Skip to content
problem genome

One of 592 unsolved problems in the Problem Genome, a collection written up for student design and engineering teams.

social · health · labor

the befriender who never called

A telephone friendship-group trial for people over 74 recruited its older participants but closed early because the charity could not recruit and keep volunteers — 42 enquiries, four who started — and formal volunteering in England has fallen since and not recovered

Source: Mountain et al., “'Putting Life in Years' (PLINY) telephone friendship groups…” Open ↗source: primaryLast updated: 2026-11-12

Problem statement

Befriending — a trained volunteer who calls or visits a lonely person regularly — is one of the most commonly evaluated loneliness services: a DCMS-commissioned rapid systematic review of 101 loneliness interventions (studies published 2008–2023) found that "befriending/mentoring/peer-support programmes" were the most common type of social-support intervention. Such services rest on a supply of volunteers. One carefully documented test of what happens when demand is created faster than a provider normally takes it on is the PLINY trial: older people aged over 74 living independently in one UK city were randomised to six weeks of short one-to-one calls followed by twelve weeks of hour-long telephone friendship groups of up to six people, led by volunteers recruited and trained by a local franchise of a national older-people's charity. Recruiting the older participants worked (70 randomised in the 95-day pilot window, 80% of them providing outcome data; recruitment then continued to 157 randomised in all). Recruiting the volunteers did not: of 42 people who expressed interest in volunteering, 12 began training and four began delivering calls, and by January 2013, 55 of the 78 participants allocated to befriending had no volunteer. The trial was closed early. The unsolved problem is a volunteer-delivered connection service that can be scaled to match demand — when the volunteer pipeline is the constraint, not the lonely people.

Why this matters

The trial authors' conclusion is a warning to commissioners: "even where part-time, paid volunteer co-ordinators exist, volunteer recruitment and retention represent a significant management challenge, and such services cannot always be scaled up quickly," and local charities may "deliberately regulate demand for their services based on the resources available to them, resulting in 'trickle' recruitment of both volunteers and clients." The general volunteer pool has since shrunk and not recovered. In the government's Community Life Survey, the share of adults (aged 16+) in England volunteering formally at least once a month fell from 27% in 2013/14 to 23% in 2019/20 and 16% in 2021/22 and 2023/24; the 2024/25 figure, 17%, is "no significant change." NCVO notes that 31% of voluntary organisations surveyed during the pandemic saw a decrease in volunteers aged 50 or older. Befriending specifically is still short: Befriending Networks' 2025 Sector Insight Report, from a survey of its member organisations in August 2025 (85 of the 288 invited responded), estimated that over 7,400 people were waiting to be matched with a befriender across its membership (the 2,085 on the waiting lists of the 80 organisations that gave a figure, scaled up to the whole membership), and 72% of member organisations reported increased demand, though volunteer numbers were mixed (27% of members reported a decrease, 39% an increase); and in November 2025 Age UK Wyvern "temporarily close[d] its valuable befriending service to new clients due to a shortage of volunteers," with 69 people on its waiting list. In interviews for the evaluation of the government's Know Your Neighbourhood loneliness fund (collected March 2023–July 2024), a Community Foundation delivering it said: "because there are only so many volunteers in the area, organisations are often fighting for them."

What’s been tried and why it hasn’t worked

The PLINY provider was contracted to recruit and train 50 volunteers over twelve months, ran an advertising campaign and direct approaches, and delivered a standard induction plus befriending and group-facilitation training. Of 42 expressions of interest (May–October 2012), 30 never followed up to commit to training; of the 12 who started training, eight dropped out — because they could not prioritise volunteering over other commitments including returning to work or full-time education (three), objected to public money going to the research team (two), lacked confidence (one), or grew tired of waiting for participant recruitment to start (one), with no reason available for the eighth — and one of the four who started delivering then left through ill health. Three volunteers ran four groups (24 participants), one of them with a different volunteer for the group stage than for the one-to-one stage. The trial team ruled out an alternative provider before stopping. The point estimate for the primary mental-health outcome favoured the befriending arm, imprecisely (SF-36 mental health 78 vs 71 at six months; mean difference 7, 95% CI −3 to 16), so the service may help — but it could not be delivered at the scale a trial (or a commissioner) needs. The government review notes, from qualitative evidence, "the importance of the emotional bond and caring/trusting relationship built with mentors, befrienders, link workers and home-sharers," which is precisely what volunteer turnover breaks.

