Skip to content
problem genome

One of 592 unsolved problems in the Problem Genome, a collection written up for student design and engineering teams.

health · digital

the locator left uncharged

Norwegian towns gave people with dementia GPS locators so they could walk out freely, but in the pilots some ran flat or were thrown away as too big; a 2026 review still names battery and charging among the key limits, and year-long Bluetooth tags remove charging, but fewer than half of carers in one study were satisfied with their accuracy

Source: Øderud et al., “GPS for trygghet, frihet og mestring. Fra prosjekt til drift…” Open ↗source: secondaryLast updated: 2026-11-17

Problem statement

People with dementia often still want to walk outdoors alone, and getting lost is a real risk. Norwegian municipalities have offered GPS locators (Drammen since 2011) so they can go out without locked doors or an escort. By 2017, 180 people in Oslo had used one, and Oslo offered the service in all 15 of its districts. Users, relatives and staff say it works. In the Oslo evaluation (relatives and staff answering for 109 users), over 90% said it made going out safer, and over 80% said it gave the user more freedom. But a locator only helps if it is charged, switched on, and with the person when they leave. Many people with dementia cannot make sure of all three on their own, although Oslo staff and relatives were sometimes surprised that users kept the habit of taking the device out while forgetting other things. In Oslo, relatives did the charging and switching for 47% of users and users did it themselves for 21%. In a Kristiansand care home, staff sometimes forgot to charge a device overnight. Twice a resident stayed out longer than agreed with a flat GPS in the bag on her walker, and staff could not find her. Residents sometimes took off a unit worn on the arm and threw it in the bin because it was too big, or because they did not recognise it or remember they had to wear it; another unit was felt by some as bulky and possibly stigmatising. A very small unit that can hang on a keyring looks little like a GPS. A 2026 qualitative review of 25 studies from several countries still lists short battery life, constant charging and unreliable location signals as the key technological limits of tracking devices. One person with dementia in a study it cites said: "My device hasn't been working for months…people around me weren't checking on me because they thought I was protected, and I was not." Low-power Bluetooth tags with a battery life of up to a year now exist, but in a Hong Kong study of 1,034 carers fewer than half of those who answered were satisfied with their location accuracy. The unsolved problem is a locator that stays on the person, keeps working and still gives a usable position, without depending on their memory. When it stops working, the people relying on it also need to know.

Why this matters

The Norwegian reports describe the locator as an alternative to locked doors and escorted walks. The Kristiansand report says it lets care-home residents go out when they want, "not only when it suits the staff" (our translation). The 2026 review finds safe walking is "a fundamental need" for people with dementia and that missing episodes cause carers great distress. The failure is quiet. A flat or forgotten device may give no warning and still looks like protection, so a locator that fails this way can be worse than none.

What’s been tried and why it hasn’t worked

(1) A municipal service with a support chain (Norway, 2011–2017). The Samspill project (Oslo, Drammen, Kristiansand, Skien, with SINTEF) set up routines covering who charges, who receives alarms, who locates and who fetches. Two alarm centres gave a 24-hour alarm service in Oslo. It worked when the chain held. When it did not, devices failed. In Kristiansand, responsibility for charging and fetching was clear in some cases and "unclear" (our translation) in others. In one case a relative was phoned to fetch a user and had not understood that this was part of the arrangement. In a care home an alarm went off and no one responded: "My mother had gone off, the alarm had gone off, but no staff member had responded" (our translation). In Oslo a geofence was dropped "because of constant misunderstandings" when alerts went to the wrong service (our translation). (2) Better and more varied devices. Some Oslo users and relatives found one model "too big and bulky" (our translation), some users found it heavy round the neck, and watches and keyrings were asked for. The 2017 report says suppliers then widened their ranges. Smaller units, watch models and GPS insoles appeared, with better battery capacity and accuracy. Yet the same report still lists charging as "often a challenge" (our translation) and slow or wrong positions as a reason some families declined the service. Two German home studies of locating devices (a smartphone the researchers recommended wearing in a waistband, 2017; two GPS watches, 2018; 17 pairs of a person with dementia and a carer analysed in each) point the same way: in the first, usability ratings "were significantly reduced after 4 weeks" and one person took the device out of the waistband, so that it "was temporarily lost"; in the second, one watch came with a charging station, "problems with the charging cable or dock" were among the technical difficulties reported, and the authors recommend "a battery life of at least 24 hours". Neither tested a signal that the device had been left behind. (3) Low-battery text alerts. In Oslo a relative who lived elsewhere got a text when her mother's keyring unit was low and phoned to remind her to charge "her keys" (our translation). This works only where a relative is reachable and the person can act on a phone call. (4) Long-life Bluetooth tags (Hong Kong, 2020–2023). A crowdsourcing system pairs a water-resistant Bluetooth tag (battery life up to one year, low-battery notice to the carer) with phones running an app that report the tag's position. This removes daily charging. In a single-arm study of 1,034 carers, over 80% of people with dementia were willing to carry the tag and carer worry fell over time. But only 43.7% (309/707) were satisfied with accuracy, because position depends on enough phones nearby; only 51 of the 143 carers who had a lost episode used the tag to search; and the tag did not significantly shorten the time to find the person. The authors call for a randomised trial. (5) The 2025–2026 evidence. A GPS feasibility trial (45 dyads given GPS trackers for six months; 14 dyads in focus groups) found carers less stressed. It also found that how long a device stayed in use depended on device features, mobile networks and neighbours. Charging was part of it: the paper says carers "have had to charge the device daily", that the battery level could be read only by sending the device a text message, and that one carer "dropped out of the study because she could not continue with the regular charging episode of the device"; another said, "I could not sustain visiting her daily to charge it, so I sent my mum to a care home instead." The 2026 review (25 studies, search to April 2025) repeats short battery life, constant charging and signal problems, and calls for designs that do not stigmatise, are easier to use and suit each stage of dementia.

