Skip to content
problem genome

One of 592 unsolved problems in the Problem Genome, a collection written up for student design and engineering teams.

health

the brace that holds the foot, and the toddlers who stop wearing it

Clubfoot braces are worn at night until age four or five, and in an Iraqi cohort a third of toddlers stopped wearing them as prescribed: one-leg braces did worse in a Norwegian follow-up and a systematic review, a non-randomised Brazilian study found the opposite, and two-boot dynamic bars look better only against historical controls

Source: Doski, “When Does Brace Noncompliance Occur in Patients with Clubfoot…” Open ↗source: primaryLast updated: 2026-11-17

Problem statement

Clubfoot is a birth condition in which one or both feet turn inward and down. About 80% of affected children live in low- and middle-income countries (Zapparoli and Volpon 2025, citing a global review). The standard treatment, the Ponseti method, corrects the foot with weekly casts in the first months of life. The correction is then held with a foot abduction brace: two open-toed boots joined by a bar, worn nearly all day for about three months and then at night and during naps until age four or five. The brace is what prevents relapse, and the brace is what families stop using. In a 2020–2024 study at a childhood disability centre in Duhok, Iraq, all 34 children kept to the brace through the first year; 11 (32.4%) became non-compliant, starting at a mean age of 14.6 months and rising most after the second birthday. Braces that tie only one leg, or let the legs move, have been made to fix this. One-leg braces are easier for families, but in Norway children who used one had stiffer feet and more minor surgery for relapse 8 to 11 years later, and a 2022 systematic review found more relapse with them (a 2025 umbrella review repeats its figures). A 2025 Brazilian study of a new one-leg brace, not randomised, found the opposite. Two-boot dynamic bars, which keep both feet held but let the legs move, have done better than the standard bar on wear and relapse, but only against historical control groups over about two years; in the one small randomised trial found (30 US children, about 18 months) and in a small Brazilian record review, they did no better and no worse than the standard bar. A 2026 Toronto team that reviewed them says the spring hinges can briefly let the foot slip out of position, the long-term effect is unknown, and its cost table prices them above the standard bar. The unsolved problem is a night brace that a walking toddler will accept for two or three more years, that never lets go of the corrected position, and that is cheap enough for a free programme, with evidence beyond a few months or a historical comparison.

Why this matters

Relapse after a lost brace phase means repeat casting or surgery. In Uganda, where a national programme supplies braces free of charge, about 21% of children drop out of clinical follow-up within two years of starting the brace. The authors name poverty and transport as the primary reasons for dropping out, and the programme has already cut that rate from about 40% by opening closer clinics, paying transport for the poorest families and training volunteer parent educators. In a comparison of 97 adherent and 66 non-adherent Ugandan children (adherent here means the family kept coming to clinic; the authors say they cannot be certain the brace was worn every night), non-adherent children had 2.6 times the odds of the deformity coming back. When Ugandan parents were asked which phase of treatment was hardest, 50.8% of the parents of non-adherent children named bracing, against 23.6% of the parents of adherent children. They described the child crying, fighting the brace or taking it off ("my son used to cry a lot and fight the time of bracing. Sometimes he would remove them"). So the brace itself is one barrier among several, but it is the one the family meets every night. The Iraqi study puts the danger in time: the brace is kept while the child is a baby and is lost when the child becomes a toddler. A Swedish national register of 288 children with isolated clubfoot shows the same pattern in a rich country, if smaller: 76% continued orthotic treatment (the brace or another orthosis) to age four or longer, and 35% changed orthosis type before age four, which was more common among those who stopped early; those who stopped early had milder feet at birth. Several of the newest designs were tested only in infants or over one month.

