Skip to content
problem genome

One of 592 unsolved problems in the Problem Genome, a collection written up for student design and engineering teams.

health · infrastructure

a chair for the road, not the floor

India's free wheelchair scheme hands out standard fixed-arm chairs at camps with little fitting, into rural homes where life happens on the floor; a 2021 review heard of chairs breaking within months and being sold as scrap, and in one Delhi hospital sample only 5% had ever had an assessment

Source: Gupta et al., “A Narrative Review of the Government Wheelchair Provision…” Open ↗source: primaryLast updated: 2026-11-17

Problem statement

Since 1981, India's Assistance to Disabled Persons (ADIP) scheme has given free wheelchairs and other aids to people with disabilities on low incomes. It is the country's largest assistive-technology programme. Most devices are handed out at camps: in the seven years to 2020, about 1.8 million people received devices, mostly through 9,460 camps. The wheelchairs come from one state manufacturer, ALIMCO. A 2021 review led by a researcher at an Indian disability-policy centre found it offers "only three basic models of wheelchairs for adults," none with postural support or a seat cushion (one adult folding model has a detachable arm). The scheme's 2024 list of approved devices now adds a cushion and an adjustable "active" chair, but the adjustable chair is to be given only at the agencies' own centres, not at camps. The standard adult folding chair on that list has fixed armrests and a fixed footrest. India has recognised the WHO guidelines for fitting wheelchairs in less-resourced settings, and implementers got a two-day orientation, but a wheelchair-service professional told the reviewers they are "not followed." The chairs also do not fit the homes they go to. Observed in villages in Andhra Pradesh, people could not transfer themselves and had to be lifted. Most chairs had no detachable arms, so lifting the person in was hard for family members. In rural homes, sitting, sleeping and eating happen on the floor, so people were lifted from the floor into the chair, and indoors they "had to make do with dragging themselves." The unsolved problem is a wheelchair, or a kit for the one already supplied, that fits a person and a floor-level home and can be handed out at camp scale. Nothing on the 2024 list helps a family get a person from the floor to the seat.

Why this matters

The review cites national data that only 20% of people with disabilities who need a mobility device have been advised to get one, and only 16% of those have one. Of these, about one fifth got the device through a government scheme. Chairs that are handed out often go unused. The review reports "a high percentage of rejection," and reports it cites say some users sell the wheelchair as scrap. One informant called the chairs "like disposable products. They break in about three months." The government's own evaluations, as summarised in a 2023 overview of the scheme, are more positive but point the same way on upkeep. A 2013 Planning Commission study found a mixed response on quality and that many beneficiaries sold tricycles that were not working properly. A 2021 evaluation found 87% of beneficiaries called their appliances good quality, and 19% had trouble getting repairs. The overview adds that appliances can become non-functional "within six months or a year," while a new one is allowed only after three years. (These figures cover all aids, not wheelchairs alone, and the evaluations themselves were not read.) In a survey published in 2026 of 100 wheelchair users and people advised to use one at the All India Institute of Medical Sciences in New Delhi, 82% had a wheelchair not in use or needing replacement. Most of these chairs were not from the government: about 10% came from the public sector, and most were bought privately or given by family or NGOs. Only 5% had ever had a wheelchair assessment and training. Nearly half were lifted in and out of the chair (48 of 100 in the paper's table; its text says 47%), 31 were assisted and 21 transferred on their own. Fit, size or shape was the top reason for dissatisfaction (34%), and 36 of 100 named fit, size or shape problems as a reason they did not use the chair they had. Road and transport difficulties (63) and work and school access (53) were the main reasons for non-use (the paper's abstract calls the second one home access). The study's own conclusion calls for wheelchair services to be built into the health system.