What would unlock progress

A redesign of the volunteer role and pipeline around where volunteers are lost: between expressing interest and committing to training (30 of 42), and between training and first call (8 of 12). The dropout reasons point to the levers — roles compatible with employment and study, shorter waits between sign-up and starting, confidence-building, and flexibility about who delivers which stage so that one lost volunteer does not strand a group. NCVO reports that remote volunteering has become common (31% of recent volunteers volunteered remotely, online or by phone), which suggests a larger pool for telephone-based roles, and the Know Your Neighbourhood fund deliberately pairs increasing volunteering with reducing chronic loneliness, treating the two as complementary. Adjacent fields with lessons: crisis-line and mentoring organisations that run high-volume, shift-based volunteer rotas. One national on-demand telephone role already exists in England: NHS Volunteer Responders' Check in and Chat, reintroduced in March 2023, links volunteers to people referred for "a one-off call or a series of calls" through a smartphone app, and NHS England reported that over a thousand volunteers had signed up at the relaunch. The one evaluation found of the wider NHS Volunteer Responders programme (Krekel et al., abstract read) reports on the volunteers' own wellbeing; its abstract reports nothing on the people called or on how long volunteers stayed. So what is not known from any source read here is whether an on-demand pool can keep the same people talking week after week, which is what PLINY could not staff.

How we’d know it’s being solved

Pipeline measures before outcome measures: the conversion rate from volunteer enquiry to first call, the time from enquiry to first call, volunteer retention at 3 and 6 months, and the proportion of referred people matched to a befriender within a set time (in PLINY, 55 of the 78 allocated to befriending by 17 January 2013 were not matched). Then the service outcome — a validated loneliness measure (the UCLA and De Jong Gierveld scales were the most used in the studies the DCMS review included) for befriended people against a comparison group. Beware the proxy: volunteers "registered" or "trained" overstates supply when most never start.

Where to start

Facility-free door: map the volunteer journey for a telephone-befriending role from enquiry to first call (using public recruitment pages and application flows of befriending charities, and interviews with people who volunteer or considered it), identify where the PLINY-type drop-offs would occur, and prototype a redesigned role and onboarding flow — for example a short, shift-based telephone role with on-demand training, studying the NHS Volunteer Responders Check in and Chat role as an existing case — then test it with prospective volunteers. Design door: design a group-continuity model for telephone friendship groups that survives the loss of a facilitator (co-facilitation, rotating volunteers, participant-led sessions), and run a small simulated test with volunteer peers. Partner door (design the trial, don't run it): with a befriending charity, write the protocol for a pilot comparing its current volunteer recruitment with the redesigned pipeline, with enquiry-to-first-call conversion as the primary outcome and a pre-registered analysis plan. Access note: charity volunteer records are not public; the facility-free door uses public material and interviews instead. Relevant skills: service design, organisational behaviour, recruitment/UX design, evaluation methods.

Genes

Related problems

Stuck the same way, in other fields.

field: water & energyinvisible water, no treaty468 aquifers cross international borders and countries report only 13 aquifer-specific cooperation arrangements — five of which do not actually operatebuilt without the people who'd live with itsource: primaryfield: digital & spacea bubble that keeps every stranger outSocial VR platforms give players mute, block, report and personal-space bubbles, but in a 100-player survey harassment stayed common and the VR-specific tools were little used; for disabled players, reactive tools act too late, default boundaries also keep out welcome strangers, and visible tools carry a social costbuilt without the people who'd live with itsource: primaryfield: digital & spaceten times the data, same computing budgetThe high-luminosity LHC will produce ten times the collision data, and current computing cannot scale to itbuilt without the people who'd live with itsource: primaryfield: making & materialsless copper per tonne, more energy to get itCopper ore grade decline creates compounding energy-emissions processing spiralbuilt without the people who'd live with itsource: secondary