What’s been tried and why it hasn’t worked

(1) One-leg braces. These leave one leg free, so the child can crawl, kick and be carried more easily. In a Norwegian multicentre cohort (94 children, 133 feet, examined at a mean age of 9.3 years), compliance was best with a custom-made, above-the-knee one-leg dynamic brace. Yet feet treated with it had less dorsal flexion (15° or more in 62% against 83% with the standard two-boot brace), more forefoot adduction, worse parent-reported function and a higher risk of surgery for relapse. Relapse surgery was needed in 42% of one-leg-brace feet against 24% (minor surgery 33% against 14%; major surgery about equal, 9% against 10%). At two to five years the same cohort had shown no difference, although that earlier analysis was by intention to treat and this one left out children who changed brace. Within the cohort, poor compliance was not linked to worse feet. The authors conclude: "Our results do not support the use of a unilateral foot abduction brace in clubfoot treatment." A 2022 systematic review (Agarwal et al., 10 studies; abstract read) found that one-leg braces "may have an edge" on adherence, but "the available comparative studies however showed inferiority of unilateral orthoses," with "high recurrence rates." A 2025 Chinese umbrella review repeats the pooled figures from the Agarwal review: relapse of 22% with two-boot braces against 30% with one-leg braces. Two other results point the other way, and both are weak. In an Egyptian randomised trial by a Cairo University team (38 children aged six months or less at entry, 60 feet, 24 months; full text read), an above-knee brace called FERAK and the Denis Browne brace gave similar final Pirani scores, and good or intermediate parent compliance was 86.7% against 66.7%, a difference that was not statistically significant. The FERAK brace has no bar joining the legs: in a child with one affected foot it is fitted to that leg only, and each leg moves on its own. Relapse needing further treatment occurred in 1 of 30 feet with FERAK and 4 of 30 with the Denis Browne brace (no test of this difference is reported), all in children whose parents reported bad compliance. The authors name the 24-month follow-up as a limit. A one-leg dynamic brace from Maine, the Cunningham brace (Dynamic Torsional Knee Ankle Foot Orthosis), is sold, including through a London clinic in a treatment package of £3,182 for one foot; in a retrospective review of the 26 of its 112 patients followed for at least two years, 88% were compliant and 8% had a recurrence, with compliance taken from parents' reports, no control group, and one author employed by the maker. A Messiah University student team has tested the Cunningham brace (2022 symposium poster; full text read): it fitted capacitance force sensors to the brace and recorded forces on patients at the maker's clinic, adapted the sensors to the Steenbeek brace for a planned comparison of the two, and ran a fatigue test on the bench, a linear actuator applying repetitive force to the brace's thigh piece, which the team says fatigues at the knee; the poster gives preliminary results only, and the two-brace comparison was still to come. The Iraqi author writes that comparative studies found the alternative braces researchers have invented inferior to the two-boot brace in preventing recurrence (the two studies cited for this are of one-leg braces), yet suggests them as a "salvage option" for a child who has started to become non-compliant with the standard brace, one that "may diminish the relapse rate"; the two papers cited for that suggestion are of dynamic two-boot braces.

(2) A new one-leg brace in Brazil (2025). At the University of São Paulo in Ribeirão Preto, a thermoformed polypropylene brace from thigh to foot (UNIC-Brace, about US$100 against US$160 for the standard brace) was compared with the standard Denis Browne brace in a prospective, non-randomised study (58 and 51 children, at least three years of follow-up). Failure was lower with the new brace (17.2% of feet against 41.3%), and so was non-adherence (13.8% against 23.5% of patients); fewer families were dissatisfied (5.2% against 13.7%). These results run against the Norwegian ones. The authors list the limits themselves: brace choice depended on which model was available, the evaluation was not blinded, only short-term results were reported, and the brace holds the ankle still, which "may contribute to calf muscle atrophy." The control group's feet were also more severe at the start (higher Pirani score), and a child with both feet affected needs two of the new braces, about US$1,400 over three years against US$960 for the standard brace.

