Skip to content
problem genome

One of 592 unsolved problems in the Problem Genome, a collection written up for student design and engineering teams.

social · digital · health

blocked, muted, never mentioned

In a national Australian survey, fewer than half of 10–17-year-olds harmed online told anyone and only 6% formally reported cyberbullying, though children whose parents regularly invited them to speak up told parents more often

Source: eSafety Commissioner Open ↗source: primaryLast updated: 2026-11-17

Problem statement

Australia has built a good deal of formal help for children harmed online: online services are expected to offer user-friendly reporting pathways under the Online Safety Act 2021 (its Basic Online Safety Expectations and industry codes), the eSafety Commissioner runs its own reporting schemes, and eSafety publishes printable family tech agreements for parents and children. Children mostly do not use the formal routes. In eSafety's "Keeping kids safe online" survey (3,454 children aged 10 to 17 and one parent each, quota-sampled to be nationally representative, December 2024 to February 2025), most children who were personally targeted did something, usually blocking, muting or asking the person to stop. But fewer than half told anyone: 48% after cyberbullying, 47% after grooming-type behaviour, 39% after sexual harassment, 34% after non-consensual tracking or monitoring. Formal reports to a platform, the police or eSafety were rarer still: 6% for cyberbullying and for tracking or monitoring, 9% for sexual harassment, 26% at most (image-based abuse). Parents often did not know: about 2 in 5 were unaware that their child had experienced sexual harassment (45%), tracking or monitoring (44%) or grooming-type behaviour (42%). One factor was linked to telling: children whose parents regularly encouraged them to speak up about anything online that made them uncomfortable told their parent far more often (grooming-type behaviour 49% against 18%; cyberbullying 49% against 31%). The unsolved problem is the moment after harm, when a young person decides whether telling an adult or reporting is worth the risk, and what a family or a reporting route can put in place beforehand so that the answer is yes.

Why this matters

The barriers children gave are specific and fixable. After grooming-type behaviour, among children who told no one, 19% said they felt embarrassed or shamed, 18% thought they would no longer be allowed to use the platform or their device, and 15% thought they would get into trouble or be blamed. Among those who did not formally report, about 1 in 10 across harms did not know how or where to report (8% to 13%), and about 1 in 6 after image-based abuse or online hate did not think anything would be done. The most common reason, across harms, was that it "didn't bother me or upset me enough", which the authors note does not mean no harm was done. eSafety warns that Australia's social media minimum age (age-restricted platforms must take reasonable steps to stop under-16s holding accounts; it took effect on 10 December 2025, about a year after the survey) may make some children less likely to tell or report "if they fear being blamed, getting in trouble, or losing access to social media or other online activities." The first follow-up of the law, three months in, shows why this matters for disclosure. The share of 10–15-year-olds holding an account on an age-restricted platform fell from 52.4% to 42.1%, but many kept their accounts. And among children who said they had used social media in the past four weeks, the share whose parent did not know rose from 23.3% to 33.3%, only among parents of girls and of 10–12-year-olds. eSafety says this "may have implications for help-seeking behaviours", while noting other explanations (parents may assume the ban works, or were unusually alert before it began). So for under-16s, telling a parent about harm on a restricted platform can now also mean confessing to being on it, and reporting through a platform's own tools can mean using an account the child is not supposed to have. eSafety's help page for young people says "You won't get into trouble if you still have an account" (archived copy of 8 June 2026); that is the regulator speaking, and it does not say what a parent will do. The positive side is real: when parents knew, most responded with emotional support and practical guidance, and most children took some self-protective step.

