social · labor · construction
no desk, no team in sight
Offices without assigned desks are often introduced to increase interaction, but in a controlled study at a Swedish agency satisfaction with communication among close colleagues fell and stayed lower a year later, which the authors tie to trouble locating colleagues, and university staff in two Swedish relocations reported less social community, and in one of them not knowing where to find colleagues
Source: Haapakangas et al., “The effects of moving into an activity-based office on…” Open ↗source: primaryLast updated: 2026-11-17
Problem statement
In an activity-based office, staff give up their own desks and choose a workspace each day to suit the task: a quiet room, an open desk, a meeting corner. Organisations adopt it to save space and, often, to improve interaction. In a natural intervention study at a Swedish government agency (the Swedish Transport Administration), four offices that moved to this design were compared with one office that did not (408 respondents; most had worked in private offices). Satisfaction with communication with the closest colleagues fell 3 months after the move and was still lower 12 months after it, at three of the four sites. The single questionnaire item on feeling part of a community also fell at 3 months; at 12 months it stayed significantly lower only for staff who had come from private offices, and the drop in the three-item social-community index was small and not statistically significant. The authors name "difficulties in finding colleagues" as the common thread and advise organisations to focus on "solving difficulties in locating colleagues at the office." At a Swedish university, after staff moved into a new building of this kind, the social-community score fell from 84.5 to 73.4 (of 100); the authors report from the open answers that staff did not know where to find their colleagues and felt "as if they were guests at the workplace," and one wrote "no one is at work anymore!" The unsolved problem is keeping people findable and keeping a sense of "our place" for a group whose members no longer have fixed seats.
Why this matters
Universities and public agencies keep moving staff into these offices, and the people affected are ordinary working adults (lecturers, researchers, administrators, agency staff). In the university follow-up, the share who worked at the office three or more days a week fell from 82% to 50% after the move, which overlapped with the pandemic; the authors of the earlier university study warn that lost concentration and lost "sense of community with colleagues" may in the long run mean "decreased efficiency, more conflicts and poorer well-being" (Berthelsen et al. 2018, abstract).
What’s been tried and why it hasn’t worked
(1) The office design itself, adopted partly for interaction. In the controlled Swedish agency study, the hoped-for gain in interaction did not appear as measured: satisfaction with communication fell (whole group, B = −0.94 at 3 months and −0.77 at 12 months on a 7-point scale, both p < 0.001), the belonging item fell as described above, social support fell slightly at 3 months and recovered by 12, and results differed between sites. The authors say their findings "clearly contradict" the positive conclusions of the 2018 review below. Their results led the agency to further improve the design and use at two of the sites; the paper does not report whether that helped. (2) Relocations at universities. At one large Swedish university (two faculties, surveys 3 months before and 9 months after, n = 217 and 200), 86% always sat in the same place, or where they usually sat, if it was vacant; the social-community score fell from 76.6 to 71.7; social support from colleagues and supervisors was perceived to have decreased; and no aspect of the work environment was perceived to have improved (a two-wave cross-sectional design). In a later relocation at a Swedish university (n = 169 and 160, 2019 and 2022), social community fell from 84.5 to 73.4 while support from colleagues did not change significantly; 95.0% said the possibility of decorating their workplace was small or very small (4.9% before; decorating was forbidden), and open answers describe not knowing where colleagues were, loss of spontaneous talk, loneliness, and departments with no designated area. Six respondents were clearly positive, one writing that "You can see who is on site and have coffee together." The authors caution that the move overlapped with COVID-19 and that the design does not allow causal conclusions. (3) Rules and software. Desk-sharing and zone rules (clear the desk, time limits on the same desk) were studied in four Swedish organisations: clear, explicit rules went with better work conditions, and the abstract reports nothing on belonging (Babapour Chafi and Rolfö 2018, Ergonomics, doi:10.1080/00140139.2018.1516805, abstract). In a later Swedish public-service relocation, the clean-desk policy "introduced challenges in maintaining team cohesion" (Forooraghi et al. 2025, Ergonomics, doi:10.1080/00140139.2025.2475350, abstract). Desk-booking software sold for these offices can set team areas ("neighbourhoods"), and one vendor suggests desk and lobby screens to support them (vendor pages from Officely and Smartway2, linked under Sources). These depend on everyone booking and checking an app, and none of the read sources evaluates whether they restore belonging; no evaluated trial of team home zones or similar fixes was found. Two kinds of colleague-finding product are also sold: "who's in" features in desk-booking software, which show colleagues who have