play, climbing structures and trike paths with physical play, and opportunities for diverse forms of play were less realised in open play areas, where the availability of loose parts and moveable equipment was the main influence. Finally, outcomes that can register change: diversity of play types rather than play versus non-play, measured in comparable weather and seasons.
How we’d know it’s being solved
Change in children's observed outdoor play — the diversity of play types (physical, exploratory, imaginative, play with rules, expressive) and time in risky play — measured by behaviour mapping at 12 months or later and in matched weather, compared with control centres. Educator-level measures are intermediate, not endpoints: tolerance-of-risk scores moved in both online trials while neither trial reported a significant effect on goal attainment. Implementation measures that track the documented failure points: share of staff trained who are still at the centre at 12 months, and the condition of yard modifications (loose parts present and stored, plantings alive) at each follow-up.
Where to start
Facility-free door: design a "low-upkeep risky-play yard kit" for a small childcare yard that answers PRO-ECO's documented maintenance failures — a loose-parts storage and rotation system that one educator can reset in five minutes, materials that do not need replenishing, a layout drawn from the play-feature associations above — and cost it against PRO-ECO's CAD $6,000 per-site budget, using published drawings and the trial's descriptions rather than site access. Design door: benefit-risk assessment already exists for settings and activities (ISO 4980:2023 for sport and recreation, a 2025 benefit-risk tool for playgrounds and educational settings, and risk-benefit assessment methods in PRO-ECO's educator training); starting from those, build an in-the-moment decision aid for educators (a card, sign or short app flow) and test it with early-childhood-education students using filmed or written play scenarios, measuring whether it changes the decision they would make, not just their stated attitude. Partner door (design the trial, don't run it): with a childcare organisation, write a protocol for a cluster trial comparing an attitude-only tool with the tool plus a centre-level routine and low-upkeep yard changes, with diversity of observed outdoor play at 12 months as the primary outcome, staff turnover recorded as a moderator, follow-up continuing after research support is withdrawn (the point at which GOGA's between-group difference faded), and a pre-registered analysis plan. Access note: observing children in childcare needs the centre's agreement, parental consent and ethics review; the first two doors need none. Relevant skills: landscape architecture, service design, behavioural science, early childhood education, evaluation methods.
Genes
Related problems
Stuck the same way, in other fields.
field: water & energydilute, dispersed, and too potent to ignoreHundreds of thousands of engines, flares and coal mine shafts emit dilute methane, where conventional solutions often fall shortbuilt without the people who'd live with itsource: primaryfield: food & the living worldfresh at dawn, half price by duskIn small-scale fisheries the fish is rarely thrown away — it is sold for half price as it warms, and no one can objectively grade the quality being lostbuilt without the people who'd live with itsource: primaryfield: the built worldthe most expensive kilometreThe first kilometre from farm to collection point costs Tanzanian potato and pineapple farmers 30–40% of their net income — headloading and motorcycles at many times a truck's rate per tonne-kilometre, on tracks the rural roads agency is not allowed to maintainbuilt without the people who'd live with itsource: primaryfield: the built worldcollision avoidance that stops at the yard gatePositive train control coverage gaps at restricted speed and in terminalsbuilt without the people who'd live with itsource: primarySources
- Brussoni M, Han CS, Lin Y, Jacob J, Munday F, Zeni M, Walters M, Oberle E. "Evaluation of the Web-Based OutsidePlay-ECE Intervention to Influence Early Childhood Educators' Attitudes and Supportive Behaviors Toward Outdoor Play: Randomized Controlled Trial." Journal of Medical Internet Research 24(6):e36826, 2022, doi:10.2196/36826, accessed 2026-10-22. Link ↗
- Brussoni M, Han CS, Lin Y, Jacob J, Pike I, Bundy A, Faulkner G, Gardy J, Fisher B, Mâsse L. "A Web-Based and In-Person Risk Reframing Intervention to Influence Mothers' Tolerance for, and Parenting Practices Associated With, Children's Outdoor Risky Play: Randomized Controlled Trial." Journal of Medical Internet Research 23(4):e24861, 2021, doi:10.2196/24861, accessed 2026-10-22. Link ↗