What’s been tried and why it hasn’t worked

(1) Formal reporting routes. Industry is expected to provide reporting pathways, and eSafety runs its own schemes. Children used them for 3% to 26% of their most recent or most impactful experiences, depending on the harm. The report says children face barriers "even when they are aware of reporting tools, including uncertainty about reporting processes and lack of trust in reporting outcomes," citing UK work by Ofcom (2024) and Internet Matters (2025) that found the same. The US National Academies made the same point in 2024, recommending reporting and adjudication systems that are "easy to use, universal, accountable, and transparent" (recommendation 7-1). (2) Rules and controls at home. Many parents who learned of a harm responded by setting new rules or changing device or app settings, and parents of 10–12-year-olds did so more than parents of teens. The same children named losing their device or platform as a reason not to tell, so the response most within a parent's reach can also teach a child to keep quiet next time. eSafety says this fear was strongest among younger children; for older teens the bigger reasons were that the harm "didn't bother me or upset me enough" and doubt that reporting would help. (3) Family and classroom agreements. eSafety's printable agreements already contain a help-seeking line. The 5–8 agreement has the child promise "If I see or hear something online that makes me feel worried, scared or sad, I will ask for help", and its parent notes say to "reassure them that they won't get into trouble", name trusted adults and give Kids Helpline. The classroom agreement asks "Where would you go to report a serious online incident?" eSafety's 13–15 agreement, written around the age restrictions (its file is dated August 2026), has now been read for this page. Every example statement in it is the teen's, such as "I'll ask for help when situations online are beyond what I can manage on my own" and "I understand why some social media platforms are only for 16+ and how this applies to me". The parent's side is a list of things to talk about, among them to "Discuss how to report harmful content or behaviour, how to block someone and where to go for help" and to "remind them that it's not their fault", and it points families to an eSafety help page "including if something happens on social media and they're under 16". The page the family fills in has an "I will ..." column for the teen, a "My safety network" box for names and phone numbers, Kids Helpline, 000, and one reporting line: "Report harmful content to the platform, or eSafety.gov.au/report if they don't help you." It has no statement in the parent's or carer's name, no place to sign, and no words about trouble, consequences or losing access; families are told to "display it in your home as a visual reminder". eSafety's 9–12 agreement goes further in its advice to parents ("Reassure them they won't get into trouble or lose access to being online"), but that is advice to the parent, not one of its example agreement statements. Other published agreements already put the promise in writing. SchoolTV's "Family Tech Agreement: 13 to 16", a template written around under-16 social media rules (it does not name a country), has a teenager's pledge and a parent/carer's pledge, each signed. The teenager's part ends "I know that if I'm worried or have made a mistake online, I can always talk to my parents or a trusted adult — and I won't get into trouble just for being honest", and the parent pledges "I will use the restorative steps if my child makes a mistake". The US Family Online Safety Institute's agreement for ages 13 and under has a signed parent half that promises to "stay calm so you always feel safe coming to me"; FOSI's teen version has the teen pledge to speak up "even if I think I might get in trouble", beside a blank for the consequence that will apply. Some templates put a promise about telling in the parent's name. A US agreement from MMGuardian, a parental-control app maker, opens with a signed parent section: "My child will not lose their phone privileges if they immediately tell me when they think that they are being cyberbullied, or are contacted by an unknown person, or receive images or videos of a naked or partially nude person or that are sexually focused, or receive a request to send such an image or video." An Australian parent and young person mobile contract by Jonny Shannon and Liz Walker, hosted by St Leonard's College in Victoria, has the parent or caregiver promise not to overreact "if they tell me this, but will calmly walk through basics of; STOP, BLOCK & TELL (Report via Esafety Website)", next to a note that a top reason students don't tell about cyberbullying "is the fear that they would overreact or restrict digital access". A third, the Family Online Safety Contract published in the same words by ThinkUKnow and by the Carly Ryan Foundation, has the parent or carer tell the child "you can come to me at any time with this concern, and we will work together to find a solution", beside the line "This contract is a requirement of having this service provided to you"; it promises nothing about the device or about how the parent will react. What these documents leave open: in SchoolTV's template the no-trouble line is in the teenager's words, not a promise in the parent's name, and it sits beside "I understand there are consequences if I break this agreement" and a restorative step that allows a "short break from devices", which is the loss children named as a reason not to tell; where the promise is the parent's, it comes with conditions and close watching: MMGuardian's holds only if the child tells "immediately", beside the child's pledges to keep parents told of the passwords to all their accounts where parents need to know them and to talk only with people "approved by my parents", and Shannon and Walker's contract gives parents "a right to look at my phone whenever there's a need"; the SchoolTV teenager pledges "I will not attempt to get around the Social Media Regulations", so a teen harmed on a restricted platform has broken the agreement by telling, and nothing says what happens then; the help line is one item among many; none gives platform-by-platform reporting steps or a route that needs no account (Shannon and Walker's names the eSafety website in one line, as eSafety's own 9–12 and 13–15 agreements do); they are page-length documents, not something made for the young person to carry; and no evaluation of whether any family tech agreement changes disclosure was found. The one trial of a family plan found was null on its own outcome: in a US randomised trial of the American Academy of Pediatrics family media use plan (1,520 parent–adolescent pairs, ages 12 to 17), completing the plan did not change adolescents' media rule engagement (between-group difference −0.1, 95% CI −1.1 to 0.9). The plan as trialled had sections on screen-free zones and times, curfews, choosing media, balance, manners, digital citizenship, safety and sleep; none of the section names or example options the paper lists is about telling an adult, and the trial did not measure disclosure. A 2026 systematic review of disclosure of technology-assisted child sexual abuse (studies from 2015 to 2025) also concludes that "Further research is needed to develop effective disclosure interventions", and lists "trusted adults who responded with empathy and understanding" among the facilitators. (4) Encouragement to talk. It is linked to more disclosure in this survey, but it is a correlation from one cross-sectional survey, and parents' awareness was weakest for the most stigmatised harms. Fathers were generally less likely than mothers to know about some harms and to give some kinds of support. eSafety's own conclusion is a list of resources still needed: help for parents "to respond calmly and supportively when children disclose", resources that reach fathers as well as mothers, and better awareness of reporting pathways.

