Skip to content
problem genome

One of 592 unsolved problems in the Problem Genome, a collection written up for student design and engineering teams.

education · health · social

more than the build

The first large trial of LEGO-based therapy for autistic pupils in English mainstream schools found a small social-skills benefit at 20 weeks, non-significant in the main analysis and not sustained at 52; its team's later fidelity analysis judges gaps in the adult's facilitation of social interaction key contributors

Source: Wright et al., “I-SOCIALISE: Results from a cluster randomised controlled…” Open ↗source: primaryLast updated: 2026-11-12

Problem statement

LEGO-based therapy is a group play programme for autistic children: small groups build LEGO models together in rotating roles (an "engineer" who reads the instructions, a "supplier" who finds the bricks, a "builder" who assembles), with a trained adult guiding the group towards collaboration and child-led problem solving. The trial team describe it as "gaining increasing popularity in UK schools" despite, before their trial, no large, fully powered randomised trial. The I-SOCIALISE cluster trial randomised 98 mainstream schools in Northern England (250 autistic pupils aged 7–15) to 12 weekly hour-long sessions run by school staff plus usual support, or usual support alone. Teacher-rated social skills were 3.74 points higher in the LEGO arm at 20 weeks (p = 0.06; standardised effect 0.18, against the 0.47 the trial was powered to detect) and 1.68 points higher at 52 weeks (p = 0.43; 0.08). The authors conclude it has "a small positive non-significant benefit for social skills at 20 weeks but not 52 weeks," that it is well received and likely cost-effective, and that it is worth further research. A later fidelity analysis by the trial team (descriptive, not pre-planned) found fidelity high overall, but within the items on the adult's facilitation of social interaction, the ones about highlighting positive interactions and prompting children to work through social problems drew the most disagreement from independent raters; the authors judge these gaps in facilitating the programme's social aims "key contributors" to its limited impact. The unsolved problem is delivering the social part of a play-based programme through school staff with three hours of training, and measuring whether autistic children's peer experience changes.

Why this matters

The trial authors describe autistic children and young people as often experiencing social isolation and loneliness, being at greater risk of being bullied and having smaller friend groups, and they note that many interventions available to autistic pupils in mainstream and specialist schools have limited or no evidence of effectiveness. LEGO-based therapy is low-cost for schools to run, manualised and deliverable by teaching assistants; the health-economics substudy found marginal cost savings and QALY gains. The authors judge it of no apparent harm, well received and deliverable without additional resources; the open question is whether the support time schools give it buys a social effect that lasts beyond the 20-week follow-up. The fidelity paper cites a National Autistic Society report in which only 39% of the teachers surveyed, and 14% of secondary school teachers, had received more than half a day's autism training; that figure is for teachers, and the trial's facilitators were mostly teaching assistants.

What’s been tried and why it hasn’t worked

The intervention as trialled. Facilitators (mostly teaching assistants with moderate autism experience) received a 3-hour training session and a manual; 749 sessions were delivered; 69% of groups received all 12 sessions and 93% at least the minimum of six. Groups had three children, one to three of them autistic, with the others invited by the school: most primary sessions had one autistic child and most secondary sessions two. The per-protocol effect (at least six sessions) was 4.23 points (95% CI 0.27–8.19; 0.21 SD); sensitivity analyses ranged 0.15–0.21 SD; most secondary outcomes leaned positive with confidence intervals crossing zero; possible larger effects in secondary schools were not significant interactions. What the fidelity analysis found. Overall fidelity was high: 91% of checklist items were self-reported as delivered across all sessions, and in the 63 video-recorded sessions (9% of the total) ratings were 89.5% self-reported and 83.1% independent (the trial paper reports 77% independent). The analysis is descriptive, was not pre-planned, and three of its authors work for Play Included C.I.C., which trains facilitators in the programme. Items about building together in a structured way had the highest fidelity; items about the adult facilitating social interaction had lower fidelity in independent ratings. The authors list five implementation barriers: facilitator training and understanding of the role; "focus on task completion over social interaction" — facilitators "may have been more focused on the set building and completion," possibly because they knew they would be assessed on sessions delivered and model completion; difficulty recognising and reinforcing autistic children's social interactions (they raise the double empathy problem: neurotypical adults may not recognise positive moments of autistic interaction); contextual factors; and measurement that did not capture children's own experience, agency or sense of belonging. Training was limited to three hours because of time barriers with schools and local authorities, and no ongoing supervision was available. The authors judge these fidelity gaps "key contributors to the intervention's limited impact on social skills." What it has not tested. The programme's originator and colleagues maintain that effects accrue with longer delivery (for example, after-school clubs); I-SOCIALISE could not test this, and the authors recommend evaluating a full school year or twice-weekly sessions.