- Ramsden R, Mount D, Lin Y, Fox E, Herrington S, Loebach J, Cox A, Bundy A, Fyfe-Johnson A, Hansen Sandseter EB, Stone M, Tremblay MS, Brussoni M. "Results from the PROmoting Early Childhood Outside cluster randomized trial evaluating an outdoor play intervention in early childhood education centres." Scientific Reports 15:1713, 2025, doi:10.1038/s41598-025-85397-1, accessed 2026-10-22. Link ↗
- Ramsden R, Pike I, Thorne S, Brussoni M. "Children's outdoor play at early learning and child care centres: Examining the impact of environmental play features on children's play behaviour." PLoS One 20(12):e0318538, 2025, doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0318538, accessed 2026-10-22. Link ↗
- Nesbit RJ, Bagnall CL, Harvey K, Dodd HF. "Perceived Barriers and Facilitators of Adventurous Play in Schools: A Qualitative Systematic Review." Children 8(8):681, 2021, doi:10.3390/children8080681, accessed 2026-10-22. Link ↗
- Yoong SL, Pearson N, Giles L, Lamont H, Wolfenden L, Jones J, Lecathelinais C, Naylor PJ, Okely A, Nathan N, Reilly K, Lorch R, Wiggers J, Jackson J, Lum M, Gillham K, Grady A. "Impact of a multi-component implementation strategy to increase outdoor free play opportunities in early childhood education and care (ECEC) services: the get outside get active (GOGA) randomised controlled trial." International Journal of Behavioral Nutrition and Physical Activity 22:51, 2025, doi:10.1186/s12966-025-01749-0, accessed 2026-10-22. Link ↗
- Caldwell HAT, Spencer RA, Joshi N, Branje K, Cawley J, Hobson H, Kirk SFL, Stevens D, Stone MR. "Impact of an outdoor loose parts play intervention on Nova Scotian preschoolers' physical literacy: a mixed-methods randomized controlled trial." BMC Public Health 23(1):1126, 2023, doi:10.1186/s12889-023-16030-x, full text read 2026-11-12, accessed 2026-10-22. Link ↗
- Eager D, Gray T, Little H, Robbé F, Sharwood LN. "Risky Play Is Not a Dirty Word: A Tool to Measure Benefit-Risk in Outdoor Playgrounds and Educational Settings." International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 22, 2025, doi:10.3390/ijerph22060940, full text read 2026-11-12, accessed 2026-10-22. Link ↗
Revision notes
This brief gets checked against its sources and contains the following revisions. Future revisions get added here.
Full check
Sources read
- Brussoni et al., online risk-reframing tool for early childhood educators (JMIR, 2022): full text
- Brussoni et al., risk-reframing trial with mothers (JMIR, 2021): full text
- Ramsden et al., PRO-ECO cluster randomised trial (Scientific Reports, 2025): full text
- Ramsden et al., play features and play types in PRO-ECO centres (PLoS One, 2025): full text (its later correction notice was also read; it touches no claim on this page)
- Nesbit et al., review of barriers to outdoor risky play in schools (Children, 2021): full text
- Yoong et al., GOGA cluster randomised trial (International Journal of Behavioral Nutrition and Physical Activity, 2025): full text
- Caldwell et al., PLEY loose-parts trial (BMC Public Health, 2023): full text
- Eager et al., benefit-risk assessment tool (International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 2025): full text
What changed
- Stated more strongly than the source: the educators' barriers were said to sit at levels a single educator cannot change; the paper says removing them would take intervention at several levels (the individual, colleagues, licensing rules); the partner starting point said the Australian trial's effect faded; only the difference between groups faded, and the centres that got the support largely kept their gain.
- Contradicted by the source, corrected: how open play areas worked: the paper says varied play happened less in open areas, where loose parts and movable equipment were the main influence; the page had turned this round.
- Numbers: the educators' goal-attainment result was given as one odds ratio without saying what it measured; the page now gives both results from the paper's table, each labelled.
- Credit: the report of fatigue in the Australian trial is now credited to the officers who delivered the strategy, marked as anecdotal, and tied to dropouts, as the paper does, not to the fading difference between groups.
- Title: the full title now places the eight pilot centres in Greater Vancouver, not Vancouver (display title unchanged).
Left open
None noted in this check.
Separate check of specific claims: One significant result from the pilot trial's second model was added, and the source list now says two papers were read in full.
Earlier full check: Three statements were brought in line with the sources: an implied link between a schools review and the training tools, who designed the yard changes, and how many young children are in childcare.
Separate check of specific claims: The full and display titles were narrowed to what the trials found, an overstated goal-attainment result was corrected, and a large newer trial and a positive loose-parts trial were added.