What would unlock progress

Something agreed before any harm happens that makes telling cheap: a known adult, a promise that telling will not by itself cost the young person their phone or account, and a short, concrete route to reporting on the platforms they actually use. It has to suit teens who want independence, since 10–12-year-olds were more likely than 16–17-year-olds to act after some harms, particularly by telling a parent, and it has to work for boys, who more often said the harm did not bother them enough. The report itself suggests "shared family expectations and agreements regarding technology use and online safety" that are reviewed as children grow. eSafety's 5–8 agreement already includes "ask for help" and tells parents to "reassure them that they won't get into trouble", and a signed 13–16 template written around under-16 rules already has the teenager write "I won't get into trouble just for being honest". eSafety's own 13–15 agreement has the teen's "I'll ask for help", a box for the names and numbers of trusted adults, and one reporting line (the platform, then eSafety.gov.au/report "if they don't help you"); it has no promise from the parent or carer at all. Parent-signed templates already promise that telling will not cost the phone (MMGuardian, if the child tells "immediately") or bring an overreaction (Shannon and Walker). So the design question is narrower: whether a parent's promise that does not depend on telling at once or on keeping every other rule, which the young person carries, and which comes with concrete reporting steps, changes anything. No trial of any of these templates has measured disclosure, and the one trial of a family plan found no change even in rule-following. It also has to cover what a family does when telling means admitting use of a platform the child is not allowed on under the age restrictions; the existing 13–16 template treats that use as a breach, and eSafety's 13–15 agreement points families to a help page for when "something happens on social media and they're under 16" but writes down nothing about what the parent will do.

How we’d know it’s being solved

(a) Share of harmed children who told a parent or other trusted adult, by harm type, against this survey's baselines (for example 48% after cyberbullying, 39% after sexual harassment). (b) Share who formally reported, against 6% (cyberbullying) and 9% (sexual harassment). (c) Fewer children giving "I thought I wouldn't be allowed to use that platform … or my device anymore" and "I didn't know how or where to report it" as reasons. (d) Parents' unawareness falling from around 45% for sexual harassment. Beware the proxy: downloads of a template or a resource page are not disclosures.

