Skip to content
problem genome

One of 592 unsolved problems in the Problem Genome, a collection written up for student design and engineering teams.

social · health · education

found, then lost at the consent box

A Danish programme screens upper-secondary students for severe loneliness and offers each one a guide, but only 204 of the 899 it found accepted a conversation, and on two loneliness items those who came scored less lonely than those who did not

Source: Pluss for Mary Fonden, “Evaluering af Lift – unge ud af ensomhed…” Open ↗source: secondaryLast updated: 2026-11-17

Problem statement

Lonely young people find it hard to ask for help, so a Danish programme decided to go looking for them. Lift – unge ud af ensomhed ("Lift – young people out of loneliness") is run by a foundation (Mary Fonden) with three municipalities (Esbjerg, Vejle, Ballerup) and several civil-society organisations. Students in upper-secondary and vocational schools fill in a short questionnaire built on the UCLA loneliness scale, at some schools alongside the yearly wellbeing survey. On the same questionnaire they can agree that a "Lift guide" may contact them if they score as severely lonely. The guide then meets them, and helps them into a group or activity where needed. Finding the young people worked. Taking up the offer did not. By May 2025, 7,347 young people had been screened and 899 (12%) identified as severely lonely. 542 (60%) gave consent and were contacted, and 204 (38% of those) accepted a conversation with a guide. That is fewer than one in four of those found. Of the 695 found who never had a conversation, 357 did not give consent and 338 gave consent, were contacted, and then did not accept a conversation. The evaluators also found that those who took part answered two loneliness items less severely than those who did not ("How often do you feel you lack someone to be with?"; "How often do you feel left out?"). They read this as a sign "at det er de mindst ensomme af de 'svært ensomme', som vælger at blive en del af Lift" ("that it is the least lonely of the 'severely lonely' who choose to join Lift"; our translation), and add that the pattern does not show on the questionnaire's other items. The unsolved problem is the step from being identified to a first conversation: the consent box, answered in a classroom, and then the guide's first contact, for a feeling that many young people find shameful.

Why this matters

The evaluators call the low consent and uptake "one of the biggest challenges for Lift throughout the project period" (our translation). They say it means a substantial share of severely lonely young people are ones Lift cannot help. The report quotes an unnamed interviewee: "Hvis vi ikke får samtykke, så har vi en viden om unge, der føler sig ensomme, men som vi ikke kan hjælpe direkte" ("If we don't get consent, we know about young people who feel lonely but whom we cannot help directly"; our translation). For those who did take part, the report is positive. Young people valued being listened to, reported feeling better able to talk about loneliness and seek help, and many felt less lonely, though not all, and a group stayed severely lonely. Screening is cheap to spread: schools said it was simple and no great burden, and one folded it into its yearly wellbeing survey. Unless the conversion problem is solved, scaling it up mostly produces counts of lonely young people who never reach a guide.

