arts · labor
help to apply that needs help to request
Canadian arts funders pay for application help and access costs for deaf and disabled artists, but a council-commissioned study found grant writing especially hard for artists with cognitive disabilities, and the Canada council still lists its process for requesting that help as a barrier
Source: Leduc et al., “Deaf and Disability Arts Practices in Canada” Open ↗source: primaryLast updated: 2026-11-17
Problem statement
Public funders are, in the words of the 2020 report described below, "a cornerstone of support for artists" in Canada, and grants are won by writing. Canadian arts funders have tried to remove that barrier for Deaf and disabled artists in two ways: "application assistance" (money to pay someone to help with the application) and "access support" (extra money for interpreters, attendants and other access costs on a funded project). Some also accept video, audio or sign-language applications. Yet in a study of 85 Deaf and disabled artists and cultural workers in six provinces, commissioned by the Canada Council for the Arts, the report found that the confusing language of applications and the skills they demand keep some people from applying at all, "especially ... people living with cognitive disabilities"; one focus-group participant put it as "Fine if you're in a wheelchair and you can sit at a computer, but if you have an intellectual disability, the forms… the programs aren't accessible at all. It's basically a two-tiered system." In 2023, the Council's own environmental scan of 15 Canadian funders states that its access team "is aware that the process for accessing its accessibility mechanisms is creating barriers for applicants and unnecessary workload for program staff." The Council has since simplified the request process, by its own account, yet its 2026–2028 Accessibility Plan still lists as a barrier that "the process for requesting Application Assistance and Access Support is not clear," and it plans to keep developing alternative application formats through 2027. The unsolved problem is a way to apply for, and request access help for, arts funding that artists with intellectual, cognitive or language-based disabilities, and Deaf signers, can use without first doing the very kind of written work the help was meant to replace.
Why this matters
The 2020 report describes Deaf, disabled and mad artists as "significantly affected by poverty", with many independent artists living "just above the poverty line." It reports that the confusing, complex language of application processes "results in some people not applying at all," and that "a significant number of interviewees felt that they had wasted time preparing unsuccessful grant applications" and had not re-applied. Where a funder has counted, demand is there and rising: the report notes that the Ontario Arts Council received 225 applications from Deaf and disabled artists and disability-arts organisations in 2015–16 (85 grants, $590,913) and 277 in 2016–17 (132 grants, $1,067,230). Making work, not only attending it, depends on getting through this gate.
What’s been tried and why it hasn’t worked
(1) Application assistance. The Canada Council pays a service provider to help eligible applicants, with set hour and dollar caps: for example up to 2 hours and $100 for account creation, up to 17 hours ($1,020) of general help for a composite grant, and 8 to 21 hours ($800 to $2,100) of sign-language support depending on the grant. The 2020 report found this help "welcomed", but some participants said they "did not know of any qualified resources to act as application assistants," and that interpreters translating applications from ASL or LSQ into written English or French sometimes lacked arts expertise, so that a Deaf artist's application could be presented "in a less convincing manner, even if equity measures have been implemented." In a 2023 study of first-time grant recipients done for the Council by a consultancy, recipients described community members often giving this kind of help unpaid, "either because grant applicants are not aware of the support available, are hesitant to request assistance, or because the support provided is not sufficient to cover all the help an individual requires"; it also records one interviewee who "appreciated that the Canada Council funded their access support request in a streamlined way and without asking for too much personal information." (2) Access support. Paying access costs separately from creative budgets is described as "a very positive development." But some participants were disappointed that access funds were allocated per Deaf or disabled artist rather than per organisation, which fails when casts change and a Deaf artist joins late, after the funds can no longer be requested; that interpretation funding is taxed as income; that time itself ("crip time") is not funded ("what [would normally take] 120 hours to make might take me 160 to 180 hours"); and that artists were unsure whether a grant would cut their disability income support. (3) Alternative formats. The 2023 scan found seven funders with alternative formats for Deaf or disabled applicants (for example, video applications at the Conseil des arts de Montréal, audio and video applications being piloted, and ASL applications accepted, by the British Columbia Arts Council, recorded verbal applications with staff help at Calgary Arts Development, and applications and final reports in alternative formats and timelines at the Ontario Arts Council). Quebec's arts council (CALQ) takes the request for application help inside the grant application: by its own page, the request "doit être déposée au CALQ en même temps que la demande de bourse principale" ("must be filed with the CALQ at the same time as the main grant application"; our translation) with invoices attached, the help "est accordée automatiquement si la demande principale est reconnue admissible" ("is granted automatically if the main application is found eligible"; our translation), and, if the grant is awarded, a flat $150 is added for producing the report on how the grant was used. The page gives no figures on how many applicants use it. (4) What the scan found about the request process itself. Asking for help can itself be "a labor-intensive process": applicants may have to