What would unlock progress

A locator designed around the charging-and-carrying routine, not the positioning chip. Year-long tags show that charging can be taken out of the routine, but in the Hong Kong study the tag's position depended on enough app phones nearby and fewer than half of the carers who answered were satisfied with its accuracy; daily-charged GPS keeps the routine. The Oslo user whose charger sits in the kitchen with her mobile while the GPS "hangs by the door where the dog lead is" (our translation), and the "keys" charged after a text, show one direction: tie the device to something the person already does every day, so that leaving with it charged needs no new memory. A second gap is honest failure: the people relying on the device should get a clear signal when it is flat, off or left at home, without the alerts a care-home worker in Kristiansand said can be disruptive when staff are busy with other tasks. Any design must fit the consent rules in Norwegian law (pasient- og brukerrettighetsloven §4-6a, named in the Kristiansand report). The 2026 review stresses that the person with dementia should choose.

How we’d know it’s being solved

(a) The share of outings on which the device was with the person, charged and reporting, logged over weeks, not asked about once. (b) The number of "silent failures": times the device was flat, off or at home while the person was out. Kristiansand recorded two in which a resident could not be found. (c) Carer and staff time spent on charging and reminders. (d) Acceptance by the person with dementia: whether they keep it on, and whether they find it stigmatising. (e) Alerts per week that staff judge useful against those they judge noise.

Where to start

Facility-free door (make a thing): design a "leaving the house" object for a daily-charged GPS locator. (The year-long Bluetooth tags above already remove charging, though fewer than half of the carers who answered were satisfied with their accuracy, so this door is not about them.) The object charges the locator, sits where the person already picks things up (keys, lead, handbag hook), and makes leaving without it hard or visible. Pair it with a simple status signal for a carer: charged, with the person, or left behind. Build it with an off-the-shelf GPS tracker or a phone standing in for one. Test the charging and status logic with student volunteers over two weeks of their own comings and goings. No partner or data is needed. Design-the-test door: write a protocol for a home trial with people with dementia and their family carers that measures (a)–(e) above against the person's current device. Include a consent process in which the person with dementia chooses. It is handed to a dementia service, not run. Ethics line: any trial with people with dementia needs research-ethics review with procedures for assessing consent capacity and for consent by a representative; the semester deliverable is the protocol only. Carer door: family carers can be reached through dementia carer support groups or a senior centre. Interview them about where things are charged and picked up at home, and test paper or foam mock-ups of the object with them. Interviews with carers need the campus ethics review; no person with dementia takes part in this door. Relevant skills: product and interaction design, embedded electronics, service design, gerontology.

Genes

Related problems

Stuck the same way, in other fields.

field: society & learningthe seating plan's mixed recordTeachers move seats to help disliked or bullied children, and Dutch classroom trials give mixed results: seating disliked pupils closer for several weeks raised their liking, though relational aggression also rose, and disliked children with behaviour problems became better liked by their seatmates, slightly more beside a well-liked buddy, but a shorter version was followed by more overt aggression class-wide and seating bullied pupils next to their best friend did not improve their wellbeingbuilt without the people who'd live with itsource: primaryfield: making & materialsless copper per tonne, more energy to get itCopper ore grade decline creates compounding energy-emissions processing spiralbuilt without the people who'd live with itsource: secondaryfield: the built worldthe most expensive kilometreThe first kilometre from farm to collection point costs Tanzanian potato and pineapple farmers 30–40% of their net income — headloading and motorcycles at many times a truck's rate per tonne-kilometre, on tracks the rural roads agency is not allowed to maintainbuilt without the people who'd live with itsource: primaryfield: society & learningsurrounded, and still aloneAfter a spouse dies, the loneliness that tracks grief is the kind more company does not easily fix — and a traditional bereavement group in the one trial that measured both kinds moved neitherbuilt without the people who'd live with itsource: primary

