Skip to content
problem genome

One of 592 unsolved problems in the Problem Genome, a collection written up for student design and engineering teams.

social · health · digital

a call someone has to hold

Care homes kept residents in touch with family through tablets and mainstream video apps — but in four Quebec homes most residents needed a staff member's help throughout the call because of cognitive and other impairments, and staff judged the calls mostly helped the families

Source: Hardy et al., “Long-term care staffs' experience in facilitating the use of…” Open ↗source: primaryLast updated: 2026-11-12

Problem statement

When visits stopped during COVID-19, care homes in Canada, Australia and Switzerland turned to tablets, smartphones and mainstream platforms (Zoom, FaceTime, Skype, WhatsApp) to keep residents in contact with their families. For residents who could hold the device and follow a conversation, it worked well enough. For residents with dementia, deafness or low vision it did not work on its own. In four Quebec long-term care homes that were each required to hold at least one video call a week between residents and their relatives over three months, almost all staff reported that assisting a call took a lot of effort (scores of 6.4 and 6.2 out of 10, on a burden scale where higher means more effort), because "most residents required continual assistance due to their cognitive and other impairments"; some residents had trouble recognising their relatives on screen, became upset that they could not touch them, or fell asleep, and "most staff members perceived that videoconferencing was beneficial primarily for families." (The same staff still rated the calls favourably overall, around 8/10 for attitude and 7/10 for keeping contact, so the shortfall is the effort and who benefits, not that the calls were useless.) The problem did not end with the lockdowns: in three southwestern Ontario homes studied in 2023–24, participants described "limited staff to support older adults with different physical and cognitive needs" and were concerned about "the decline in offering videoconferencing services across LTCHs post pandemic." The unsolved problem is a video-calling setup that a resident with cognitive or sensory impairment can take part in without a staff member holding, prompting and repairing the call — so that contact survives staff shortages and continues outside emergencies.

Why this matters

A Quebec manager described the loss of visits as having "a very big impact" on residents' health and mental state, and video contact is the most-studied digital response: the Campbell evidence and gap map found videoconferencing and telephone calls the most common digital interventions evaluated for older adults' isolation and loneliness. Family members interviewed in Australia used calls not only to chat but to continue caring — monitoring health and providing "social enrichment" — and valued video because it carried facial cues and lip movements that masks and telephones lose, which mattered especially for relatives who were hard of hearing. The authors argue the issue "can no longer be seen as a secondary concern that is relegated to the periphery of lifestyle programs." Yet in some countries care homes are required to provide telephone contact while video remains an optional extra, and the gap map found that no included study or review assessed affordability or lack of accessibility.

What’s been tried and why it hasn’t worked

Homes used mainstream apps on consumer devices, booking systems, and workarounds. (1) Staff-mediated calls. In Quebec, managers said routines had been adapted, but staff reported that adding the role to their day was hard "especially in the context of staff shortage and turnover"; most sites had only a few tablets, no public Wi-Fi to move between rooms, and no practice standards. (2) Bigger screens. Some homes cast calls to a television because residents with severe cognitive impairment "have difficulty focusing well on the small screen of the tablet"; some homes also connected a telephone handset to the tablet, which helped some residents with hearing problems follow the conversation. These were local workarounds, and not all four homes had access to an Internet network. (3) Scheduling. In the Australian interview study, limited devices meant calls had to be booked in advance through improvised calendars, email and phone, sometimes only in fixed "visitation hours," so families who missed the slot missed the call; one participant, whose father lived in a care home outside Australia, described how it "took a while to identify a couple of the nursing staff who both are willing and can find the time to actually help him do calls." (4) Conversation through the device. In Swiss nursing homes, families and staff reported that keeping a conversation going through a device was often difficult when the resident had cognitive decline or sensory impairment; a doctor noted the challenge for "those who don't hear well, those who don't see well, or those who are a bit confused and don't understand what it is." (5) A tablet with auto-answer and remote access. In seven Ontario homes (interviews September 2022–July 2023), the DIT-Tech project gave individual residents personal Android tablets with "remote control access, direct family calls via auto-answer on Skype, and personalized setups", close to the hands-free design this brief would otherwise propose. Families and residents welcomed it, but "initial enthusiasm among staff and care partners was countered by staff resistance due to workload and past tech issues," staff described usability issues, and staff named poor fit with the homes' goals, structure and management as the biggest barrier. The common thread, in the Australian authors' words: "commercial video calling systems can be hard to use for care home residents."