What’s been tried and why it hasn’t worked

(1) Systematic screening with an opt-in. The tool itself is not the problem. The evaluators cite DEFACTUM's conclusion that the UCLA-9 version is valid and easy to use for this purpose, and the 12% identified is a little below the 14% the programme expected. The drop comes at the consent box and again at the first call. (2) Why young people say no. The evaluators could not find any young person who had stayed out of Lift willing to be interviewed. The reasons come from participants who hesitated or first said no, focus groups after three screening sessions, and reasons sent in writing by Vejle municipality. One of the main reasons was fear and shame: "hvis man deler sine følelser, så bliver de på en måde mere virkelige" ("if you share your feelings, they somehow become more real"; our translation). One young person who had declined a conversation said it was hard "to let someone new in and tell your life story" (our translation). Young people were also unsure what the screening was for: one was surprised to be contacted by a strange man, and others said "the teacher was a bit quick" or that nothing was said about being contacted afterwards (our translations). Some wondered whether their problem was "bad enough" (our translation). (3) Who presents the screening. Teachers, wellbeing coordinators, study counsellors or the guides themselves have each introduced the screening, and the evaluators found the best results when it is introduced by someone who knows about loneliness and Lift, whom the young people feel safe with, and who has dedicated time. In Esbjerg, where guides presented the screening themselves, guides said "Det var nemmere at få samtykke" ("It was easier to get consent"; our translation). Consent ran at 70% in Vejle against 52% in Ballerup and 57% in Esbjerg. Even so, they conclude that it is hard for a single introduction to make sure every young person has reflected on loneliness before answering. Mary Fonden produced presentation material, including a video, and confusion still occurred. (4) Boys. Guides and local staff report that boys in particular find it hard to take the screening seriously and sometimes laugh at one another in class, which makes consenting even more shameful for those who are severely lonely. (5) After the first meeting. Guides often found one or two conversations were not enough and held more, or set up their own groups. This blurs their role and uses more resources than were set aside. Moving young people into lasting communities took a long time, and "not very many" were ready to do so within the project period (our translation). Independent support. A peer-reviewed validation study by researchers at DEFACTUM and the universities of Aarhus, Southern Denmark and Manchester (Bo et al. 2025; funded by Mary Fonden, which designed and collected the Lift-stage data and reviewed the manuscript before submission but had no role in the analysis; competing interests declared) found the same leak outside Lift. In a feasibility test at three schools in Silkeborg, 29 of 93 students were identified and "only seven of those identified accepted the offer of support". None of the 22 who declined volunteered for an interview. In Lift's own 2023–24 screening, 1,117 of 2,845 students (39.3%) chose to answer anonymously, so they could not be contacted at all (in that study students who do not want to give contact details answer anonymously, so this appears to be the consent step again, counted over everyone who answered that year, not a further loss on top of it). These students were more often men, had a non-Danish mother tongue, or attended vocational schools, 10th grade or basic preparatory education. They were no less lonely than those who answered by name. The authors point to stigma, privacy worries, and not understanding the support on offer, and call for studies of why young people decline. The evaluation has no comparison group. Follow-up questionnaires were answered by 56, 29 and 13 young people at 2, 5 and 10 months, a technical fault meant answers had to be linked to the screening by timing, and the interviewed young people were found by the guides.

What would unlock progress

A consent step that does not ask a severely lonely 16-year-old to decide in a classroom, among classmates, at one moment, whether a stranger may contact them. The evaluators and the guides float some options: use class- or school-level screening results to start collective activities on loneliness, so that young people can talk about it "without first having to identify themselves and accept individual help" (our translation); frame Lift, as the guides suggest, as lifting young people into a community rather than out of loneliness; and keep the door open after the screening so that a young person can join later. The design question is how a later, private, low-stakes "yes" could work, and how a young person could know beforehand who the guide is and what a first meeting would involve.

How we’d know it’s being solved

(a) Conversion from identified to first conversation, against 204 of 899 (23%), reported separately for boys and girls and by school type. (b) Whether the most lonely now take part: the gap between participants and non-participants on the two loneliness items should close. (c) Late uptake: the share joining weeks after the screening, a route the evaluators say Lift should keep open. (d) For participants, change in UCLA score at 2, 5 and 10 months with fewer people lost to follow-up, ideally against a comparison group. Beware the proxy: "young people screened" is the easiest number to grow and the least informative.

Where to start

Facility-free door: from the report's funnel (7,347 → 899 → 542 → 204 → 121; the 121 are those of the 204 who were referred on to other offers) and its interview quotes, map each point where a young person can drop out and the reason given at that point. Then rewrite the consent screen, the introduction script and the first-contact message as a set with a clear purpose, a named and pictured guide, a choice of contact mode, and no "severely lonely" label. Test it with student volunteers recruited openly on campus, for example in a residence hall or a first-year seminar, who read the set and say what they think it is for, who will contact them and what happens next, using hypothetical scenarios. No one is asked about their own loneliness, and no student screens or reads anyone else's answers. What carries over to the real users: whether the purpose, the guide and the next step are understood, and which wording feels like a label. What does not: how shame works for a severely lonely 16-year-old answering in class, and any consent rate. Those need the partner door. Make door: make a printed "later door" card handed to every student in the class after the screening, so holding one marks no one out. It carries the guide's face and name, a picture of what a first meeting looks like, and a private way to say yes weeks later that needs nothing filled in in front of others. The object matters because it is given to everyone, kept in a wallet or bag, and is still there after the consent moment has passed, when the funnel shows many identified young people have already been lost. Wellbeing surveys, the programme's presentation video, and anonymous chat or helpline services for young people already exist. The evaluation also says local project leaders focus on providing easy-to-use standard material that introduces Lift and puts a face on the guides, so the card starts from that material. This differs because it turns a one-moment consent into a standing invitation tied to a known local person. Make it with print and simple materials, and test its look, wording and whether people would keep it with first-year university volunteers reached through a residence hall or student wellbeing office, who are not screened or identified. What carries over and what does not is the same as for the first door. Partner door (design the trial, don't run it): with a school or municipality that screens, design a cluster-randomised comparison of the current consent step and the redesigned one. Pre-register conversion to a first conversation, and the conversion gap for boys, as primary outcomes. Access note: any screening of minors for loneliness, and any trial, needs ethics review, parental consent rules and a partner. Relevant skills: interaction and service design, youth work, survey methodology, adolescent psychology.