(3) Two-boot braces that let the legs move. These already exist and have the best results so far. With the Dobbs dynamic bar (US, 2007; 28 children, about 29 months), non-compliance was reported in 7% against 41% in the authors' earlier standard-brace series, and blistering in 7% against 23.5%. In a second US study (2009; 57 children per group, about two years), compliance was 81% against 47% as the abstract prints it (its own count for the standard brace, 21 of 57, comes to 37%, and the Toronto team's table gives that group's non-compliance as 63%), recurrence 19% against 39%, and five standard-brace children but none on the dynamic bar needed posteromedial release (both abstracts read). Both compared with historical controls, not at random, and neither abstract says how wear was measured, so the Norwegian authors' point about parent-reported wear may apply. The comparisons that did not use historical controls found no gain. In a US randomised trial (2008–2012; 30 children, 15 per group, mean follow-up 18.7 months; abstract read), with Mitchell shoes on either a dynamic or a static bar, there were four recurrences in each group and "no differences were found between the two brace types," with compliance self-reported. A Brazilian retrospective review (28 children, 43 feet; abstract read) found recurrence in 8.33% of feet on the Denis Browne bar and 5.26% on the Dobbs bar, with no significant difference. The 2026 Toronto team, who reviewed these designs, write that the Dobbs bar's spring-loaded hinges "can cause intermittent loss of the corrective foot position" and resist inversion, that "the long-term impact of this is unknown," and that the literature is limited and conflicting. They list costs of about US$107 for the standard Mitchell-Ponseti bar, US$27 for the Iowa flex bar, US$150–200 for the Dobbs bar, US$156 for the Move Bar and US$300 for the one-leg ADM orthosis. Their own spring-free multi-joint bar was tested in a feasibility study that randomised 11 children aged 1 to 3 to the new bar or their usual Mitchell-Ponseti bar for 30 days: all 7 parents in the new-bar arm found it more comfortable, there was no inferiority over one month, and temperature sensors found non-compliance in 3 of 11 children where parents' logs found none. The prototype costs about US$130, and the authors call for longer studies. The paper also records mechanical failures during the trial: the first version's slider had a slot one child could put a finger into, a pinch risk (the sliders were then made solid); the ball-joint linkages broke on three separate occasions, the ball joint popping out of its socket (the joints were then reinforced); one child, the tallest and heaviest in the study, snapped the crossbar after 35 days; and slight wear on all the brass ball-joint inserts slightly shifted the corrective foot position (maximum change under 10°). (The trial's registry entry, NCT05293743, lists 17 enrolled; its posted results say 5 withdrew before starting and 12 were randomised, of whom 1 control child withdrew after the first visit, which leaves the 11 children in the paper.) The Toronto bar has no springs: in the team's patent application (US20230277352A1, The Hospital for Sick Children, filed 2023, still pending after a final rejection in 2025), rollers let each boot slide along the bar and limited ball joints let it tilt, while a fixed 10° of dorsiflexion and a pinned minimum external rotation hold the foot. A second spring-free coupling exists on paper. The University of Iowa's "Kick-Bar" (its prototyping studio's page says "Patent Pending" and gives no number; the patent matched to it here, by inventor and design, is US12279986B2, granted 2025, in force to 2042) joins the boots with two stacked parallel bars and four hinges, so that one foot can rise with the knee "while maintaining the abduction angle and rotational orientation of both feet"; the patent names the need for "a more comfortable and more tolerable product." The university's prototyping studio built prototypes that drew feedback from parents and doctors, and a vice-president of an organisation called Clubfoot Solutions, quoted on the studio's page, says the studio turned the concept into a workable, manufacturable device for that organisation's new bracing system; a 2020 conference paper by a Protostudios author and the patent's three inventors (abstract read) names one test only, that each version of the design was tested for fit with the commercial shoe and platform system, and says special attention was paid to putting the brace on and taking it off; no trial in children and no sale was found. In India, a 2025 3D-printed adjustable splint (under 152 g; its authors estimate about US$25 a unit and quote much higher prices for the Dobbs and Mitchell braces, about US$1,200 and US$350, than the Toronto table does, calling their comparison "indicative rather than directly equivalent") reported 94% compliance and no sores in 33 infants. But it was only for babies up to six months, followed for three months, with compliance taken from parents' logbooks, and the authors name a possible Hawthorne effect.