identify their own access needs and service providers, complete request forms, meet strict deadlines, do this "before finding out if their grant applications are successful," and justify each request with a costed budget, "labor that non-disabled and hearing artists are not required to do." Staff at several funders fill the gaps informally, helping applicants reword needs to fit eligible expenses and using "creative workarounds to rules"; staff said this labour can be made invisible, and the scan concludes that it "gets erased on paper." The scan found application assistance and access support to be the main access practices across the 15 funders, and reports some funders taking the work on themselves (completing requests on the applicant's behalf, recommending providers, flexible deadlines). (5) The Canada Council's own changes since the scan. Its 2024 Accessibility Progress Report says it began simplifying and putting into plain language the wording of forms and guidelines, said the process for requesting Application Assistance and Access Support "will be simplified," was "exploring" video and audio applications, and would convene a group to test alternate application formats for Deaf applicants; feedback it received in 2024 included "the time and complexity of the payment process for artists living with disabilities and the maximum amount offered through Application Assistance." Its current pages describe the process as it now stands, without saying what changed or when: an applicant asking again for Application Assistance in the same category sends the grant name and a brief project description, and the Council confirms the annual limits and gives a new case number (the other steps stay the same), and Access Support can be requested with the grant application or at any time after the award until the final report, though it is assessed only once the grant succeeds and still needs budget notes (rates times hours, per provider) and supports "linked directly to the project activities." The 2026–2028 plan, after saying the request process "has been simplified," still lists it as "not clear" and sets only "continued" development of alternative formats (end of 2027) and simplification of forms (end of 2028). No published evaluation of any of these changes was found.
What would unlock progress
Moving the labour of access from the applicant to the funder, which the 2023 scan names as an emerging opportunity ("redistributing the labor of access"), and designing the application and the access request for the people who find writing hardest, not as a written form with a paid helper bolted on. The starting point is what is already done: the Canada Council's simplified requests and plain-language forms, its alternative formats still in development, and funders that already accept video, audio, ASL or alternative-format final reports. What those leave open is the access request itself, which still asks the applicant to name supports and providers and cost them hour by hour, and the share of the process still written. That means plain-language or picture-supported questions, sign-language and spoken answers accepted throughout (including final reports, which one interviewee in the 2020 report said must be written, with too little guidance for Deaf signers, and which only some funders, such as the Ontario Arts Council, accept in other formats), a single request that covers both the grant and its access needs without a costed justification the applicant must write, and a pool of assistants who know the arts. The funders already accepting alternative formats are natural places to see what works.
How we’d know it’s being solved
(a) Applications submitted, and success rates, by artists with intellectual or cognitive disabilities and by Deaf signers, compared with other applicants (the 2020 report notes that data tracking "is not systematic" in most institutions interviewed and that self-identification is voluntary, so this baseline would itself need building); (b) time and number of steps an applicant spends on the access request before a grant decision; (c) share of applicants who complete an application in a non-written format end to end, including the final report; (d) applicants' own ratings of whether the process was usable without a helper.
Where to start
Facility-free door. Using only the public guidelines of the Canada Council (including its current Application Assistance and Access Support pages) and of the seven funders the 2023 scan names as accepting alternative formats, map every step, form, word count, deadline and written requirement an applicant with an intellectual disability or a Deaf signer meets from first contact to final report, and mark which steps the alternative formats leave untouched. The deliverable is a step map with the points where the applicant must still write or justify. Design door (digital, users reachable). Design and prototype a plain-language, picture-supported, video-answer application-and-access-request flow for a small arts grant, in which one request covers both the project and its access needs with no separate costed access budget for the applicant to write. The 2023 scan names seven Canadian funders that already accept or are piloting alternative-format applications (video, audio, ASL or recorded verbal), and the Canada Council already lets Access Support be requested with the grant application; the team's prototype differs by also replacing the access-request paperwork (named supports, providers and an hour-by-hour costing, which the Canada Council's current Access Support page still asks for) and, where a funder still requires it, the written final report. Test the prototype with students who have learning or intellectual disabilities through a campus disability office or an inclusive post-secondary programme, and with Deaf students who sign, in supervised sessions; for people with intellectual disabilities the session plan needs ethics review, and the first semester's deliverable can be the test design with a paper prototype. Design-the-study door. Design the baseline in (a): a voluntary, accessible self-identification and process-experience survey that a funder could add to its application system. Relevant skills: service and interaction design, plain-language and easy-read writing, sign-language video production, disability studies.