What’s been tried and why it hasn’t worked

(1) Free supply at scale. Under the rules the 2021 review studied, ADIP gave a free device to anyone with at least 40% disability and a household income under INR 15,000 a month, within an aid cost ceiling of INR 10,000 (about US$135), with a new wheelchair allowed every three years. The September 2024 revision raised these limits: the full cost is paid for incomes up to INR 22,500 a month (half for INR 22,501 to 30,000), and aids costing up to INR 15,000 are fully covered. This reaches large numbers, but the 2021 review found that "wheelchair services are largely absent" and that the budget had no heading for maintenance or follow-up. The 2024 rules now require implementing agencies to maintain the devices they supply free of charge, and plan a mobile app for repair requests; no source read says whether this has changed practice. Getting a chair can take three trips (documents, an assessment camp, a fitting camp) and sometimes more than a year's wait. (2) Training providers in the WHO guidelines. A wheelchair-service professional interviewed for the review, whose organisation had stopped asking for scheme funds, said the two-day orientation "never became a part of the system," so chairs and tricycles "are distributed en masse, without a cushion." She added that fitting would not help anyway, "as there are no wheelchair options available," and that camps are too large for individual attention. (3) Quality standards. India has recently adopted the ISO 7176 wheelchair standards. A 2025 paper reports tests at an ISO-compliant laboratory at Mobility India in Bangalore on five manual wheelchairs commonly used in India (full text read). Three failed the durability tests: two with structural failures, and one stopped after repeated caster failures. One imported chair and one locally made economy chair passed, and the authors call the local model the most cost-effective. Durability standards address chairs breaking, but not the fit or the floor-to-chair transfer. (4) Service models elsewhere. In Indonesia, users who got chairs through WHO-style eight-step services were compared with users who got hospital-style chairs without service. The groups were too different for a statistical comparison, and breakdowns were common in both (28.8% and 8%). Use and skills fell over three to six months, and the authors call for routine maintenance. Service alone does not fix the product. (5) Chairs designed for rough ground. The Leveraged Freedom Chair (MIT, sold through GRIT and in production in India), Motivation's Rough Terrain chair and Whirlwind's RoughRider are rough-ground chairs: the first is described by its makers as an all-terrain chair for rural areas, and the other two are often distributed in low-resource settings. Their published tests measure propulsion, mobility and skills on test tracks: in rural Laos the Leveraged Freedom Chair showed no statistical difference in bouts of mobility over five days from locally made chairs (high variability), and in a comparison Motivation's chair beat the RoughRider on rough and smooth tracks (abstract read). None of the results read addresses getting from floor level into the seat, or a chair used indoors in a floor-level home. (6) The adjustable chair already on the list. ADIP's 2024 list includes an active folding wheelchair (up to INR 15,000) with a pressure-relief cushion and adjustable seat depth, footrest and backrest. It is to be given only through headquarter activity by ALIMCO and national or regional centres, so camp recipients still get the standard chair. (7) Floor-to-seat aids made elsewhere. These exist, but none is built for this setting. Ralf Hotchkiss, the Whirlwind designer, made a cloth "jump seat" slung halfway between the wheelchair seat and the ground: the rider "can first lift himself onto the low-level seat, and from there, into the wheelchair seat." Two occupational-therapy students at the University of British Columbia designed ChairStairs, two fold-out scissor steps of 6 inches that attach under the seat for wheelchair-to-ground transfers. They had done no testing with users, and the user needs good trunk control and enough arm strength to climb the steps. The ChairStairs paper cites an earlier student design, the "Lift Me Up" device (University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, 2010): a gas-spring scissor-lift platform, 22 inches high when raised and 5 when lowered, that lets one assistant move an 8-year-old girl with a spinal cord injury between wheelchair height and the floor; she slides across onto it and partly lifts herself on its armrests to raise it, no weight limit is given, and the prototype was tried with her alone (materials US$544.44). In 1996 a Queen's University engineering thesis designed a ground-level device (GADI) for women with disabilities in rural India. It keeps the rider near the floor instead of lifting them into a chair (abstract read). At a rehabilitation centre in Dhaka, Bangladesh, low trolleys are often used instead of wheelchairs, because people eat and cook at ground level. All of these serve a person who can lift themselves in stages, or they replace the chair with a floor device. None is meant for a family member helping someone who cannot lift themselves into the scheme's fixed-arm chair, and none of the sources read reports a field test; Lift Me Up was tried only with its one client.

