Skip to content
problem genome

One of 592 unsolved problems in the Problem Genome, a collection written up for student design and engineering teams.

social · digital · health

a screen that can only wait

An Oslo trial assigned 516 frail older people living at home to be offered a one-button video screen: 150 took one, 97 of those screens were never contacted by anyone, and home-dwelling was not prolonged, while some users felt the receive-only design made them passive

Source: Eikemo et al., “The effect of digital communication technology on older…” Open ↗source: primaryLast updated: 2026-11-17

Problem statement

Komp is a screen with a single button for older people who cannot manage smartphones or tablets, developed by the Norwegian start-up No Isolation and now sold by Abilia, which acquired it. Family members use an app to send it photos and messages and to make video calls, which connect automatically after ten seconds. The older person can only switch it on or off and change the volume; they "cannot initiate contact through the Komp screen; they can only receive." In a randomised trial in three Oslo boroughs, 516 frail older people receiving home nursing care were assigned to be offered a Komp and 595 to usual services. Only 150 took one (29% of the group, 42% of those actually offered). Of those 150, 97 screens were never used: no one reached out through the app. About a third of recipients (53) had any registered use, averaging 1.1 activities a week. After 28 months the offer had not delayed moves into long-term care (hazard ratio 1.16, 95% CI 0.94 to 1.43, not significant), though the intervention group spent about five fewer days in short-term institutional stays. A companion interview study with 12 older people and their relatives found that half settled into stable use; others turned the screen off, covered it or gave it up, and some older people objected to the design: one man was dissatisfied "at not being able to initiate calls via Komp" and kept it switched off, and one woman felt "infantilised". The current Norwegian FAQ on Komp's own sales site still answers "Can you call out from Komp?" with "No" (our translation). Simple ways to reach out are already on sale elsewhere: the ViewClix smart frame sends a "Call-Me" text request, the Konnekt videophone calls a contact with one touch of a large named button, and GrandCare's help pages describe "Call Me" buttons that alert a caregiver or a call list. No evaluation of any of these with frail home-nursing recipients was found, and a request or a call does nothing for someone whom nobody answers. The unsolved problem is a way for an older person who cannot use a smartphone to reach out, that tells them whether anyone heard, and that still works for people with thin networks, rather than a screen that can only wait to be contacted.

Why this matters

Norway, like other Western countries, is pushing "ageing in place", and low social contact is one of the risk factors for moving into a care home. Simplified devices are one response for people left out by mainstream technology; the trial authors note that, to their knowledge, only two earlier randomised trials had tested a digital communication technology as a standalone intervention for older adults' social connectedness, and they describe theirs as the first randomised trial of such a technology's effect on formal care use. Newer reviews of randomised trials do not settle the question: a 2025 meta-analysis of 40 trials found social-contact interventions "showed limited impact" on loneliness, and a 2026 meta-analysis of 7 trials found a small, non-significant pooled effect of technology-based interventions (abstracts read). The authors raise a possible harm: for the 97 people whose screens stayed dark, "the presence of an unused device could have acted as a constant reminder of limited social contact." A device whose value depends entirely on others acting puts the people with the thinnest networks, who most need contact, at the greatest risk of getting nothing from it.