(4) Boots and sores. In an Australian hospital, pressure sores that forced a pause in bracing were nearly twice as common after a switch from Markell boots on a Denis Browne bar (2010–2018) to Mitchell boots on a Ponseti bar (2018–2021): 22.9% against 12.6%, in 247 children, in a retrospective comparison of two eras; non-compliance was recorded in 33.2% overall (abstract read). In a MiracleFeet-supported clinic at Khyber Teaching Hospital, Pakistan, 42.9% of 91 children under two had blisters or sores at 24 hours and 41.8% still had them at day 7; most problems declined by day 30, compliance stayed high and no child relapsed over six months (abstract read).

(5) Support for families. Education, reminders, closer clinics and transport help are the other route, and in Uganda they have worked (dropout about 40% down to about 21%). A 2026 scoping review of low- and middle-income settings (preprint, single reviewer; full text read) finds that adherence there is "constrained primarily by economic and structural factors" and concludes that "evaluated adherence interventions remain scarce." It also names "the child's distress with the brace eroding caregiver resolve" as a separate determinant.

(6) Shorter bracing. A Swiss centre lengthened the Achilles tendon and did a limited posterior release at the outset, then braced for about 2.1 years instead of the four to six years usually advised; in 107 children followed retrospectively, results were similar to those reported for the standard method. It is a surgical route, with no concurrent control group.

What would unlock progress

Dynamic two-boot bars show the direction; what they leave open is the target. The sources point to three demands at once. The brace must keep both feet held in abduction and dorsiflexion at every moment, since one-leg designs lost correction in the longer Norwegian follow-up and in a systematic review, and spring hinges may let the foot slip. It must give the child enough freedom to turn and kick in sleep that the brace is not fought. And it must be cheap enough to be given free and replaced as the child grows (the Brazilian children needed six to seven braces over three years), nearer the US$27–107 of a plain bar (the MiracleFeet brace, a plain two-boot brace with clip-off shoes made for low-income programmes, costs less than US$20 to produce, its maker says) than the US$150–200 of a dynamic one. Better wear data would help decide between designs: in the Norwegian study, brace use came from parents' reports, and the authors note that parents tend to overestimate it; in Toronto, sensors and logs disagreed. Short trials will not settle the question, since the Norwegian difference was not found at 2–5 years and was found at 8–11 years, in an analysis that left out children who changed brace.

How we’d know it’s being solved

(a) Night-time wear kept up from age 12 to 48 months, measured by a sensor rather than by parents' report. The Iraqi finding gives the benchmark: non-compliance began at a mean of 14.6 months and rose most after 26.6 months. (b) Relapse and surgery rates no worse than with the standard two-boot brace at long follow-up (the Norwegian difference was found at 8 to 11 years, not at 2 to 5). (c) Fewer children stopping because of sores or distress (pressure sores in 12.6–22.9% in Australia; sores in 42.9% at 24 hours in Pakistan). (d) A cost per child, counting replacements as the child grows, that a free national programme such as Uganda's can carry.

Where to start

Safety first. This is a medical brace that holds a corrected foot in a baby or toddler. A wrong brace can let the foot slip back or cause sores. No part a student team makes is ever worn by a child, not even for a moment. Student work stays on the bench, on a doll, or with adults. This page is not treatment advice; families should follow their own clinic's bracing plan.