Genes
Related problems
Stuck the same way, in other fields.
field: digital & spaceeurope's satellites run on parts others can embargoWell over half the electronic components in European spacecraft come from outside Europe, where export rules like ITAR can put the best technology out of reachbuilt without the people who'd live with itsource: primaryfield: health & medicinethe locator left unchargedNorwegian towns gave people with dementia GPS locators so they could walk out freely, but in the pilots some ran flat or were thrown away as too big; a 2026 review still names battery and charging among the key limits, and year-long Bluetooth tags remove charging, but fewer than half of carers in one study were satisfied with their accuracybuilt without the people who'd live with itsource: secondaryfield: water & energyinvisible water, no treaty468 aquifers cross international borders and countries report only 13 aquifer-specific cooperation arrangements — five of which do not actually operatebuilt without the people who'd live with itsource: primaryfield: health & medicinefree lunch the gluten-free child skipsIn a survey of 75 mostly affluent Massachusetts families, most children with coeliac disease had never eaten the state's now-free school breakfast and many parents were not confident the cafeteria could make a safe gluten-free meal, while a 2010 Italian regional audit found 71% of schools serving gluten-free meals fell short on at least one control areabuilt without the people who'd live with itsource: primarySources
- Leduc V, Boukala M, Rouleau J, Louw A, McAskill A, Théroux C, Heussaff S, Grenier L, Bernier M, Bouscatier S, Marcelli E, Parent L, Saunders D, Tembeck T, Angrignon-Girouard O, Grimard C. "Deaf and Disability Arts Practices in Canada." Research report. Montréal: Canada Council for the Arts, 2020, accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
- Fernandes, Sabine A. (with Daniela Navia and Mana Rouholamini). "Environmental Scan of Access Practices in Arts Funding: Final Report." Canada Council for the Arts, October 2023, accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
- Canada Council for the Arts. "Application Assistance.", accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
- Canada Council for the Arts. "Access Support.", accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
- Canada Council for the Arts. "2024 Accessibility Progress Report.", accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
- Canada Council for the Arts. "2026–2028 Accessibility Plan.", accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
- Goss Gilroy Inc. "Impact of Canada Council for the Arts Grants on First-Time Recipients – Final Report." Prepared for the Research, Measurement, and Data Analytics Section, Canada Council for the Arts, February 22, 2023, accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
- Conseil des arts et des lettres du Québec. "Aide aux personnes handicapées pour la présentation d'une candidature ou d'une demande de bourse.", accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
Revision notes
This brief gets checked against its sources and contains the following revisions. Future revisions get added here.
Worth knowing
- the 2023 scan's list of seven funders with alternative formats includes programmes for Indigenous and Black artists, so fewer than seven of them are aimed at Deaf or disabled applicants
- the evidence is qualitative: interviews, focus groups and a funder's own scan, not measured outcomes
Full check
Sources read
- Leduc et al., Deaf and Disability Arts Practices in Canada (Canada Council, 2020): full text (read in the English edition and the French original)
- Fernandes, environmental scan of access practices in arts funding (Canada Council, 2023): full text
- Canada Council, 2024 Accessibility Progress Report: full text
- Canada Council, 2026–2028 Accessibility Plan: full text
- Canada Council, Application Assistance page: full text (read in English and French)
- Canada Council, Access Support page: full text
- Goss Gilroy, study of first-time Canada Council grant recipients (2023): full text
- Quebec arts council (CALQ), page on help for disabled applicants: full text (read in French)
What changed
- Stated more strongly than the source: demand from Deaf and disabled artists was called large, resting on one funder's counts; the text now says that where a funder has counted, demand is there and rising; requesting access help was said to be a labour-intensive process; the scan says it can be, and the text now says so; the Council's current pages were presented as showing its promised simplification in place; neither page says what changed or when, so the text now says they describe the process as it stands.
- Credit: the point that final reports must be written, with too little guidance for Deaf signers, is now credited to one interviewee in the 2020 report, not to the report itself.
Left open
None noted in this check.
Separate check of specific claims: Two earlier attempts were added: a Council-commissioned study of first-time grant recipients, in which recipients described community members giving application help unpaid, and Quebec's arts council, which takes the request for application help inside the grant application itself.
Earlier full check: Nine fixes: the long title now says grant writing is especially hard, not hardest, for artists with cognitive disabilities (display title unchanged), an unsupported claim that most artists need grants was replaced with the report's own words, several statements are now credited to some participants or to the scan's author rather than to everyone, and the returning-applicant process is described as the Council's page gives it.
Separate check of specific claims: The design project no longer says seven funders already accept video or audio applications, since the scan's list includes a pilot and other formats, and it now notes that the Council already lets access support be requested with the grant application.
Earlier full check: The long title was narrowed so that it no longer rests on one focus-group participant's words (display title unchanged), the Council's newer accessibility reports were added, a claim that final reports must always be written was corrected (the Ontario Arts Council accepts other formats), and the complaint about per-artist access funds is now credited to some participants.