What would unlock progress

A product that matches how people live, not only a better-built chair. The review names the gaps: arms that come off for a sideways transfer, a way to get from the floor to the seat without a full lift, a cushion, a chair usable indoors as well as on the road, and adjustments that a camp team can make without a therapist. The test published in 2025 shows a locally made economy chair (INR 14,750) can pass the ISO durability tests at about half the price of the imported chair that also passed; the cheapest chair tested (INR 8,700), a model the authors say is distributed through government and non-government schemes, failed. The adjustable chair already on the 2024 list shows the scheme will pay for fit, but only at centres. The design target is what the camp channel still lacks: a kit for the standard chair (listed at up to INR 8,000) that costs little enough to hand out at camp scale, is fitted in minutes at a camp, can be set up by someone with little training, and can be repaired by a family. The 2024 rules apply the INR 15,000 limit to each item separately in two named cases (multiple disabilities, and several limbs or parts involved in the same disability), and allow additional manual devices "but not for the same purpose"; they do not say how a transfer aid used with the chair would be costed, and no transfer aid is on the approved list. The floor-to-seat transfer is the part nothing on the scheme's list addresses. The aids made elsewhere (a jump seat, fold-out steps) are for people who can lift themselves; one student platform (Lift Me Up) lets one assistant move a child who slides across and partly lifts herself. A transfer that a family helps with, for an adult who cannot lift themselves, into a fixed-arm chair, is still open.

How we’d know it’s being solved

(a) Fewer handed-out chairs found unused at follow-up. The Delhi figure of 82% with a chair not in use or needing replacement is a rough reference point, not a baseline for scheme chairs, because few chairs in that sample came from the government. (b) Fewer users naming fit, size or shape as a reason for dissatisfaction or non-use (34% and 36 of 100 in Delhi). (c) Family members report that transfers from the floor take less lifting, measured with a simple carer-effort rating. (d) The chair or kit passes the ISO 7176-8 durability test that three of five common models failed. (e) The kit costs well within the ADIP limit of INR 15,000 for one aid.

Where to start

Make door (a floor-to-seat transfer aid; facility-free): Start from the gap the scheme's own list leaves. The camp chair (the standard adult folding model, up to INR 8,000) has fixed armrests and a fixed footrest. The list already has a cushion (INR 2,100) and an adjustable chair, but the adjustable chair is given only at centres. The only chairs on the list with "Removable armrests for sideways ingress and egress" are the two motorised joystick models, which are also supplied only through the manufacturer and the national and regional centres. The rough-ground chairs above were tested on propulsion, mobility and track skills. Staged floor-to-seat aids do exist: Hotchkiss's cloth jump seat halfway between seat and ground, and the ChairStairs fold-out steps under the seat. But both are for a rider who lifts themselves, and ChairStairs had not been tested with users when it was written up. A helper-operated platform also exists: Lift Me Up, which lets one assistant move an 8-year-old between the floor and wheelchair height, but she slides across and partly lifts herself, and it was tried only with her. In the Andhra Pradesh villages, people could not transfer themselves; families lifted them from the floor, where people in these homes sit, sleep and eat. So do not design a new wheelchair, a new cushion, or another self-transfer step. Start from the jump seat, the fold-out steps and the Lift Me Up platform, and make the version a family helper can use with an adult who cannot lift themselves, into the fixed-arm chair: (a) a free-standing aid for getting between the floor and the seat in stages instead of one full lift, such as a low, stable step or platform with a slide board; or (b) an attachment for the standard chair that does the same job, such as a lift-off or swing-away arm clamp that opens the fixed-arm frame for a sideways slide, with a board that hooks onto it. Build from plywood, tube clamps and foam in an ordinary workshop. Cost target: the 2024 rules do not say how a transfer aid used with the chair would be costed, so aim well below the standard chair's INR 8,000 so a camp can hand it out at scale. Log how long a novice takes to fit or set it up from a one-page picture guide. Safety: no wheelchair user and no person with a disability tests a student transfer aid with their body weight. Strength, tipping and slipping are tested with weights or a test dummy, under repeated load. Able-bodied team members may try the movement only at low height, with a spotter and a mat. No partner or restricted data is needed.

User door (advise and rate): The real users, wheelchair users in rural Indian homes and the families who lift them, cannot be reached from an ordinary campus within a term. Wheelchair users near campus are stand-ins, reached through a campus disability office or a local disability or independent-living group. They advise and rate: they look at mock-ups, try an arm release from their own seat, and rate drawings and videos of the dummy tests. They do not transfer on a student prototype. What carries over: how a sideways transfer works, where hands and a board go, whether an arm release can be worked from the seat, and how much effort a carer should need. What does not carry over: floor-level living (sitting, sleeping and eating on the floor), the scheme's chair, rural Indian homes and roads, and family lifting as the normal way in. Sessions need the campus's ethics review.

Field-test door (design the test): The field test is designed, not run: a protocol for a camp-based implementing agency comparing kit and no-kit users at three and six months. It would use the Delhi study's measures (use, fit, dissatisfaction reasons) plus a carer-effort rating for floor transfers, with ethics review in India. Relevant skills: mechanical and industrial design, ergonomics, cost engineering, field-trial design.