Where to start

Facility-free door: using only the report's Tables 4 and 5 (reasons for not telling and not reporting, by harm), its parent-awareness figures and its conclusions, map which barriers a family agreement could address (fear of losing the device, blame, not knowing where to report) and which it cannot (shame after the most serious harms, low trust in platforms). Then write a one-page "if something goes wrong online" section for a family agreement: who to tell, what the parent promises, and the reporting steps for three platforms teens use. Test whether it is understood with university student volunteers recruited openly on campus, using hypothetical scenarios only. No one is asked about their own experiences of online harm, now or as a child. Tell volunteers the topic before they sign up, let them stop at any time, and hand out the campus support contact. What carries over: whether the promise and the steps are clear and believable. What does not: whether a 14-year-old would actually tell.

Printed-card door: design a printed object the young person keeps (a card for a phone case or wallet) that carries a parent's signed promise about disclosure and the reporting steps, made in matching parent and teen halves so each holds the other's commitment. What already exists: eSafety's printable family tech agreements by age group, which already include an "I will ask for help" line and tell parents to reassure children they won't get into trouble (the 13–15 version, written around the age restrictions, already has the teen's line "I'll ask for help when situations online are beyond what I can manage on my own", a "My safety network" box for the names and numbers of trusted adults, Kids Helpline, 000 and the line "Report harmful content to the platform, or eSafety.gov.au/report if they don't help you"; the card should start from these and add what that agreement leaves out: any promise in the parent's or carer's name, any word on trouble or losing access, which the 5–8 and 9–12 versions give only as advice to parents, anything written down about harm met on a platform the teen is not allowed to use, reporting steps beyond that one line, and a form the teen carries, since the agreement is made to "display it in your home as a visual reminder"); SchoolTV's signed 13–16 agreement, with matching teenager and parent pledges, restorative steps and the teenager's line "I won't get into trouble just for being honest"; the Family Online Safety Institute's agreement, whose signed parent half promises to stay calm; MMGuardian's agreement, whose signed parent section promises the child will not lose phone privileges for telling at once about cyberbullying, unknown contacts or sexual images; Shannon and Walker's Australian mobile contract, whose parent promises not to overreact and points to reporting via the eSafety website; the ThinkUKnow and Carly Ryan Foundation contract, whose parent invites the child to come "at any time"; the American Academy of Pediatrics Family Media Plan (trialled in the US with no change in rule-following); and platform help pages. None of these was found to have been evaluated for its effect on disclosure. Signed, matching halves and a parent's no-loss promise already exist, so this card differs only in three ways, and each one has to earn its place: the parent's promise does not depend on telling at once or on keeping every other rule, and says what it covers, including harm met on a platform the teen is not supposed to be on, which the 13–16 template counts as a breach; the young person carries it; and it gives reporting steps platform by platform, where eSafety's 13–15 agreement gives one line (the platform, then eSafety.gov.au/report), and says what to do when the teen has no account to report from. Test its wording, look and whether people would keep it with two groups reachable on campus: student volunteers, and university staff or students who are parents of teenagers, recruited openly. Use invented scenarios only; no one is asked about their own experiences of online harm. Tell volunteers the topic before they sign up, let them stop at any time, and hand out the campus support contact. Parents can say whether they would sign the promise; no teenager is involved at this stage. What carries over from parents near a US or European campus: whether the promise is one they would sign and keep, and whether the card is clear. What does not: they do not live under Australia's minimum age, so they cannot judge the steps for children on platforms they are not allowed on; that part waits for the partner door.

Partner door (design the trial, don't run it): with a school or parent organisation, design a comparison of the existing family tech agreement against it plus the disclosure card, with pre-registered outcomes (telling a trusted adult; knowing where to report), measured by a short survey that asks about knowledge and intentions, not about harms experienced. Access note: any study with children is with minors and needs ethics review, parental consent and safeguarding procedures for any disclosure; questions about online sexual harms need specialist review. Relevant skills: communication and graphic design, service design, developmental psychology, survey methods.