What’s been tried and why it hasn’t worked

(1) The receive-only screen, in a randomised trial (2022–2025). Eligible people were home-nursing recipients aged 67+ (mean 84.6) in three Oslo boroughs. Devices were usually offered in person with a demonstration and, when possible, relatives present, installed by trained staff, and free. The original plan had municipal care staff also using Komp to contact participants, but this "ultimately did not occur due to delays", so contact relied only on private networks. Results: low uptake, most screens unused, no effect on the primary outcome, a reduction in short-term stays, and no difference in other care services. The authors note that low exposure cut the trial's statistical power, and that frailer people may have been more likely to accept while "more active and technologically competent individuals have previously rejected Komp". Earlier work they cite found users phoning relatives to ask for a Komp call, a workaround for not being able to call out. (2) What happened in homes (interviews, 2023). Twelve pairs of an older person (aged 72–96) and a relative were each interviewed about a month after the screen arrived and again some months later (February–November 2023). Six reached stable use. Four were unstable: a son could not catch his father's attention when he was dozing or watching TV, wanted the device to mute the television during calls, and proposed connecting Komp to an emergency button so his father could call others if in need; a woman with no family received Komp for friends, but the set-up assumes a close, tech-able relative as administrator, and her friend struggled to set up the app and invite others. Two broke down: a man in his nineties, dissatisfied at not being able to start calls, kept it switched off, and his daughter then stopped sending messages; a woman in her eighties rejected it because handing relatives the power to invite contacts, start calls and post pictures made her feel "infantilised" and "like being put in prison", and she preferred her phone and FaceTime, where she could start calls. (3) Mainstream devices. Phones and tablets let users call out but are what this group finds hard to use; Komp was designed to remove that barrier, and its designers removed outgoing contact to do so; a 2021 Norwegian analysis of the design found it carries "inscribed" expectations of "well-functioning families with digitally incompetent older people and competent relatives" (read in Norwegian; our translation). Smart speakers offer a voice route: with any Echo device a person can say "Alexa, call Dad" and the device pulls the number from the contact list, and on an Echo Show a family member can "Drop In" (connect without the other side answering), but "Both sides must grant permission in their Alexa app settings" first. Oslo's municipal one-button device is the safety alarm (trygghetsalarm): everyone over 75 is entitled to an indoor one, a press reaches the alarm centre, and the municipality says it "skal ikke brukes til omsorgsoppgaver som utføres av hjemmetjenesten" (must not be used for care tasks done by home services; our translation); only the outdoor GPS model "aktiverer toveis tale mellom deg og dine pårørende" (opens two-way speech with your relatives). (4) One-action outgoing contact and request buttons already on the market. The Konnekt videophone, sold for seniors in Australia, Europe, the UK and North America, has large named call buttons ("To call Amy, you simply touch the 'Amy' button"), and if the contact does not answer in the app "we can setup Videophone to call your landline or mobile phone numbers as a backup". GrandCare's Action Buttons, "Sometimes referred to as "Call Me" buttons", send an email, text or phone call to one caregiver, all caregivers, or a Call List when pushed, and a caregiver can set the press to show "an on-screen Acknowledgment to the resident"; the page does not say whether anyone saw or answered. A 2023 do-it-yourself guide builds a "Call Me" button from a Flic button, an Echo Glow light and an Echo Dot speaker: a press texts a family member, and the light turns green with a spoken message to show it was sent, but nothing shows whether it was seen, and no second contact is tried. A patent filed in 2006 and granted in 2011 for a bedside video system (US7965309B2) had a "Call Family" button that shows "calling Rick" while a request is made and fades when the option is unavailable. None of these was found evaluated. The ViewClix smart frame, sold as "a senior-friendly smart frame", also leaves every call to the family, but its FAQ says "Seniors can request a video call using ViewClix's Call-Me feature", which sends the family member an SMS text. No evaluation of this feature was found in Europe PMC, and it still needs someone at the other end who answers: it does nothing for the 97 in the trial whom nobody contacted. GrandPad, a tablet for older adults, has been studied as a telehealth tool (two implementation case studies, abstract read).

What would unlock progress

Give the older person a minimal "send" as well as "receive", without bringing back the complexity that excluded them, starting from what the products on sale leave open. One-touch calling (Konnekt), voice calling (Echo), request texts (ViewClix Call-Me) and "Call Me" buttons sent to a call list (GrandCare) all exist, but none was found evaluated with this group, the do-it-yourself and GrandCare buttons show at most that a request was sent, and none of the pages read says what the older person is told when nobody answers. The open design question is a single tangible action that tells chosen people "I'd like a call" or "thinking of you", shows the older person whether it was seen and answered, falls through to someone else when nobody answers, and makes the screen's silence visible to the family side. The interviews add three practical needs: getting the person's attention when they are dozing or the TV is on; set-up that works when the main contact is a friend, not a tech-able relative; and a clear "on" state, since screens switched off by the user block all contact. Because municipal care staff never used the device as planned, a service that guarantees some contact for people with thin networks is the other half of the fix, and outside a design team's reach (Abilia now sells a care-staff version, Komp Pro, for "welfare checks, medication prompts, and social connection visits"; no evaluation of it was read); the device can at least report when it has gone unused.

How we’d know it’s being solved

(a) The share of delivered devices that are never contacted falls well below 97 of 150. (b) Contact initiated by the older person (a request signal or call) becomes a measurable share of all activity, where today it is zero by design. (c) Weekly activity per user rises above 1.1, with fewer screens left switched off. (d) Uptake among those offered rises above 42%, including among more able and more independent older people, who previously turned Komp down. (e) In a future trial, an effect on loneliness or home-dwelling, measured on everyone offered, not only on users.

