Skip to content
problem genome

One of 592 unsolved problems in the Problem Genome, a collection written up for student design and engineering teams.

health · digital

the planner needs a partner

Sweden prescribes clocks and digital planners to people with dementia, but in Swedish interview studies they did not make time management independent: a partner still sets them up and prompts their use, and people without a partner's support risk missing out

Source: Persson et al., “Daily time management in dementia: qualitative interviews…” Open ↗source: primaryLast updated: 2026-11-17

Problem statement

Losing track of time starts early in dementia: what day it is, whether it is morning or evening, what is coming next. In Sweden, occupational therapists at memory clinics prescribe time aids for this. The simpler ones are electronic clocks that show the day, date and part of the day. The advanced ones are digital planners with a schedule and spoken reminders. People with dementia and their partners like them, and all 15 interviewees in one study would recommend their aid. But the Swedish studies agree on what the aids do not do. In interviews with people who had used their aid for at least three months, "Time AT could support time orientation … but did not enable independent time management." The easy clocks did not say what was going to happen. The advanced planners were set up and run by the partner, who then reminded the person to look at them. In a study of eight carers of people with early dementia (six) or mild cognitive impairment (two) using a common digital planner (MEMOplanner), it "did not reduce the need for assistance from the informal carers." (The same paper's discussion is more hopeful: all eight carers said there had been "a significant change in time management" since the planner arrived, which its authors read as implying that it "helps the user become independent"; the paper makes both statements.) Carers had not had time to learn all its functions, and some doubted it would be used when the person was home alone. Occupational therapists describe the same dependence from their side. Prescription is "complex and time-consuming," it works best when a partner takes part, and people with no support from a partner or other close person "are at risk not receiving or fully benefitting from time AT." A Swedish randomised trial found a modest benefit but enrolled only people who had such a person. The authors of the therapist study also conclude that there is "a gap between easy-to-use and advanced time AT." The unsolved problem is a time aid that tells a person with dementia what comes next. It should not need a partner to program it, prompt its use, or learn its functions first.

Why this matters

The goal of the aid is independence at home, especially during the hours a person spends alone. The 2023 study found that responsibility for time management moved to the partner early in dementia. People with dementia felt that as "a sense of defeat," and also as a relief that someone they trusted had taken over. Partners felt sorrow. Questions about time and what would happen next kept coming back, though some partners said they did not mind them. In the 2020 study, therapists said the questions became tiring, especially when the two lived apart and the person phoned day and night. The people who most need an aid that works alone, those living alone or whose partner works, are the ones the current aids serve worst. Therapists said that without a close person "you can really only consider the simplest assistive technology," and some aids could not be prescribed at all. The 2023 study recruited mostly spouses and names people living alone as a group to include in future research.

What’s been tried and why it hasn’t worked

(1) Easy electronic clocks showing date, day and part of the day. These are easy to start using, cut down questions about the time, and gave a feeling of security. But they "did not inform participants as to what was going to happen," and some people also kept regular calendars, and partners still had to put the time in context. (2) Advanced planners with a schedule and reminders. These can reassure a partner that the person will eat on time when home alone. But the partner "first took care of the time management and administration … and then provided reminders to use it," and partners said such a device may only help "for a limited period of time" and must be introduced early. In the MEMOplanner study, therapists gave 1 to 2 hours of training, but carers "did not have the time to learn other functions," and saw it as "a calendar … hung up in their kitchen." The study's authors add that users "may not always act upon the reminder or alarm." (3) A randomised trial. In a multicentre Swedish trial (73 people with mild to moderate dementia recruited, 57 followed for three months), people given individually prescribed time aids rated their satisfaction with performance on their own time-related goals higher than a waiting-list group did (p = .028). The between-group difference for performance itself was not significant (p = .053). The intervention group improved by 2.8 points on a 10-point scale, past the clinically meaningful 2-point mark, but the waiting-list group also improved by 1.6. In the complete-case sensitivity analysis no test was significant. The trial says little about planners: 24 of the 26 people in the intervention group got easy clocks, and only 2 got aids that also support planning. Having a significant other was required to join, and no record was kept of how much help each person got with the aid. The authors conclude that time aids can help and "should be considered," and also call the evidence base "weak." (4) Weekly boards, including magnetic boards with symbols and a voice note recorder, were among the prescribed aids. In the 2023 interviews these too were run with a partner's help: "you have to remind him to check. Look, it's right there." (5) Remote planning. The maker of MEMOplanner now offers a web service through which relatives and support persons can "remotely help plan activities or see if activities have been completed and acknowledged." That still needs a relative or support person to do the planning.

Positive findings beyond Sweden: in a 2026 uncontrolled study in India (38 people with dementia and their caregivers), scores changed little and not significantly, but interviewees described more confidence about the time and doing valued activities "more independently." They also said such aids would suit people living alone.