Facility-free door (make a thing, bench only): Check what is sold and patented first. Many braces already exist: the standard two-boot brace (Mitchell-Ponseti bar, Iowa flex bar, Denis Browne bar, the low-cost MiracleFeet brace), one-leg braces (Norway, the Brazilian UNIC-Brace, the UK ADM, the Cunningham brace), two-boot dynamic bars (Dobbs, Move Bar, the Toronto 2026 bar) and an adjustable 3D-printed splint for infants (India 2025). Dynamic bars already let the legs move; they report better wear against historical controls, but no gain in the one small randomised trial. Spring-free couplings also already exist on paper: the Toronto bar (rollers and limited ball joints, patent pending) and the Iowa Kick-Bar (two parallel bars and four hinges, patent granted 2025 and in force to 2042, prototypes only). So do not make another infant splint, another dynamic bar or another spring-free coupling as if it were new. Start from what is still open: the sources found report no bench test of whether any of these couplings keeps the set foot angles over many leg movements (the nearest is the Messiah student fatigue test of the one-leg Cunningham brace's thigh piece, described above, which looked at material fatigue, not angle drift); the Toronto bar clips onto standard Mitchell-Ponseti boots, but nothing was found on couplings for the low-cost boots that free programmes supply; and the dynamic designs cost more than the plain bars. (The Iraqi author could not explain why toddlers found the night brace uncomfortable and suggests filming children asleep in it; the Toronto team's premise is that freer leg movement improves tolerance.) Build bench models of the three principles from the published patent drawings (spring hinge, roller and ball joint, parallel bars and hinges) with 3D-printed parts and stock hardware, sized for children aged 1 to 4, plus any simpler variant of your own that fits programme boots. Every bench model stays on the doll rig in the workshop: it is never fitted to boots a child wears, and it is never given or lent to a family or a clinic. These are test models for a rig, not products; the Iowa patent is in force, so anything meant for sale would need its owner's licence. That licence line is information only: nothing a student team builds under this page is for sale or for use on a child. Test them on a rig: a jointed toddler-size leg model made from a doll or printed parts. Measure whether the set angles hold after many cycles of hip and knee movement, and compare the drift across the mechanisms, starting the drift test and a pinch-point and breakage check from what the Toronto paper reports for its prototype in use (worn ball-joint inserts shifted the foot position by under 10°, ball joints broke three times, a crossbar snapped, and a child got a finger into a slider slot). Log weight, parts cost and how many sizes are needed from 12 to 48 months. Compare cost on paper with the plain bars (US$27–107), the Dobbs bar (US$150–200), the Toronto prototype (about US$130) and the Brazilian brace (US$100). No partner or data is needed.

Parent door (the nightly routine, adults only): Parents put the brace on every night, often with a crying child. Test the routine, not the child. Time how long it takes an adult to put both boots and the coupling on a weighted toddler-size doll in a dark room, compared with a standard bar built the same way, and note the steps where people go wrong. In every session the model stays in the room, it is handled by adults only, and no child is present. Start with adult volunteers on campus. Then bring in parents of children in brace treatment, reached through a children's orthopaedic clinic or a parent support group near campus. They take part on their own, without their children. Even this adult-only study needs an ethics review, because the parents are recruited through their child's care.

User door (design the test): The real wearers are young children in clubfoot programmes. They cannot be reached from a campus, and no student team should try. So the deliverable is a protocol handed to an orthopaedic team, who would run it only after ethics review: a randomised comparison of a spring-free coupling built by a qualified brace maker (never the team's bench model) against the standard brace from age 12 months, with sensor-measured night wear, skin checks and relapse follow-up to at least age 5, a device-failure and injury check at every visit (for example, inspecting each set for breakage, pinch points and skin marks, with stopping rules set in advance), and an interview guide for caregivers based on the Ugandan questions. The Toronto feasibility trial's own study protocol and statistical analysis plan are posted with its registry entry (NCT05293743) and can serve as a template. The failure and injury check follows from the Toronto prototype's reported breakages and pinch risk, described above. Relevant skills: mechanical and industrial design, biomechanics, simple sensing, trial design.