What would unlock progress

Facilitation support that does not depend on a long training course: something that helps a teaching assistant see and respond to social interaction during a session, as opposed to build progress. The authors suggest videos or access to trainers for ongoing support, a minimum standard of facilitator experience, training in neurodivergent communication styles, and a stronger theory of change. Staged, video-based training already exists: Play Included C.I.C., whose director co-wrote the manual, runs a Brick-by-Brick® training pathway that starts with an online, self-paced Certified Facilitator course (praised in its own leaflet for its "short, high-quality videos") and continues to an experiential Advanced Facilitator workshop. No controlled evaluation of whether that training changes in-session facilitation or children's outcomes was found. What training before sessions leaves unsolved is support during them. A design-and-engineering opening is the measurement gap the authors name: the fidelity checklist recorded, yes or no, whether session elements were delivered, and the trial's outcomes were questionnaires, so children's joy, agency and connectedness during sessions were not captured directly. A low-burden way to observe or record interaction during play (turn-taking, joint attention to the build, child-initiated exchanges) would serve both as facilitator feedback and as an outcome autistic children's experience could be judged by. Adjacent field: coaching tools in teacher education that use short video review of practice.

How we’d know it’s being solved

A standardised effect on social outcomes that persists to 52 weeks, measured by raters blind to allocation (the I-SOCIALISE primary outcome was rated by unblinded teachers who did not deliver the sessions), alongside session-level measures of peer interaction and children's own reports of enjoyment and belonging (the trial did collect child-reported loneliness and perceived social support as secondary outcomes). Implementation measures: independent fidelity ratings on the social-facilitation items specifically, not only the structural items. Beware the proxy the fidelity paper suggests may have steered delivery: sessions delivered and models completed are easy to count and can rise while the social aim is neglected.

Where to start

Facility-free door: design an in-session facilitator prompt system (a card deck, a tablet tally, or a bracelet-style clicker) that cues the adult to notice and name social moments rather than build progress, using the trial's published fidelity items and the programme manual's role structure; test usability with education students role-playing sessions with peers. Measurement door: build and pilot, on volunteer adults playing LEGO in assigned roles, an observation or audio-based coding scheme for peer interaction during collaborative building (who initiates, turn-taking, exchanges about the build), and estimate inter-rater reliability — a step towards the in-session measurement the fidelity paper says was missing. Partner door (design the trial, don't run it): with a school group or local authority, write a protocol comparing standard delivery with delivery plus the facilitation support and a full-school-year dose, with a blinded social outcome at 52 weeks and children's self-reported experience as co-primary outcomes, and a pre-registered analysis plan. Access note: work with autistic pupils needs school agreement, parental consent and ethics review, and autistic young people should be heard in the research (the fidelity authors recommend more of young people's voice, through public involvement and interviews); the first two doors need none. Relevant skills: interaction design, education, developmental psychology, observational methods, wearables or audio sensing.