What would unlock progress

An aid built for the hours when no one else is there. The sources point to the gap between the two existing kinds, which the 2020 study names directly. Easy clocks need no setup but give no "what next," and planners give "what next" but need someone to program them and prompt their use. Boards set by placing symbols or picture cards exist, and showing the time against the plan is not new: MEMOplanner's own product sheet describes a timeline in which the day "is displayed as illuminated dots that fade as time passes", and an electronic planner in the India study uses magnetic activity cards with a light for every quarter hour that goes off as time passes. In that study, though, caregivers reported that people with dementia had difficulty understanding the passage of time shown by the small lights, and caregivers found the advanced devices "complex to operate or manage." But in the Swedish interviews the weekly boards still needed a partner to say "look," and MEMOplanner users "may not always act upon the reminder or alarm." Prompts that announce themselves have been tried nearby. In a home study of tablet prompts set up by care partners from a printed manual, raters scored "91 (43.3%) trials as involving participants with dementia initiating the day's task themselves and 119 (56.7%) trials as involving support from the care partner" (Cannings et al. 2024). In a US pilot trial, a smart home that sensed activity and sounded a chime before each prompt led people to use a memory-aid app more, with the prompts timed by the home's own activity sensing rather than set by a person, but its participants had amnestic mild cognitive impairment, not dementia, and it needs a sensor-fitted home (Schmitter-Edgecombe et al. 2022). Something in between would show now and next, could be set by whoever is present (a home-care visitor, a day-centre driver, the person themselves) without learning menus, and would make sense without a reminder to look at it. Remote planning and completion checks already exist for MEMOplanner, but they still assume a relative or support person is doing the planning. Some carers in the MEMOplanner study doubted it would be used when the person was alone. Any change has to suit early dementia, when the 2023 and 2024 authors say aids are best learned.

How we’d know it’s being solved

(a) The Canadian Occupational Performance Measure on the person's own time-related goals, the primary outcome in the Swedish trial, with performance, not only satisfaction, improving over a waiting-list control. (b) The number of time-related questions the person asks a partner in a day, which kept recurring in the 2023 interviews. (c) Minutes per week a partner or visitor spends setting up and maintaining the aid. (d) Whether the person uses the aid on days they are home alone, observed or logged, not assumed. (e) Whether people living alone, without a partner taking part, get the same benefit. The Swedish trial could not answer this because it required a significant other.

Where to start

Facility-free door (make a thing): card-set boards already exist, including one that shows time passing against the cards (the India study's planner, where caregivers reported that people with dementia had trouble reading its lights), and planners already sound alarms. What no source shows is the partner's "Look, it's right there" built into a board that anyone present can set: the self-announcing prompts tried so far ran on a tablet set up by a care partner or in a sensor-fitted smart home (see What Would Unlock Progress). Make a board set by placing activity cards (lunch, transport, visitor, bed), with no menus, and make and compare two or three ways for the card that comes next to call attention to itself when its time comes (light, sound, movement). The aim is that a person who has not been told to look notices it and can tell what happens next. Build it in cardboard with simple electronics in an ordinary workshop. Test it with campus volunteers who have never seen it. Time how long they take to set a day, and record whether they notice and read the next card without being prompted. Reachable users door: older adults without dementia at a senior centre can stand in for the visitor or partner who sets the board, and test whether setting it is quick and clear. Family carers reached through dementia carer support groups can review the mock-ups against their own routines and say which cue would work on days the person is home alone. Design-the-test door (people with dementia): for people with dementia themselves, the semester deliverable is the design of the test, not the test. Write a home-trial protocol for people with early dementia who live alone, measuring (a)–(e) above against an easy electronic clock, with consent procedures suited to reduced cognitive capacity. It is handed to a memory clinic or assistive technology centre, not run. Ethics review: any testing with people with dementia, including informal mock-up sessions, needs approval from an ethics review board (the Swedish studies were approved by regional ethical review boards) and a clinical partner; students do not recruit people with dementia directly. Relevant skills: interaction and product design, occupational therapy input, gerontology.

Genes

Related problems

Stuck the same way, in other fields.

field: society & learningsurrounded, and still aloneAfter a spouse dies, the loneliness that tracks grief is the kind more company does not easily fix — and a traditional bereavement group in the one trial that measured both kinds moved neitherbuilt without the people who'd live with itsource: primaryfield: society & learninga call someone has to holdCare homes kept residents in touch with family through tablets and mainstream video apps — but in four Quebec homes most residents needed a staff member's help throughout the call because of cognitive and other impairments, and staff judged the calls mostly helped the familiesbuilt without the people who'd live with itsource: primaryfield: society & learningmatched by likeness, missed by needGerman volunteer tandems pair refugees with local mentors to build friendships, but in a randomised evaluation only 85 of 234 refugees offered a place were paired, and those with greater needs were less likely to get a mentorbuilt without the people who'd live with itsource: primaryfield: society & learningthe invisible curriculumStates are betting on "high-quality instructional materials," but only one teacher in five uses a curriculum by the book, and the national count rests on self-reportbuilt without the people who'd live with itsource: secondary