booked a desk or checked in through the app (on some, also their seat on a floor plan), and magnetic in/out and staff-locator boards, on which each person moves a magnet beside their name to show whether they are in and where, set out as rows of names with status or location columns; the board pages show no floor plan of where a team sits and do not mention desk-sharing offices, and none of these maker pages reports any evaluation (pages linked under Sources). (4) The evidence that points the other way. A 2018 systematic review of 17 studies concluded that the design "has positive merits in the areas of interaction, communication," but most included studies were not controlled. A 2026 Bayesian meta-analysis (35 studies, N = 7,959) found "robust evidence" that these offices increase coworker contact (median 0.31, 10 studies), while effects on communication and on coworker relationships were uncertain; outcomes were better in private organisations and when the comparison was an open-plan office rather than cell offices, and in public organisations the pooled coworker-relationship effect leaned negative (−0.10, uncertain). Its authors "could not include quantitative studies on workspace or organizational belonging," so belonging has not been pooled. The open problem is therefore narrower than "these offices destroy belonging": more contact on average, but in public-sector moves from private or cell offices, where all three Swedish studies sit, each study found some loss in community or in communication with close colleagues, two of the three report trouble finding colleagues, and nothing tried so far has been shown to fix that.
What would unlock progress
Two needs come straight from the sources: being able to find a colleague without searching the floor or booking an app, and having some marker of "my group's place" when nobody owns a desk. The first university study's finding that 86% sit in the same place anyway suggests people already rebuild territory informally; a design could support that openly (team home zones, a portable personal marker) rather than fight it. Any fix has to fit the clean-desk rule these offices use and staff who are in on different days.
How we’d know it’s being solved
(a) The same validated scales the sources used (the social-community score from the university studies; satisfaction with communication) before and after a change, with a comparison group; (b) time to locate a named colleague on a given day; (c) share of staff reporting that they know where their group sits; (d) office attendance, kept separate because pandemic-era changes confound it. Beware the proxy: desk occupancy or bookings are not belonging.
Where to start
Facility-free door (design and test on paper): take the open-answer themes in Toivanen et al. (not knowing where colleagues are, no place of one's own, feeling like a guest) and design a floor-plan and signage scheme for a team home zone in an activity-based office, then test it as a paper or foam-board model with campus staff and graduate students who work in shared offices, timing how fast they can say where a named person would be. No partner or restricted data is needed. Make door: build a team "home base" object, adapted from the magnetic in/out boards already sold: a board fixed on a wall or pillar in the team's zone (not on a desk, so it fits the clean-desk rule) that holds a simple floor plan and one token per team member, which each person moves to where they sit today and back to "not in" when they leave. Anyone, including a visitor, can then see from one spot who in the group is in and where, with no app or booking; the board itself is the marker of "our place" that staff said they lacked. What exists: desk name plates and table tents; booking software that assigns team "neighbourhoods" and shows colleagues who have booked; magnetic in/out and staff-locator boards, where each person moves a magnet beside their name. The first two either sit on one desk or need everyone to book in an app; the in/out boards need no app but list names in rows and columns, with no floor plan of where the team sits that day. None of the read sources or maker pages evaluates any of them for belonging. Build it in a workshop from board, magnets or pegs and printed tokens, and test it in a staged one-day trial: on a campus shared study floor, or in a department or university administration office that already uses shared desks, with student and staff volunteers. Before the trial, ask the campus ethics office whether it needs review; volunteers are told what the trial involves and can leave at any time. Can a stranger find a named person faster than with no board, and do members say the zone feels more like their place? Who the users are and what carries over: the people on the page are office staff with no assigned desk, at a Swedish public agency and at Swedish universities, most of whom had their own offices before. On an ordinary campus they are reachable as staff in administration offices or departments with shared desks, graduate students in shared offices, and local employers who use shared desks. Speed of finding a colleague and how easy the board is to read carry over from a one-day campus trial. Whether the board slows the loss of belonging over a year, among staff who gave up their own offices, does not: that needs a real move and the design-the-test door below. Design-the-test door: with a university facilities office planning a move, design (do not run) a before-and-after study with a comparison unit, using the social-community scale. Relevant skills: interior and product design, environmental psychology, wayfinding.