What would unlock progress

A calling system designed for the care-home context rather than borrowed from consumer use, and, as DIT-Tech shows, one that cuts staff steps and fits the home's routines rather than adding another device for staff to manage; auto-answer and remote access alone did not remove the workload objection. A stand alone did not remove it either: in a 2025 Norwegian feasibility study, an iPad on a wheeled stand or tabletop tripod was used for video calls in a dementia unit and a short-term unit for six weeks, the calls were "facilitated by care staff to ensure no technological difficulties", and staff said it "would be a great relief if residents could use it independently" (focus groups with four staff and four family members; no residents were interviewed). A video link "designed specifically for people with dementia to use" (inTouch, a touchscreen with a telephone handset) was described in 2014 and tested in two home trials linking private households, not in care homes (abstract read). The Australian authors specify the requirements: ease of use, learnability and accessibility, "especially for those with dexterity impairments"; hardware such as physical stands or supports that let residents position the device "without needing substantial involvement from caregivers"; and support for independent use. The Quebec television workaround adds large displays. For residents with hearing loss, the evidence that video carries lip movements suggests captioning and audio routing to hearing aids or headphones as part of the design (an inference from the sources, not a tested intervention in them). For residents with dementia, the Quebec findings on recognition and distress suggest the design problem is as much about the conversation (prompts, shared objects, short formats) as about the hardware.

How we’d know it’s being solved

Three measures: (a) staff minutes per completed call and the share of calls completed without continuous staff presence (the burden the Quebec staff rated at 6.2–6.4/10); (b) the share of residents with cognitive or sensory impairment who can take part in a call, and the frequency of calls per resident per week; (c) a resident-side outcome — observed engagement during calls for residents with dementia, or a loneliness measure for residents able to self-report — rather than family satisfaction alone, since staff judged the existing calls to benefit families more than residents. Beware the proxy: number of calls booked measures access, not connection.

Where to start

Facility-free door: starting from what DIT-Tech already tried (auto-answer, remote access) and the staff objections it met, prototype a "hands-free" care-home calling station — a fixed stand or wheelchair/bed mount, a large screen, a one-touch or family-initiated answer, live captions, and audio output to a headset — using consumer components, and run usability tests with older adults (or with simulated dexterity, vision and hearing impairment) to measure setup time and the number of staff actions per call. Design door: design a conversation aid for calls with relatives who have dementia — on-screen photo prompts, a short structured call format, cues for the family member — drawing on the recognition and distress problems the Quebec staff describe, and test it with family carers. Partner door (design the trial, don't run it): with a care-home group, write a protocol comparing usual tablet calls with the redesigned station, with staff time per call and residents' participation as primary outcomes and an observational engagement measure for residents with dementia, plus a pre-registered analysis plan. Access note: work with care-home residents needs the home's agreement and ethics review; the facility-free door uses simulated impairments and older volunteers instead. Relevant skills: interaction design, accessibility engineering, hardware prototyping, gerontology, qualitative methods.

Genes

Related problems

Stuck the same way, in other fields.

field: the built worldcounts of unknown accuracyHighway decisions rest on traffic counts whose accuracy is rarely known, checked by methods that vary agency to agency, and may not hold after installationbuilt without the people who'd live with itsource: primaryfield: health & medicinea calm room two nurses wideA psychiatric intensive care unit built a sensory room for patients to use when they chose, but its location required two of the day shift's five nurses in the room and the door left open to ward noise, so it went underusedbuilt without the people who'd live with itsource: primaryfield: digital & spacea bubble that keeps every stranger outSocial VR platforms give players mute, block, report and personal-space bubbles, but in a 100-player survey harassment stayed common and the VR-specific tools were little used; for disabled players, reactive tools act too late, default boundaries also keep out welcome strangers, and visible tools carry a social costbuilt without the people who'd live with itsource: primaryfield: the built worldhalf a border is no borderGeorgia clears a truck in ten minutes and then holds it for two days, partly because the Azerbaijani side cannot keep up — one-sided border-post modernisation across Central Asia leaves paired crossings mismatchedbuilt without the people who'd live with itsource: primary