Genes

Related problems

Stuck the same way, in other fields.

field: society & learninga screen that can only waitAn Oslo trial assigned 516 frail older people living at home to be offered a one-button video screen: 150 took one, 97 of those screens were never contacted by anyone, and home-dwelling was not prolonged, while some users felt the receive-only design made them passivebuilt without the people who'd live with itsource: primaryfield: society & learningtherapy built for specialists, needed in a campMental health care for displaced people leans on scarce specialists, while stigma, language and culture keep many from the services that existbuilt without the people who'd live with itsource: primaryfield: society & learningthe senior gym few older australians useAustralian councils install park exercise equipment built for older people, but in two Melbourne parks under 3% of older visitors were seen using it, a randomised trial of QR codes and guided sessions did not raise use among people over 60, and the council programme that did raise it runs on weekly volunteer sessionsbuilt without the people who'd live with itsource: primaryfield: the built worldone lead supplier, three fuels that won't mixThe last leaded transportation fuel has one tetraethyl-lead supplier who has signalled an end to production — and its three unleaded replacements are not approved to be mixed with each other, so some 3,200 mostly single-tank airports must each choose one fuel before 2030built without the people who'd live with itsource: primary

Sources

  • Gupta S, Meershoek A, De Witte L. "A Narrative Review of the Government Wheelchair Provision System in India." International journal of environmental research and public health 2021;18(10):5109, doi:10.3390/ijerph18105109, accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • Srishti J, Avijit B, Gita H. "Patterns and unmet needs in wheelchair utilization: A mixed-method study of user experience at a tertiary hospital in India." Journal of rehabilitation and assistive technologies engineering 2026;13:20556683251397326, doi:10.1177/20556683251397326, accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • Ghosh R, Behera P, Ghosh Moulic S, Raju S, Mhatre A. "Raising wheelchair quality in India using international testing standards." Disability and rehabilitation. Assistive technology 2025;20(8):2830-2835, doi:10.1080/17483107.2025.2475146 (full text through the library; record via Europe PMC), accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗ Link 2 ↗
  • Government of India, Department of Empowerment of Persons with Disabilities, Office Memorandum of 09.07.2024, "Notification of Comprehensive List of Aids and Assistive Devices approved for distribution under Scheme of Assistance to Persons with Disabilities for Purchase/Fitting of Aids /Appliances (ADIP Scheme)", accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • Rispin K, Wee J. "Comparison between performances of three types of manual wheelchairs often distributed in low-resource settings." Disability and Rehabilitation: Assistive Technology 2015;10(4):316-322, doi:10.3109/17483107.2014.1002541 (abstract), accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • Stanfill CJ, Jensen JL. "Effect of wheelchair design on wheeled mobility and propulsion efficiency in less-resourced settings." African Journal of Disability 2017;6:342, doi:10.4102/ajod.v6i0.342, accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • Government of India, Department of Empowerment of Persons with Disabilities (Divyangjan), Office Memorandum No. 4-2(12)/2020-DD-I-Part(1) of 26.09.2024, "Revision of Scheme of Assistance to Persons with Disabilities for Purchase/Fitting of Aids/Appliances (ADIP Scheme) during the period of 15th Finance Commission i.e. from 01.04.2022 to 31.03.2026-reg.", accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • Werner D. "Nothing About Us Without Us: Developing Innovative Technologies For, By and With Disabled Persons", Part Four, Chapter 30 "Evolution of the Whirlwind Wheelchair", section "4. A Jump Step and Toilet Seat for a Wheelchair" (pp. 192–194), DINF, accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • Kellett A, Turner J. "Chairstairs: An Assistive Technology Device For Independent Wheelchair-To-Ground Transfers." RESNA Student Design Competition 2015, accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • Gupta A, Haac J, Khan N, Rao V, Goldberg R, Caves K. "“Lift Me Up” Device." RESNA Student Design Competition 2010 participant, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, posted 19 May 2010 (original RESNA Student Design Competition page no longer available; read from the Internet Archive copy), accessed 2026-11-17; Lysack JT. "The Design and Development of an Appropriate Wheeled Mobility Device for Women With Disabilities in India: An Engineering Perspective" [Master's thesis]. Queen's University, August 1996 (abstract), accessed 2026-11-17; MIT GEAR Lab, "LFC Wheelchair", accessed 2026-11-17; Dhar R, Roy C. "ADIP Scheme: An Analytical Overview." Manpower Journal, Vol. LVII, Nos. 3 & 4, July – December, 2023, accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗ Link 2 ↗ Link 3 ↗ Link 4 ↗
Revision notes

This brief gets checked against its sources and contains the following revisions. Future revisions get added here.