Genes
Related problems
Stuck the same way, in other fields.
field: making & materialsno plastic, heavier traysFrance banned plastic cooking, reheating and serving containers in school canteens from 2025, but the national catering council's own guide finds no plastic-free fibre tray on the market, gives no compliant material top marks for weight, and flags lid handling and container washing as strain risks for kitchen staffbuilt without the people who'd live with itsource: primaryfield: making & materialsless copper per tonne, more energy to get itCopper ore grade decline creates compounding energy-emissions processing spiralbuilt without the people who'd live with itsource: secondaryfield: the built worldthe extra deck nobody calculatedAround 95% of ferry deaths happen on domestic routes that SOLAS never covered — and the boats that capsize have often had decks added and land engines fitted with no naval architect, no stability booklet and no surveyor able to checkbuilt without the people who'd live with itsource: primaryfield: health & medicinetwo weeks in the freezerMailed frozen meals are a lower-cost way to feed homebound people with dementia, but the person must store, pick and reheat two weeks of them; in a US pilot trial, daily delivered meals did not significantly lower nursing-home placement compared with frozen meals, and interviews with nine recipients and seven caregivers found problems storing the boxes and knowing when they would arrivebuilt without the people who'd live with itsource: primarySources
- Haapakangas A, Hallman D, Mathiassen SE, Jahncke H. "The effects of moving into an activity-based office on communication, social relations and work demands – A controlled intervention with repeated follow-up." Journal of Environmental Psychology 66:101341, 2019, doi:10.1016/j.jenvp.2019.101341 (full published version read from the University of Gävle DiVA copy), accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
- Toivanen S, Berthelsen H, Muhonen T. "Consequences of implementing activity-based flexible offices in academia: a follow-up study of perceived changes in the physical and psychosocial work environment after relocation." Facilities 41(15/16):129-145, 2023, doi:10.1108/F-05-2023-0043 (full text read from the Malmö University DiVA copy), accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗ Link 2 ↗
- Berthelsen H, Muhonen T, Toivanen S. "What happens to the physical and psychosocial work environment when activity-based offices are introduced into academia?" Journal of Corporate Real Estate 20(4):230-243, 2018, doi:10.1108/jcre-06-2017-0017 (author's accepted version read in full from the Malmö University DiVA copy), accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
- Engelen L, Chau JY, Young S, Mackey M, Jeyapalan D, Bauman AE. "Is activity-based working impacting health, work performance and perceptions? A systematic review." Building Research & Information 47(4):468-479, 2018 (volume and pages as in the OpenAlex record), doi:10.1080/09613218.2018.1440958 (abstract read from the OpenAlex record), accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
- Lauterbach AS, Borge RH. "How is your new office? A meta‐analytic review of activity‐based offices' theoretical foundations and empirical outcomes." Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology 99(1):e70099, 2026, doi:10.1111/joop.70099 (published version read in full from the Norwegian NVA repository record), accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗ Link 2 ↗
- Babapour Chafi M, Rolfö L. "Policies in Activity-based Flexible Offices -‘I am sloppy with clean-desking. We don’t really know the rules.’" Ergonomics 62(1):1-20, 2019 (first published online 2018), doi:10.1080/00140139.2018.1516805 (abstract), accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
- Forooraghi M, Hultberg A, Jonsdottir IH, Babapour Chafi M. "Exploring alignments between design principles and work unit needs in activity-based flexible offices: a case study." Ergonomics 68(9):1472-1490, 2025, doi:10.1080/00140139.2025.2475350 (abstract), accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
- Officely, "Making the Most of the Neighborhoods and Desks on Officely in Slack", accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
- Smartway2, "Office Neighborhoods: benefits, definitions and implementation tips", accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