Sources

  • Mountain GA, Hind D, Gossage-Worrall R, Walters SJ, Duncan R, Newbould L, et al. "'Putting Life in Years' (PLINY) telephone friendship groups research study: pilot randomised controlled trial." Trials 15:141, 2014, doi:10.1186/1745-6215-15-141, accessed 2026-10-22. Link ↗
  • NCVO, "Time Well Spent 2023 — 3. Volunteer participation", accessed 2026-10-22. Link ↗
  • Department for Culture, Media and Sport, "Interim overarching evaluation on the Know Your Neighbourhood Fund," GOV.UK, 2025, accessed 2026-10-22. Link ↗
  • Department for Culture, Media and Sport, "Loneliness interventions across the life-course: executive summary," GOV.UK, accessed 2026-10-22. Link ↗
  • Department for Culture, Media and Sport, "Community Life Survey 2024/25: Volunteering and charitable giving," GOV.UK, accessed 2026-10-22. Link ↗
  • Susan Hunter, "Our communities need befriending - but services are overstretched," TFN, 27 October 2025, accessed 2026-10-22. Link ↗
  • Befriending Networks, "Befriending Sector Insight Report October 2025", accessed 2026-10-22. Link ↗
  • Age UK Wyvern, "Plea for volunteers," 3 November 2025, accessed 2026-10-22. Link ↗
  • NHS England, news item of 6 March 2023 on the Check in and Chat service (read in the Internet Archive copy of 8 June 2026), accessed 2026-11-12. Link ↗
  • Krekel C, Shreedhar G, Lee H, Marshall C, Boler A, Smith A, Dolan P. "Happy to Help: Welfare Effects of a Nationwide Volunteering Program." Review of Economics and Statistics, pp. 1-16, published online 2026-10-13, doi:10.1162/rest_a_01533 (abstract read via Crossref record), accessed 2026-11-12. Link ↗

Also cited in the brief

  • The final NIHR PHR monograph (Hind et al. 2014, doi:10.3310/phr02070) with the process evaluation. Link ↗
Revision notes

This brief gets checked against its sources and contains the following revisions. Future revisions get added here.

Worth knowing

  • the trial paper says 55 of 78 people had no volunteer; the trial's longer report says 50 of 78, and the page keeps the paper's figure
  • the trial paper also gives an adjusted mental-health result that favours befriending more clearly, and says it must be treated with caution

Full check

Sources read

  • Mountain et al., PLINY telephone befriending pilot trial (Trials, 2014): full text
  • Hind et al., PLINY trial report (NIHR Public Health Research, 2014): full text (searched for the trial's figures, not read end to end)
  • NCVO, Time Well Spent 2023: volunteer participation: full text
  • DCMS, Community Life Survey 2024/25: volunteering: full text
  • DCMS, Know Your Neighbourhood Fund interim evaluation (2025): full text
  • DCMS, loneliness interventions across the life-course: executive summary: full text
  • Befriending Networks, Befriending Sector Insight Report (2025): full text
  • TFN, summary of the befriending sector report (2025): full text
  • Age UK Wyvern, plea for volunteers (2025): full text
  • NHS England, Check in and Chat news item (2023): full text (read from an archived copy)
  • Krekel et al., Happy to Help: NHS Volunteer Responders (Review of Economics and Statistics, 2026): abstract only

What changed

  • Not found in the sources, replaced with what they say: befriending was called one of the most common loneliness services; the review counts studies, so the page now says one of the most commonly evaluated.
  • Numbers: the reasons the eight trainee volunteers dropped out: the paper gives "tired of waiting" for one person and has no reason for another, and the page now says so.
  • Credit: the loneliness review was called a DCMS review; DCMS commissioned it from two other bodies, and the page now says DCMS-commissioned.
  • Citation details: a hyphen restored in the title of the government page.

Left open

  • what the one evaluation of the wider volunteer programme found (abstract only)

Separate check of specific claims: England's existing Check in and Chat telephone volunteer service was added as an earlier attempt, with the one evaluation found of the wider programme.

Earlier full check: The full befriending sector report was added, and its waiting-list figure is now described as an estimate scaled up from the groups that answered.

Separate check of specific claims: Volunteering figures now come from the government survey and cover England, current evidence of a befriender shortage was added, and the trial result is described as imprecise.