Where to start

Facility-free door (make a thing): the screen itself exists, phones already call out, and one-action routes are already sold: Konnekt's one-touch named call buttons with backup numbers, voice calling on an Echo, ViewClix's "Call-Me" text request, and GrandCare's "Call Me" buttons that alert a call list (a do-it-yourself version with a Flic button and a light that turns green when sent is also published). So the object is a "send" for someone who cannot use a phone that also covers the unanswered request. Do not rebuild a button that only sends a text or only shows "sent": start with a short desk survey of these routes, and build only the part none of them covers, which is telling the older person whether the request was seen and answered and what happens when nobody answers. Then design and build a single physical "I'd like a call" control that sits beside a TV or chair, for example a large knob, a lift-off tile or a squeeze object, not an app or a screen menu. It sends a "please call me" or "thinking of you" message to chosen contacts through a microcontroller with Wi-Fi, and the object itself shows the person what happened: sent, seen, passed on, or nobody yet. A request nobody answers passes on to a second chosen contact, and the family side is told when the object has gone unused. Add an attention cue for a person dozing or watching TV (a light or chime the user can tell apart from the television and the phone: in the interviews one man repeatedly confused Komp's content with the television, and one woman had to be directed to talk at Komp rather than into her phone during video calls). No partner or data is needed beyond a makerspace and a free messaging service. User door: the users are older people living at home who find smartphones hard, and the relatives or friends who would receive their requests. A team can reach them within a term through a senior centre or a sheltered-housing common room; where they have adult children or friends, those can be asked to take part from their own phones. In short supervised sessions, test, against the existing routes (a mock-up of a "Call-Me" request button, a mock-up of a large one-touch named call button, and phoning a relative to ask for a screen call), whether the request object is understood without instruction, can be operated with weak hands or poor sight, and does not feel "for demented people", which was one woman's reason for refusing Komp; ask relatives how they would want to receive requests and what they would do with one nobody else answered. What carries over to the frail home-nursing recipients in Oslo (mean age 84.6): whether the control is understood, can be handled and is accepted. What does not carry over: people who come to a senior centre may be more able and better connected than the trial's participants, so these sessions cannot show whether requests get answered for people with thin networks. A home trial of use and loneliness is designed, not run: write a protocol that counts unused devices and user-initiated contacts as outcomes. Testing with people needs the campus's ethics review; any work with people with dementia is design-the-test only. Relevant skills: product and interaction design, embedded electronics, gerontology.

Genes

Related problems

Stuck the same way, in other fields.

field: health & medicinewhen the skin says it's fineJapan's draft heat manual tells older people not to trust their own sense of heat indoors and to read a room thermometer instead, but in a Saitama comparison a free sticker thermometer did not change reported air-conditioner hours and a quarter rarely looked at it, a small randomised trial of heat-index monitors found no difference, and in a Canadian lab trial fans eased how older adults felt without lowering peak core temperaturebuilt without the people who'd live with itsource: primaryfield: health & medicinea chair for the road, not the floorIndia's free wheelchair scheme hands out standard fixed-arm chairs at camps with little fitting, into rural homes where life happens on the floor; a 2021 review heard of chairs breaking within months and being sold as scrap, and in one Delhi hospital sample only 5% had ever had an assessmentbuilt without the people who'd live with itsource: primaryfield: health & medicineinvisible to the systemCervical screening coverage ranges from 0.7% to 93% across low- and middle-income countries, held back by low awareness, distance, cost and the pelvic exambuilt without the people who'd live with itsource: primaryfield: health & medicinedesigned for the young, prescribed for the oldDigital health technologies fall short at adoption for older adults despite potential benefitsbuilt without the people who'd live with itsource: primary