Genes

Related problems

Stuck the same way, in other fields.

field: food & the living worldforever chemicals in the farmlandNo field-validated remediation exists for PFAS-contaminated agricultural soiltested in the wrong worldsource: secondaryfield: making & materials141 gaps in the rulebook for 3d-printed partsQualifying 3D-printed metal parts runs into 141 standardization gaps, 91 needing research before standards can be written, and know-how held as trade secrettested in the wrong worldsource: primaryfield: society & learningthe armband says you're fineHeat-stress wearables tell workers their core temperature using often-secret algorithms validated mostly on young, healthy volunteers, with device agreement reported as close below 38 °Ctested in the wrong worldsource: secondaryfield: the built worldthe slow work of turning a scan into a modelScan-to-BIM for existing buildings requires laborious manual interpretationtested in the wrong worldsource: secondary

Sources

  • Doski J. "When Does Brace Noncompliance Occur in Patients with Clubfoot Deformity?" Clinics in orthopedic surgery 2025;17(6):1070-1075, doi:10.4055/cios24441, accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • Sætersdal C, Fevang JM, Engesæter LB. "Inferior results with unilateral compared with bilateral brace in Ponseti-treated clubfeet." Journal of children's orthopaedics 2017;11(3):216-222, doi:10.1302/1863-2548.11.160279, accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • Zapparoli FY, Volpon JB. "Design and evaluation of a unilateral brace for preventing clubfoot relapse: A prospective study." Journal of rehabilitation and assistive technologies engineering 2025;12:20556683251313768, doi:10.1177/20556683251313768, accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • Dreise M, Elkins C, Muhumuza MF, Musoke H, Smythe T. "Exploring Bracing Adherence in Ponseti Treatment of Clubfoot: A Comparative Study of Factors and Outcomes in Uganda." International journal of environmental research and public health 2023;20(14):6396, doi:10.3390/ijerph20146396, accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • Seatle H, Harvey B, Robitaille S, Bouchard M. "Novel Dynamic Foot Abduction Bar for Clubfoot Treatment." Journal of the Pediatric Orthopaedic Society of North America 2026;16:100397, doi:10.1016/j.jposna.2026.100397, accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • Kuhl S, Cook TM, Morcuende J, Grosland N. "Clubfoot Kickbar: Development of an Improved Brace for Use Following Correction of Clubfoot." 2020 Design of Medical Devices Conference (DMD2020), Minneapolis, 2020, doi:10.1115/dmd2020-9043 (abstract read via the Crossref record), accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • Chen RC, Gordon JE, Luhmann SJ, Schoenecker PL, Dobbs MB. "A New Dynamic Foot Abduction Orthosis for Clubfoot Treatment." Journal of Pediatric Orthopaedics 2007;27(5):522-528, doi:10.1097/bpo.0b013e318070cc19 (abstract), accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • Garg S, Porter K. "Improved bracing compliance in children with clubfeet using a dynamic orthosis." Journal of Children's Orthopaedics 2009;3(4):271-276, doi:10.1007/s11832-009-0182-9 (abstract), accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • Ogutu V, Jacob EE, Vahwere BM, et al. "Global prevalence, patterns, and predictors of relapse following Ponseti treatment for idiopathic clubfoot: a systematic review and meta-analysis." BMC Musculoskeletal Disorders 2026;27(1):636, doi:10.1186/s12891-026-10017-6, accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • Seidel A, Tinembart S, Kaiser N, Ziebarth K. "Shorter Night Splinting by a Modified Ponseti Method With Similar Foot-Function and Health-Related Quality of Life." Cureus 2025;17(3):e80260, doi:10.7759/cureus.80260, accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • Beldar MK, Ahuja BB, Chougule NK, Sahoo K, Mohite DD. "Design improvements and clinical evaluation of an adjustable clubfoot splint." Scientific Reports 2025;15(1):41946, doi:10.1038/s41598-025-25876-7, accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • Fouse BD, Rasinske SJ, Snodgrass SR, et al. "Force Characterization and Manufacturing of a Dynamic Unilateral Clubfoot Brace." 