Genes

Related problems

Stuck the same way, in other fields.

field: food & the living worldthe machines exist, the burning continuesIndia subsidizes the machines to end crop residue burning — but 44,000-98,000 people still die annually because equipment access was never the only barrierbuilt without the people who'd live with itsource: secondaryfield: health & medicinethe exercise rarely handed outHome balance exercises help chronic dizziness and have been packaged as booklets and free websites, yet primary care still rarely prescribes them, many trial patients did not report finishing them, and GPs keep prescribing anti-vertigo drugs with weak evidencebuilt without the people who'd live with itsource: primaryfield: food & the living worldthe mold cure nobody usesAflasafe cuts aflatoxin contamination by 80–100% but remains poorly adopted while people get liver cancerbuilt without the people who'd live with itsource: primaryfield: health & medicinethe ventilator has a password problemMany networked medical devices in hospitals are unpatchable and exposed to cyber attackbuilt without the people who'd live with itsource: primary

Sources

  • eSafety Commissioner, "Who knows? Who helps?: Children's help seeking, parental awareness, and barriers to support after online harm." Australian Government, November 2026. Contributing authors: Melanie Burton, Claire Lister, Savannah Minihan, Mariesa Nicholas and Tatum Street (read through the Internet Archive copy, because the eSafety site did not answer), accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗ Link 2 ↗
  • National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine. Social Media and Adolescent Health. Washington, DC: The National Academies Press, 2024, doi:10.17226/27396 (Summary), accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • eSafety Commissioner. (2026). Early days, early insights: Understanding experiences of social media age restrictions at the three-month follow-up. Australian Government, July 2026 (read through the Internet Archive copy), accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗ Link 2 ↗
  • eSafety Commissioner. Creating a family tech agreement for 5 to 8 year olds and Online Safety Classroom Agreement: Primary and secondary school, Internet Archive copies, accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗ Link 2 ↗
  • eSafety Commissioner. Creating a family tech agreement for 13- to 15-year-olds, Creating a family tech agreement for 9- to 12-year-olds and Creating a family tech agreement for 5- to 8-year-olds, accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗ Link 2 ↗ Link 3 ↗
  • Moreno MA, Binger KS, Zhao Q, Eickhoff JC. "Effect of a Family Media Use Plan on Media Rule Engagement Among Adolescents: A Randomized Clinical Trial." JAMA Pediatrics 175(4):351, 2021, doi:10.1001/jamapediatrics.2020.5629 (full text), accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • McGinn T, Chereni A, McGinnis E. "A systematic review of the perceived barriers to and facilitators of technology assisted – Child sexual abuse disclosure." Child Abuse & Neglect 172:107869, 2026, doi:10.1016/j.chiabu.2025.107869 (abstract), accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • MMGuardian. "Our Family Online Tech Agreement", accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • Shannon J, Walker L. "Your Mobile Phone Contract between parents and their young person", hosted by St Leonard's College, accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • ThinkUKnow. "Family Online Safety Contract" and Carly Ryan Foundation. "Family Online Safety Contract", accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗ Link 2 ↗
  • eSafety Commissioner. "I need help: Something has happened online" (read in the Internet Archive copy), accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗ Link 2 ↗
  • SchoolTV. "Family Tech Agreement: 13 to 16", accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • Family Online Safety Institute. "Family Online Safety Agreement, Ages 13 and Under" and "Family Online Safety Agreement For Teens", accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗ Link 2 ↗
Revision notes

This brief gets checked against its sources and contains the following revisions. Future revisions get added here.

Worth knowing

  • The link between parents encouraging children to speak up and children telling them comes from one survey taken at one point in time, so it shows the two go together, not that one causes the other
  • The survey ran about a year before Australia's social media minimum age took effect; the worry that the age rule may make children less willing to tell is the regulator's forecast, not a finding