Sources

  • Eikemo K, Malmberg-Heimonen I, Rasmussen EB, Thordardottir BSA, Tøge AG, van der Wel KA. "The effect of digital communication technology on older adults' formal care use in Norway: a randomized controlled trial." BMC geriatrics 2026;26(1):713, doi:10.1186/s12877-026-07322-z, accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • Bavngaard MV, Lund A, Rasmussen EB. "Domestication as Stabilisation: Exploring the Incorporation of Social Technology by Older Adults and Their Relatives." Sociology of health & illness 2026;48(1):e70131, doi:10.1111/1467-9566.70131, accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • Børve Rasmussen E, Askheim C, Oppedal B, Haldar M. "Varm teknologi mot ensomhet blant eldre?" Tidsskrift for samfunnsforskning 2021;62(4):353-372, doi:10.18261/issn.1504-291x-2021-04-03 (read in full, in Norwegian), accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • Hansen T, Johansen R, Kirkøen B, et al. "Digital bridges to social connection: A systematic review and meta-analysis of digital interventions for loneliness and social isolation." Internet Interventions 2025;41:100856, doi:10.1016/j.invent.2025.100856 (abstract read via the Europe PMC record), accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • Meier Z, Buchtova M, Sandora J, et al. "Efficacy of Technology-Based Interventions on the Reduction of Loneliness: Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis." Journal of Medical Internet Research 2026;28:e80059, doi:10.2196/80059 (abstract read via the Europe PMC record), accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • Tha SH, Hough K, Bui N, Dulaney S, Perissinotto C. "The Use of Age-Friendly Technology in the Care of Older Adults: Two Implementation Case Studies." Journal of Applied Gerontology 2026;45(3):515-526 (published online 2025), doi:10.1177/07334648251343513 (abstract read via the Europe PMC record), accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • Komp, "Komp – familien aldri langt unna | Videosamtaler for eldre" (Komp's Norwegian sales site, with its FAQ), accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • Abilia, "Virtual care delivery - Komp Pro" (maker's page), accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • ViewClix, "ViewClix FAQ for setup, shipping, video calls, and daily use" (maker's page), accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • Konnekt, "One-Touch Seniors Videophone" (maker's page), accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • Konnekt, "How It Works" (maker's page), accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • Konnekt, "Phone for Seniors" (maker's page, with its sales partners), accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • GrandCare Systems, "Action Buttons" (maker's help page), accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • The Senior List, "Alexa for Seniors: Using Alexa to Age in Place" (consumer guide), accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • Asurion, "How to activate and use the Alexa Drop In feature" (consumer guide), accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • Oslo kommune, "Trygghetsalarm" (municipal service page, in Norwegian), accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • Engelman F. "A non-emergency "Call Me" lighted button that speaks reassurance to your elderly parent." Frank's Easy Tech Corner, 2023 (hobbyist post), accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • Mattila EW, Moote SR (Quickwolf Tech Inc). "Bedside video communication system." US patent US7965309B2, filed 2006-10-24, granted 2011-06-21, accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
Revision notes

This brief gets checked against its sources and contains the following revisions. Future revisions get added here.

Worth knowing

  • No evaluation was found of the one-touch call and call-request products the page lists; what they do comes from sellers', help and hobbyist pages.

Full check

Sources read

  • Eikemo and others, Oslo trial of the one-button video screen (2026): full text
  • Bavngaard and others, interviews with screen users and relatives (2026): full text
  • Rasmussen, Askheim, Oppedal and Haldar, analysis of the screen's built-in expectations (2021): full text (read in the Norwegian original)
  • Komp's Norwegian sales site and FAQ: full text
  • AbilityNet, Komp FAQ (2021): full text
  • Abilia, Komp Pro page: full text
  • ViewClix FAQ: full text
  • The Senior List, Alexa for seniors; Asurion, Alexa Drop In: full text
  • Oslo kommune, safety alarm page: full text (read in Norwegian)
  • Konnekt, one-touch videophone, seniors phone and how-it-works pages: full text
  • GrandCare help page on action buttons: full text
  • Engelman, home-built 'call me' button (blog post, 2023): full text
  • US patent 7,965,309, bedside video communication system: full text (front page and the relevant columns read from the patent images)
  • Hansen and others, review of social contact interventions (2025): abstract only
  • Meier and others, review of technology-based interventions for loneliness (2026): abstract only
  • Tha and others, telehealth implementation study (2026): abstract only

What changed

  • Not found in the sources, removed: the user door's claim that many older people have adult children willing to take part from their own phones; it now says such relatives or friends can be asked where they exist.
  • Credit: the FAQ quoted on whether Komp can call out was called the maker's; the site read names a sales company and neither the original maker nor its buyer, so the page now calls it the FAQ on Komp's own sales site.

Left open

  • that no evaluation of the one-touch call and request products was found (a record of the page's own searches)

Separate check of specific claims: The two different screen counts are now explained from the trial paper (300 screens available, 150 delivered), who led the project is given in the trial paper's own words, and citations for the sources the page uses were added to its source list.

Earlier full check: Twelve statements were brought in line with the sources, among them 'like most of Europe' (now 'like other Western countries'), 'common' (now 'one response'), 'pragmatic' trial (removed), the order of events for one interviewee, a remote-control detail no source gives, a help page that does not show the buttons are on sale, and a patent called expired that is now described as filed in 2006 and granted in 2011.

Separate check of specific claims: A search for existing products found one-touch outgoing calls and call-request buttons already sold or described (Konnekt, GrandCare, smart-speaker calling, a home-built button, an older patent), so the unsolved part is now a way to reach out that tells the older person whether anyone heard.

Separate check of specific claims: The make-a-thing door now says not to rebuild an existing call-request feature, adds a check of what is sold, and defines the object as a physical 'I'd like a call' control that shows what happened to the request; the user door names who the users are and what carries over.

Earlier full check: The full title now says the trial assigned 516 people to be offered the screen (only 359 were actually offered; display title unchanged); the maker is now named correctly, an existing call-request feature and two newer reviews were added, and a staff-use sentence and two interview details now follow the papers.