2022 Collaboratory/Engineering Symposium, Messiah University Mosaic, item engr2022/21 (the original page no longer opens; Internet Archive copy), accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • Farrar EJ, Lo M, Groothoff L, Cunningham J, Theuri J. "Two-year retrospective cohort results on use of a dynamic unilateral brace for treatment of clubfoot: Can compliance and prevention of recurrence both be achieved?" Journal of rehabilitation and assistive technologies engineering 2022;9:20556683221112084, doi:10.1177/20556683221112084, accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • Agarwal A, Rastogi A, Talwar J, Deo NB, Rastogi P. "Unilateral limb orthosis for maintenance of deformity correction following treatment of clubfoot with Ponseti technique: a systematic review." Journal of pediatric orthopedics. Part B 2022;31(2):e195-e201, doi:10.1097/bpb.0000000000000897 (abstract), accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • Zhao F, Wu T, Kang Q, et al. "Management of idiopathic clubfoot: an umbrella review and CPAM-LRC consensus: Limb Reconstruction Committee of Orthopedics Branch of China International Exchange and Promotion Association for Medical and Health Care (CPAM-LRC)." Journal of Orthopaedic Surgery and Research 2025;20(1):1103, doi:10.1186/s13018-025-06459-8, accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • Hegazy M, El Barbary H, Hammoud M, Arafa A, Mohamed MT, Barakat AS, Afifi A. "The foot external rotation above-knee (FERAK) brace versus the Denis Browne brace for management of idiopathic clubfoot following Ponseti casting: a randomized controlled trial." International orthopaedics 2022;46(2):313-319, doi:10.1007/s00264-021-05107-0, accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • Chong DY, Finberg NS, Conklin MJ, Doyle JS, Khoury JG, Gilbert SR. "Prospective evaluation of the use of Mitchell shoes and dynamic abduction brace for idiopathic clubfeet." Journal of pediatric orthopedics. Part B 2014;23(6):501-504, doi:10.1097/bpb.0000000000000090 (abstract), accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • Lara LCR, Gil BL, Torres LCA, Dos Santos TPS. "COMPARISON BETWEEN TWO TYPES OF ABDUCTION ORTHOTICS IN TREATING CONGENITAL CLUBFOOT." Acta ortopedica brasileira 2017;25(4):125-128, doi:10.1590/1413-785220172504155890, accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • Naili JE, Lindeberg M, Esbjörnsson AC. "Duration and outcome of orthotic treatment in children with clubfoot - a four-year follow-up national register study of Swedish children born between 2015 and 2017." BMC musculoskeletal disorders 2024;25(1):425, doi:10.1186/s12891-024-07544-5, accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • Kollias CM, Neville E, McLachlan L, Vladusic S. "Pressure sores and bracing complications in idiopathic clubfoot." Prosthetics and orthotics international 2026, doi:10.1097/pxr.0000000000000524 (abstract), accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • Khattak HK, Qazi AJ, Khan EW, Ahmad E, Khan ZA, Noormal, Abubakkar S, Hayat S. "Complications Arising From the Use of Foot Abduction Orthosis (FAO) in Ponseti-Treated Clubfoot Patients." Journal of pediatric orthopedics 2026;46(6):e564-e570, doi:10.1097/bpo.0000000000003153 (abstract), accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • Nantalaga KC. "Barriers, facilitators and interventions for foot abduction brace adherence in the Ponseti management of idiopathic clubfoot in low- and middle-income countries: a scoping review." Research Square preprint 2026, doi:10.21203/rs.3.rs-10037868/v1, accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • Seatle HR, Bouchard ML, Harvey BJ (The Hospital for Sick Children). "Dynamic foot abduction bar." US patent application US20230277352A1, filed 2023, accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • Cook TM, Grosland NM, Morcuende J (University of Iowa Research Foundation). "Reciprocating connecting bar assembly for a clubfoot brace." US patent US12279986B2, granted 2025, accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • University of Iowa Protostudios, "Clubfoot Kick-Bar", accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • MiracleFeet, "The MiracleFeet Brace" (maker's page), accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • Cunningham Prosthetic Care, "Clubfoot Bracing" (maker's page), accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
  • London Orthotic Consultancy, "Club foot (treatment)" (clinic page), accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
Revision notes

This brief gets checked against its sources and contains the following revisions. Future revisions get added here.