Sources

  • Persson AC, Dahlberg L, Janeslätt G, Möller M, Löfgren M. "Daily time management in dementia: qualitative interviews with persons with dementia and their significant others." BMC geriatrics 2023;23(1):405, doi:10.1186/s12877-023-04032-8, accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • Baudin K, Sundström A, Lindner H. "Informal carers' experiences in everyday life and the use of digital assistive technology for time management in persons with dementia or mild cognitive impairment." BMC geriatrics 2024;24(1):365, doi:10.1186/s12877-024-04979-2, accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • Persson AC, Janeslätt G, Borg J, Dahlberg L, McKee KJ, Löfgren M, Möller MC. "The potential of time-assistive products to improve daily time management in persons with dementia: a randomised controlled trial." Disability and rehabilitation. Assistive technology 2025;20(8):3177-3187, doi:10.1080/17483107.2025.2514546 (open-access full text, DiVA), accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • Persson AC, Boman IL, Dahlberg L, Janeslätt G, Möller MC, Löfgren M. "Lack of time and dependence on significant others: Occupational therapists´ experiences of prescribing time assistive technology for persons with dementia." Scandinavian journal of occupational therapy 2020;27(8):614-624, doi:10.1080/11038128.2020.1751875 (open-access full text, DiVA), accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • Dsouza SA, Bangera K, Acharya V, Guddattu V. "A mixed methods evaluation of time management products for persons with dementia in India: what works, what does not, and what may." BMC geriatrics 2026;26, doi:10.1186/s12877-026-06985-y, accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • Abilia, "MEMOplanner" product sheet ("Overview and reassurance in daily life"), March 2026, accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • Cannings M, Brookman R, Parker S, Hoon L, Ono A, Kawata H, Matsukawa H, Harris CB. "Optimizing Technology-Based Prompts for Supporting People Living With Dementia in Completing Activities of Daily Living at Home: Experimental Approach to Prompt Modality, Task Breakdown, and Attentional Support." JMIR aging 2024;7:e56055, doi:10.2196/56055, accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • Schmitter-Edgecombe M, Brown K, Luna C, Chilton R, Sumida CA, Holder L, Cook D. "Partnering a Compensatory Application with Activity-Aware Prompting to Improve Use in Individuals with Amnestic Mild Cognitive Impairment: A Randomized Controlled Pilot Clinical Trial." Journal of Alzheimer's Disease 2022;85(1):73-90, doi:10.3233/JAD-215022 (author copy), accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
Revision notes

This brief gets checked against its sources and contains the following revisions. Future revisions get added here.

Worth knowing

  • the carer study's own discussion is more hopeful than its abstract; the page gives both statements

Full check

Sources read

  • Persson et al., interview study of time aids in dementia (BMC Geriatrics, 2023): full text
  • Baudin et al., carers of digital planner users (BMC Geriatrics, 2024): full text (its later correction notice was also read; it touches no claim on this page)
  • Persson et al., randomised trial of time aids (2025): full text
  • Persson et al., occupational therapist focus groups (2020): full text
  • Dsouza et al., time aids in India (BMC Geriatrics, 2026): full text
  • Abilia, MEMOplanner product sheet: full text
  • Wennberg et al. (2018 and 2021), Janeslätt et al. (2019) and Mirjan et al. (2026): record only

What changed

  • Not found in the sources, removed: that boards set with symbols or picture cards are easy to set; the page now says only that such boards exist.
  • Not found in the sources, replaced with what they say: the therapist study does not say the people who lived apart were couples; the page now says 'especially when the two lived apart'.
  • Stated more strongly than the source: carers had no time to learn all the planner's functions, not its functions at all; partners said an advanced planner 'may only help' for a limited period; the page no longer gives the clocks' silence about what comes next as the reason some people kept regular calendars; the paper puts the two side by side.
  • Credit: that planner users may not always act on a reminder is the study's authors' sentence, not something carers said.
  • Entry points: the make starting point now notes that the India study's planner with lights was found hard to follow, so it no longer reads as untried.
  • Other: added from the India study: caregivers said people with dementia found time shown by small lights hard to understand, and found the advanced devices complex to operate.

Left open

None noted in this check.

Separate check of specific claims: The carer study's more hopeful statement, the planner users' diagnoses, the planner's fading-dots timeline and two studies of prompts that announce themselves were added, with their citations on the source list.

Earlier full check: Three phrases were brought back to the sources: the trial is a Swedish randomised trial, not the only one; a conclusion was credited to the therapist study's authors; and carers doubted the planner would be used when the person was alone.

Separate check of specific claims: The make starting point now begins from card-set planners that already exist and asks for a board whose next card calls attention to itself, and a wrongly named ethics authority was corrected.

Earlier full check: The trial and the therapist study were read in full and their key details added, an overstated burden claim was corrected, the planner's remote completion check was added, and the long title now says 'Interview Studies' and 'People Without a Partner's Support'.