Worth knowing

  • the display title rests on one source; two others call the scheme's standard chair an indoor chair
  • the 82% of chairs unused in the Delhi sample mostly did not come from the scheme

Full check

Sources read

  • Gupta, Meershoek & De Witte, review of India's wheelchair scheme (2021): full text
  • Delhi hospital study of wheelchair users (2026): full text
  • Ghosh et al., durability tests of wheelchairs in India (2025): full text
  • D'Innocenzo et al., Indonesia wheelchair study (2021): full text
  • Stanfill & Jensen, wheelchair design in less-resourced settings (2017): full text
  • Senjam et al., satisfaction with assistive devices in India (Scientific Reports, 2025): full text
  • Nisha & Balamurugan, scheme distribution 2020 to 2025 (2026): full text
  • Rispin & Wee, three wheelchair types compared (2015): abstract only
  • Mhatre (2017) and Brien et al. (2024): abstract only
  • Government of India, 2024 scheme rules and approved-device list: full text
  • Werner, Nothing About Us Without Us, chapter 30: full text
  • Kellett & Turner, ChairStairs (RESNA student design competition): full text
  • UNC Chapel Hill, 'Lift Me Up' device (RESNA student design competition, 2010): full text (read from an archived copy)
  • Lysack, ground-level mobility device thesis (Queen's University, 1996): abstract only
  • Dhar & Roy, analytical overview of the scheme (Manpower Journal, 2023): full text
  • CAG audit chapter on Rajasthan disability schemes: full text (checked in part)
  • MIT GEAR Lab, Leveraged Freedom Chair page: full text

What changed

  • Not found in the sources, replaced with what they say: the rough-ground chair tests were said to measure outdoor skills; they measured propulsion, mobility and track skills; ChairStairs' designers are now described as two occupational-therapy students at the University of British Columbia; the paper names no country.
  • Stated more strongly than the source: devices were given out 'mostly' through the 9,460 camps; only the results read are said not to address the floor-to-seat transfer, since one paper was read as an abstract; low trolleys are used instead of wheelchairs at one rehabilitation centre in Dhaka, not across Bangladesh; ChairStairs had not been tested with users when it was written up.
  • Credit: the person who said WHO guidelines are not followed is now described as a wheelchair-service professional whose organisation had stopped asking for scheme funds; the gaps the unlock lists are credited to the review as a whole; the cushion and fitting points come from its interviews, not the village observations.
  • Dates: the Delhi survey and the durability tests are now dated by publication, since neither paper says when the work was done; ChairStairs' year was removed; nothing on the paper supports one.
  • Entry points: the make starting point now builds on the jump seat, the fold-out steps and the Lift Me Up platform, and aims at a transfer a family helps with, for an adult who cannot lift themselves, into a fixed-arm chair.
  • Other: an earlier student design was added: a platform that let one helper move an 8-year-old between floor and chair height, tried only with her.

Left open

  • the ground-level device in the 1996 thesis (read only as an abstract)
  • the 2013 and 2021 government evaluations (known only from a published summary)

Separate check of specific claims: Two findings were added (nearly half the Delhi users were lifted in and out of the chair; only the motorised chairs on the scheme list have removable armrests), and citations were added to the source list.

Earlier full check: A local chair's durability result was given with its price (nearly twice the scheme chair's, while the cheapest chair tested failed), the count of structural failures was corrected, how the scheme's cost limit applies was restated, and the durability paper was read in full.

Separate check of specific claims: A search added earlier floor-to-seat aids made elsewhere (a jump seat, fold-out steps, a ground-level device) and government evaluations of the scheme, and a kit budget that misread the scheme's rules was removed.

Separate check of specific claims: The make starting point became a floor-to-seat transfer aid rather than a new chair or cushion, with a rule that no disabled person tests it with body weight; the user starting point uses stand-in wheelchair users, with an ethics line.

Earlier full check: The scheme's 2024 rules and device list replaced older figures, the Delhi 82% figure is no longer treated as a baseline for scheme chairs, and the long title was toned down, with breakage and resale now credited to the 2021 review.