- Flowscape, "Desk booking software for hybrid workplaces", accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
- Desk.ly, "Where can I check who is still working in the office?", accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
- Archie, "Hot Desk Booking Software", accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
- Hybo, "Who's in the Office?", accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
- Zapfloor, "See who is currently in the office", accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
- OfficeSpace, "Hot Desk Booking Software", accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
- Meeting Room 365, "Desk Booking & Hot Desking for Hybrid Offices", accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
- Magnatag, "Magnetic In-Out Whiteboard Systems", "Staff Tracker Personnel Locator", "On-Duty Staff Locator" and "In-Out, Lunch and Location", accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗ Link 2 ↗ Link 3 ↗ Link 4 ↗
Revision notes
This brief gets checked against its sources and contains the following revisions. Future revisions get added here.
Worth knowing
- Of the three Swedish studies, two report trouble finding colleagues; the third reports only a fall in the sense of community
Full check
Sources read
- Haapakangas et al., controlled study of a Swedish agency's move to activity-based offices (Journal of Environmental Psychology, 2019): full text (read from the university repository copy)
- Toivanen et al., follow-up of a Swedish university relocation (Facilities, 2023): full text (read from the university repository copy)
- Berthelsen et al., activity-based offices in academia (Journal of Corporate Real Estate, 2018): full text (the authors' accepted version)
- Lauterbach and Borge, meta-analysis of activity-based offices (Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology, 2026): full text
- Engelen et al., systematic review of activity-based working (Building Research & Information, 2018): abstract only
- Babapour Chafi and Rolfö, desk-sharing rules in four Swedish organisations (Ergonomics, 2018): abstract only
- Forooraghi et al., a Swedish public-service relocation (Ergonomics, 2025): abstract only
- Makers' pages for desk-booking software, desk name plates and in/out boards: full text (two makers' pages refused access)
What changed
- Not found in the sources, removed: the make door said booking software shows team areas on screens; neither maker's page shows that, and the words are gone.
- Title: the full title said university staff in both relocations reported not knowing where to find colleagues; it now says this was reported in one of them (display title unchanged).
- Entry points: the make door's team board is now presented as an adaptation of the in/out boards already sold, and its list of what exists says what each product leaves open (the boards show no floor plan; the apps need everyone to book).
- Other: a sentence now describes two kinds of colleague-finding product already sold: 'who's in' views in desk-booking apps and magnetic in/out boards; none has been evaluated.
Left open
- that table tents are among the desk markers sold (the maker's page could not be opened)
Separate check of specific claims: Two papers named in the text and the makers' pages it describes were added to the source list, two links now open the papers, and the staged-trial door now asks for a campus ethics check.
Separate check of specific claims: A sentence that said people in all three Swedish studies lose track of colleagues now says two of the three report it, and two makers' pages are now named on the page.
Earlier full check: A claim that loneliness research overlooks office workers was removed, a description of booking apps was brought back to what the makers' pages show, two products no source names were removed from the make door, and a study read only in summary is no longer said to have measured nothing on belonging.
Separate check of specific claims: The make door changed from a personal desk marker, which is close to products already sold, to a team board, and a note on who the users are and what a campus test can show was added.
Earlier full check: The full title and opening were narrowed to what the controlled study found (communication with close colleagues fell; the wider sense of community fell only slightly), the display title changed from No Desk, No Tribe to No Desk, No Team in Sight, and a newer meta-analysis was added.