Sources

  • Hardy MS, Fanaki C, Savoie C, Wilchesky M, Gagnon MP, Laberge M, et al. "Long-term care staffs' experience in facilitating the use of videoconferencing by cognitively impaired long-term care residents during the COVID-19 pandemic: a mixed-methods study." BMC Health Services Research 24(1):646, 2024, doi:10.1186/s12913-024-11095-9, accessed 2026-10-22. Link ↗
  • Kelly RM, Xing Y, Baker S, Waycott J. "Video Calls as a Replacement for Family Visits During Lockdowns in Aged Care: Interview Study With Family Members." JMIR Aging 6:e40953, 2023, doi:10.2196/40953, accessed 2026-10-22. Link ↗
  • Bernardi S, Fiordelli M, Rubinelli S, Spagnoli V, Malacrida R, Martignoni G. "Navigating Communication in Nursing Homes During COVID-19: Perspectives From Families, Healthcare Professionals, and Managers in Southern Switzerland—A Qualitative Study." International Journal of Public Health 69:1606583, 2024, doi:10.3389/ijph.2024.1606583, accessed 2026-10-22. Link ↗
  • Welch V, Ghogomu ET, Barbeau VI, et al. "Digital interventions to reduce social isolation and loneliness in older adults: An evidence and gap map." Campbell Systematic Reviews 19(4):e1369, 2023, doi:10.1002/cl2.1369, accessed 2026-10-22. Link ↗
  • Garnett A, Yurkiv H, Connelly DM, Booth R, Donelle L. "Perceived Use of Web-Based Videoconferencing for Social Connectedness Among Older Adults Living in Long-Term Care: Qualitative Study." JMIR Aging 9:e73213, 2026, doi:10.2196/73213, accessed 2026-10-22. Link ↗
  • Kokorelias KM, Grigorovich A, D'Elia T, Astell A, McMurray J, Iaboni A. "Staff, resident, and care partner perceptions on the use of a personalized tablet to mitigate the impact of isolation in long-term care residents." PLoS One 20(5):e0319005, 2025, doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0319005, accessed 2026-10-22. Link ↗
  • Austbø LBH, Testad I, Gjestsen MT. "Using a Robot to Address the Well-Being, Social Isolation, and Loneliness of Care Home Residents via Video Calls: Qualitative Feasibility Study." JMIR Formative Research 9:e59764, 2025, doi:10.2196/59764, accessed 2026-11-12. Link ↗
  • Boyd H, Jones S, Harris N, Panteli N, Leake J, Jones R. "Development and testing of the inTouch video link for people with dementia: Design approach and practical challenges." 2014 IEEE International Conference on Bioinformatics and Biomedicine (BIBM), pp. 608-612, 2014, doi:10.1109/bibm.2014.6999231 (abstract), accessed 2026-11-12. Link ↗
Revision notes

This brief gets checked against its sources and contains the following revisions. Future revisions get added here.

Worth knowing

  • the title's point that staff felt the calls mostly helped families comes from the four Quebec homes only, not from all three countries
  • DIT-Tech is mainly a recreation tablet (games, films) with video calling as one feature

Full check

Sources read

  • Hardy et al., videoconferencing in Quebec long-term care homes (2024): full text
  • Kelly et al., family members on video calls in Australian aged care (JMIR Aging, 2023): full text
  • Bernardi et al., Swiss nursing homes during the pandemic (International Journal of Public Health, 2024): full text
  • Welch et al., digital interventions for isolation and loneliness: evidence and gap map (Campbell Systematic Reviews, 2023): full text
  • Garnett et al., family contact in Ontario care homes after the pandemic (2026): full text
  • Kokorelias et al., the DIT-Tech tablet in Ontario care homes (2025): full text
  • Austbø et al., a video-call robot in a Norwegian care home (JMIR Formative Research, 2025): full text
  • Boyd et al., inTouch video link for people with dementia (IEEE BIBM, 2014): abstract only

What changed

  • Not found in the sources, replaced with what they say: an earlier attempt was headed as a tablet built to need less staff; the paper does not say that, and the heading now names the features it does report: auto-answer and remote access.
  • Numbers: that one of the four Quebec homes had no Internet at all: the paper's wording can be read two ways, so the page now says only that not all four homes had Internet access; the number of implementation studies the page rests on, now five, not three.
  • Credit: a quote about the staff time calls took was placed in Australia; the speaker's father lived in a care home outside Australia, and the page now says so.

Left open

  • the inTouch video link and its two home trials (abstract only)

Separate check of specific claims: The long title was narrowed to the four Quebec homes its key sentence comes from, in that source's own words; display title unchanged.

Separate check of specific claims: Two earlier attempts at a purpose-built calling station were added: a tablet on a stand tried in a Norwegian care home, and a video link designed for people with dementia.

Earlier full check: Six wordings were brought in line with the sources, including the long title, a quote now given to one manager instead of several, and where a list of design needs came from.

Separate check of specific claims: No changes were made to the text.