Genes

Related problems

Stuck the same way, in other fields.

field: digital & spacethe account she can't openWomen are 36% less likely than men to own a mobile money account — and the gap is widening despite a decade of programs to close itbuilt without the people who'd live with itsource: secondaryfield: health & medicinethe oximeter lies about darker skinPulse oximeters systematically overestimate oxygen levels in darker-skinned patients, concealing life-threatening hypoxemiabuilt without the people who'd live with itsource: primaryfield: the built worldnobody goes backArchitects almost never go back to check whether their buildings work — about 3% of UK practices do it routinely on housing projects and U.S. 2030-commitment firms had reported measured performance for just 329 projects ever by 2021 — so the profession cannot learn from its own outputbuilt without the people who'd live with itsource: primaryfield: the built worldtwice the steel it needsStructural engineers size beams for loads they will never see — steel utilisation averages below 50%, and a 2022–23 survey found material efficiency is now a top design priority yet the amount of spare capacity engineers build in has barely movedbuilt without the people who'd live with itsource: secondary

Sources

  • Pluss for Mary Fonden. Evaluering af Lift – unge ud af ensomhed. Implementering, resultater og læring fra programmets første tre år. September 2025, accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • Bo A, Kjærside Nielsen B, Christensen AF, Christiansen J, Qualter P, Severinsen MG, Lasgaard M. Detecting loneliness among late adolescents: Validation and testing of a detection tool based on the UCLA Loneliness Scale. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences 2025;1548(1):148-162, doi:10.1111/nyas.15316, accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
Revision notes

This brief gets checked against its sources and contains the following revisions. Future revisions get added here.

Worth knowing

  • The page rests on one programme evaluation written for the programme's own foundation, with no comparison group, and one study the same foundation funded
  • The display title names the consent step, but about half of the young people found who never had a conversation had already given consent

Full check

Sources read

  • Pluss, evaluation of Lift – young people out of loneliness, for Mary Fonden (2025): full text (read in Danish)
  • Bo et al., validation of a loneliness detection tool for late adolescents (Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences, 2025): full text

What changed

  • Not found in the sources, replaced with what they say: joining later was called impossible in the current design; the report does not say so, and the page now says the evaluators want a route to join later kept open.
  • Stated more strongly than the source: lonely young people were said to rarely ask for help; the report says they find it hard to seek help and gives no frequency; a single introduction was said to be unable to make every young person reflect on loneliness; the report says this is hard.
  • Contradicted by the source, corrected: the notes said neither source heard from young people who declined; the evaluators received written reasons from some of them through one municipality, and the page now says neither interviewed them.
  • Credit: the hesitation about letting someone new in was given as what 'others' said; it is one young person's words; the validation study's authors are now placed at all four of their institutions, and its funding line now says the foundation also designed and collected the programme-stage data and reviewed the manuscript.
  • Dates: the programme's table is now described as giving figures as of a date in May, not drawn on it.
  • Entry points: the make door's card now starts from the material local project leaders already provide that introduces the programme and puts a face on the guides.

Left open

None noted in this check.

Separate check of specific claims: The page now says that about half of the young people found who never had a conversation had given consent, no longer says the consent step makes them name themselves in front of classmates (the screening is anonymous), and explains that the funnel's last figure counts those referred on to other offers.

Separate check of specific claims: The size of the second school test was added (29 of 93 students identified), and a sentence now explains that the anonymous answers appear to be the consent step again, not a further loss.

Earlier full check: Several statements were brought back to the report's wording (the partners are civil-society organisations, screening runs alongside the wellbeing survey at some schools, fear and shame are one of the main reasons rather than the main one, and scaling up mostly produces counts of young people who never reach a guide), and three translations were marked.

Separate check of specific claims: The entry points now test only with openly recruited volunteers on made-up scenarios, never ask anyone about their own loneliness, and the make door became a card handed to every student.

Earlier full check: The full title was narrowed to the two loneliness items on which participants scored less lonely, a few figures and quotations were brought in line with the report, and a peer-reviewed validation study was added.