Genes

Related problems

Stuck the same way, in other fields.

field: water & energygrants built for big utilitiesFederal resilience grants for water systems are designed for applicants that small utilities cannot be — the cost share alone can exceed a small town's annual budget, and no one tracks who gives upbuilt without the people who'd live with itsource: primaryfield: food & the living worldthe lake burst, the warning didn't arriveSatellite imagery can identify dangerous glacial lakes but warning systems can't reach mountain communities in timebuilt without the people who'd live with itsource: primaryfield: the built worldsmart defenses for dumb controllersAI intrusion detection reaches near-99% accuracy on benchmarks, but its computing cost strains the constrained hardware of industrial control systemsbuilt without the people who'd live with itsource: primaryfield: the built worldcounts of unknown accuracyHighway decisions rest on traffic counts whose accuracy is rarely known, checked by methods that vary agency to agency, and may not hold after installationbuilt without the people who'd live with itsource: primary

Sources

  • Wright B, Kingsley E, Cooper C, Biggs K, Bursnall M, Wang HI, et al. "I-SOCIALISE: Results from a cluster randomised controlled trial investigating the social competence and isolation of children with autism taking part in LEGO® based therapy ('Play Brick Therapy') clubs in school environments." Autism, 2023, doi:10.1177/13623613231159699, accessed 2026-10-22. Link ↗
  • Biggs K, Gomez de la Cuesta G, Kingsley E, McPherson J, Murray F, Laurie M, Bursnall M, Coates E, Barr A. "Lessons learnt about implementing LEGO based therapy (Play Brick Therapy) based on fidelity data and experience from a large school-based randomised controlled trial." PLoS One 21(2):e0336952, 2026, doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0336952, accessed 2026-10-22. Link ↗

Also cited in the brief

  • National Autistic Society, "Education report 2023" Link ↗
Revision notes

This brief gets checked against its sources and contains the following revisions. Future revisions get added here.

Full check

Sources read

  • Wright et al., I-SOCIALISE trial of LEGO-based therapy in schools (Autism, 2023): full text
  • Biggs et al., fidelity analysis of the I-SOCIALISE trial (PLoS One, 2026): full text
  • Play Included, Brick-by-Brick Programme leaflet for professionals (2024): full text
  • National Autistic Society, Education report 2023: full text
  • Gao et al., meta-analysis of game-based interventions for autistic children (Frontiers in Pediatrics, 2025): abstract only
  • Angelis et al., randomised study of LEGO-based therapy (Brain Sciences, 2024): abstract only
  • Wright et al., NIHR Public Health Research report on the trial (2023): abstract only
  • LEGO-based neurotherapy and executive functions study (Brain Sciences, 2026): abstract only

What changed

  • Not found in the sources, removed: the reason schools were said to take up the programme; the page still says it is low-cost, manualised and run by teaching assistants, but no longer claims that is why schools choose it.
  • Not found in the sources, replaced with what they say: the description of the existing facilitator training; the leaflet gives no course length and calls the advanced workshop experiential, and the page now uses those terms.
  • Stated more strongly than the source: the measurement starting point called an interaction coding scheme the instrument the fidelity paper says was missing; the paper names no such instrument, so it is now a step towards the in-session measurement the paper asks for.
  • Contradicted by the source, corrected: that the fidelity checklist recorded only what the adult did and that nothing captured the interaction; the checklist also had yes-or-no items on the children, and what the authors say was not captured directly is children's joy, agency and connectedness.
  • Numbers: the autism-training figures: the report gives 39% of all teachers surveyed (not of primary teachers) and 14% of secondary teachers; the page now says so, and that the trial's facilitators were mostly teaching assistants, not teachers.
  • Credit: the view that effects build with longer delivery is now credited to the programme's originator and colleagues.

Left open

None noted in this check.

Separate check of specific claims: The source notes now say which sources were read in full and which only in summary; nothing in the main text changed.

Earlier full check: Two phrases were brought back to the papers' wording: that the programme does no apparent harm, and what the authors recommend about involving autistic young people.

Separate check of specific claims: The full and display titles were toned down to what the trial found, the facilitation shortfall was narrowed to two checklist items, a claim about scarce support time was removed, and an existing facilitator training route was added.