Full check

Sources read

  • eSafety Commissioner, Who knows? Who helps? Children's help seeking after online harm (2026): full text
  • eSafety Commissioner, Early days, early insights: three-month follow-up of the social media age restrictions (2026): full text
  • eSafety Commissioner, family tech agreement for 13- to 15-year-olds: full text
  • eSafety Commissioner, family tech agreement for 9- to 12-year-olds: full text
  • eSafety Commissioner, family tech agreement for 5- to 8-year-olds, current version: full text (searched; the relevant parts read)
  • eSafety Commissioner, earlier family tech agreement for 5- to 8-year-olds and the classroom agreement: full text
  • eSafety Commissioner, family tech agreement page: full text
  • SchoolTV, Family Tech Agreement: 13 to 16: full text
  • Family Online Safety Institute, family agreements for ages 13 and under and for teens: full text
  • MMGuardian, Our Family Online Tech Agreement: full text
  • Shannon and Walker, mobile phone contract between parents and their young person: full text
  • National Academies, Social Media and Adolescent Health (2024): full text (the Summary chapter)
  • Moreno et al., randomised trial of a family media use plan (JAMA Pediatrics, 2021): full text
  • McGinn, Chereni and McGinnis, systematic review of barriers to and facilitators of disclosing technology-assisted child sexual abuse (Child Abuse & Neglect, 2026): abstract only (the page quotes only words that appear in the abstract)

What changed

  • Not found in the sources, removed: the printed-card starting point said eSafety's own reporting can be used without an account; no source read says so, and the claim was taken out.
  • Stated more strongly than the source: the problem statement said children mostly do not use any of the help on offer, which took in the family agreements; the survey measures telling someone and formal reporting, not use of agreements, so it now says children mostly do not use the formal reporting routes.
  • Citation details: eSafety's agreements for 13- to 15-, 9- to 12- and 5- to 8-year-olds were added to the source list under the titles printed on them.
  • Entry points: the printed-card starting point now begins from what eSafety's agreement for 13- to 15-year-olds already carries (the teen's own help line, a box for trusted adults, Kids Helpline and one reporting line) and lists what it leaves out: any promise in the parent's name, any word on trouble or losing access, and anything about harm met on a platform the teen is not allowed to use; the card's third difference now asks for reporting steps platform by platform, where the agreement gives one line, and for what to do when the teen has no account to report from.
  • Other: What's Been Tried and What Would Unlock Progress now describe eSafety's agreement for 13- to 15-year-olds in its own words: every example statement is the teen's, the parent's side is a list of things to talk about, and there is no statement in the parent's name and no place to sign; the 9- to 12-year-old agreement's line telling parents to reassure children they won't get into trouble or lose access is now given as advice to the parent, not one of the agreement's own statements; the list of what templates leave open now notes that eSafety's 9- to 12 and 13- to 15-year-old agreements also name the eSafety website in one line.

Left open

  • what the UK studies by Ofcom and Internet Matters found (given only as the eSafety report describes them; not opened)

Separate check of specific claims: Two existing family agreements the page quotes were added to the source list, and the two campus testing doors now tell volunteers the topic in advance, let them stop at any time and hand out the campus support contact.

Separate check of specific claims: A sentence saying a platform's reporting tools assume an account was softened to what the page's own figures support, eSafety's help-page line telling young people they won't get into trouble if they still have an account was added, a third Australian family contract (ThinkUKnow and the Carly Ryan Foundation) was added as an earlier attempt, and citations for the family-plan trial and for McGinn, Chereni and McGinnis's disclosure review were added to the source list.

Earlier full check: Six statements were brought in line with the sources: a comparison with other countries that no source makes was removed, eSafety's reassurance to parents is now quoted exactly, a template is no longer called Australian, one template's password pledge and how the templates are kept now follow what the documents say, and what the family-plan trial's list of sections shows is stated more carefully.

Separate check of specific claims: A search for existing products found signed family agreements from SchoolTV, the Family Online Safety Institute and MMGuardian and an Australian parent and young person phone contract, plus the one trial of a family media plan and a review of disclosure research; the page and the printed-card starting point now begin from what these already promise.

Separate check of specific claims: The second starting point was renamed a printed-card project, and it now uses invented scenarios only, asks no one about their own experiences of online harm, and says what campus parents can and cannot stand in for.

Earlier full check: Every survey figure was checked against the eSafety report; a claim that existing family agreements do not focus on telling was removed, eSafety's own family and classroom agreements and its three-month follow-up of the age restrictions were added, and the comparison by parent is now between fathers and mothers, as the report gives it.