Sources

  • Øderud T, Ausen D, Aketun S, Thorgersen M. "GPS for trygghet, frihet og mestring. Fra prosjekt til drift – Bruk av GPS for lokalisering av personer med demens/ kognitiv svikt." SINTEF Teknologi og samfunn, rapport 2017:00342, versjon 4, 2017-09-30, accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • Fosse GA. "Erfaringsrapport Samspill. Pilotering av lokaliseringsteknologi (GPS) i Kristiansand kommune." Kristiansand kommune, mars 2016, accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • Kwok HT, Dhawan A, Lye V, Fong L, Leung P, Orgeta V. "Supporting safe walking and managing missing incidents in dementia: a qualitative narrative synthesis of current evidence." Age and ageing 2026;55(1):afaf371, doi:10.1093/ageing/afaf371, accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • Nwofe ES, Bishop D, Rooke C, Seelam K, Porter J, Windle K, Doyle M. "Techno-organisational network and reliable implementation of GPS technology for people with dementia and their caregivers in the community." Disability and rehabilitation. Assistive technology 2025;20(7):2298-2314, doi:10.1080/17483107.2025.2501079 (full text; abstract), accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗ Link 2 ↗
  • Wong B, Cheng T, Fung N, Lin Z, Lai KK, Ho F, Chan SG, Kwok T. "Using Crowdsourcing Internet of Things Technology to Reduce Caregiver Worry in Dementia-Related Lost Episodes: Longitudinal Observational Study." JMIR human factors 2025;12:e73670, doi:10.2196/73670, accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • Megges H, Freiesleben SD, Jankowski N, Haas B, Peters O. "Technology for home dementia care: A prototype locating system put to the test." Alzheimer's & Dementia: Translational Research & Clinical Interventions 2017;3(3):332-338, doi:10.1016/j.trci.2017.04.004, accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • Megges H, Freiesleben SD, Rösch C, Knoll N, Wessel L, Peters O. "User experience and clinical effectiveness with two wearable global positioning system devices in home dementia care." Alzheimer's & Dementia: Translational Research & Clinical Interventions 2018;4(1):636-644, doi:10.1016/j.trci.2018.10.002, accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
Revision notes

This brief gets checked against its sources and contains the following revisions. Future revisions get added here.

Full check

Sources read

  • SINTEF, Oslo locator pilot final report (2017, in Norwegian): full text
  • Fosse, Kristiansand locator pilot report (SINTEF, 2016, in Norwegian): full text
  • Kwok et al., review of locating technology in dementia (2026): full text
  • Wong et al., Hong Kong Bluetooth tag study (2025): full text
  • Nwofe et al., GPS trackers for people with dementia (2025): full text
  • Peterson et al. (2025), Kobayashi-Cuya et al. (2026), Swain-Velasco et al. (2026) and Cullen et al. (2022): abstract only

What changed

  • Not found in the sources, replaced with what they say: the unlock section and the first starting point no longer compare the accuracy of Bluetooth tags with GPS, which no source does; they now give the Hong Kong finding that fewer than half of carers were satisfied with the tags' accuracy.
  • Stated more strongly than the source: responsibility for the device was clear 'in some cases', as the Kristiansand report says; a flat or forgotten device 'may' give no warning, since some devices in the sources send low-battery messages; the 2026 review is no longer called the newest; two other 2026 reviews were also checked and are named.
  • Contradicted by the source, corrected: the 2026 review covers 25 studies, most qualitative and six mixed-methods; Oslo had two alarm centres giving a round-the-clock service; the Kristiansand unit was worn on the arm, as the report says.
  • Numbers: the Hong Kong satisfaction figure is 309 of the 707 carers who answered, not of all 1,034.
  • Credit: the complaints about one Oslo model are now credited as the report does: too big and bulky to some users and relatives, heavy round the neck to some users, and requests for watches and keyrings to several people and staff.
  • Title: the long title's ending now gives the Hong Kong accuracy finding instead of a comparison with GPS (display title unchanged).

Left open

  • the 'thought I was protected' quotation and its attribution to a person with dementia (the study it comes from was not opened)

Separate check of specific claims: Charging passages from the UK study and two German home studies of locating devices were added, with their citations on the source list.

Earlier full check: The UK study was read in full, two descriptions from the Kristiansand report were brought back to its words, and four translated quotations were marked as our translations.

Separate check of specific claims: The object starting point was narrowed to daily-charged GPS locators, since year-long tags already remove charging, and the carer starting point's ethics line was reworded.

Earlier full check: Details were corrected from the Norwegian reports (who answered for users, where the charger was kept, a third reason a unit was thrown away), a Hong Kong study of year-long Bluetooth tags was added, and the titles were reframed (display title 'A Locator Nobody Charged' → 'The Locator Left Uncharged').