Worth knowing

  • the Ugandan comparison is between families who kept coming to clinic and those who stopped, not a measure of nightly brace wear
  • the finding that one-leg braces did worse rests partly on a systematic review read only as an abstract; a later review repeats its pooled figures

Full check

Sources read

  • Doski, brace compliance in an Iraqi cohort (2025): full text
  • Sætersdal et al., Norwegian long-term follow-up of brace types (2017): full text
  • Zapparoli & Volpon, Brazilian brace comparison (2025): full text
  • Dreise et al., Ugandan clubfoot programme study (2023): full text
  • Seatle et al., Toronto feasibility trial of a dynamic bar (2026): full text
  • Farrar et al. (2022): full text
  • Naili et al. (2024): full text
  • Lara et al., Brazilian record review of dynamic bars (2017): full text
  • Beldar et al., Indian 3D-printed splint (2025): full text
  • Zhao et al., umbrella review (2025): full text
  • Ogutu et al., relapse meta-analysis (2026): full text
  • Seidel et al., Swiss shorter-bracing study (2025): full text
  • Hegazy et al., FERAK brace randomised trial (2022): full text
  • Nantalaga, scoping review (preprint): full text
  • Agarwal et al., systematic review of brace types (2022): abstract only
  • Chong et al., randomised trial of a dynamic bar (2014): abstract only
  • Chen et al., dynamic foot abduction orthosis (2007): abstract only
  • Garg & Porter, dynamic orthosis compliance (2009): abstract only (the full text could not be opened)
  • Kollias et al. (2026), Khattak et al. (2026) and McCartney et al. (2019): abstract only
  • Iowa and Toronto patents for brace couplings: full text
  • Toronto and second trial registry records: full text
  • University of Iowa prototyping studio, MiracleFeet, Cunningham and London Orthotic Consultancy pages: full text
  • Messiah University student poster on the Cunningham brace (2022): full text

What changed

  • Not found in the sources, removed: a clause saying travel help and education do not reach the child's distress; the scoping review lists parent education and peer support among the measures tried.
  • Stated more strongly than the source: the 2007 dynamic-bar study no longer says parents reported the wear figures, since neither abstract says how wear was measured, and a point about parent-reported wear now 'may apply' to both dynamic-bar studies; the Ugandan comparison of 97 and 66 children now says that 'adherent' means the family kept coming to clinic, and that the authors cannot be sure those families used the brace every night.
  • Numbers: the 2009 dynamic-brace study's compliance for the standard brace is now given as the abstract prints it, with what the paper's own counts come to (21 of 57, about 37%).
  • Entry points: the bench starting point's statement that no bench test of a coupling was found now names the nearest one, a student fatigue test of a one-leg brace, which looked at material fatigue, not whether the foot angles hold; safety: nothing a student team builds under this page is for sale or for use on a child; safety: every bench model stays on the doll rig in the workshop; it is never fitted to boots a child wears and never given or lent to a family or a clinic; safety: in every parent session the model stays in the room, is handled by adults only, and no child is present; safety: the trial protocol handed to an orthopaedic team now includes a device-failure and injury check at every visit, with stopping rules set in advance.
  • Other: a student team's force and fatigue testing of the one-leg Cunningham brace was added to the earlier attempts, with its preliminary status.

Left open

  • results drawn from papers read only as abstracts (the main systematic review, the randomised and earlier dynamic-bar studies, and two newer papers)

Separate check of specific claims: The Kick-Bar's patent is now described as matched to it by inventor and design, its conference paper and the Toronto trial's posted protocol were added, a price difference in the Indian splint paper is shown, and six citations were added to the source list.

Earlier full check: The Egyptian brace trial was read in full and described as it is, a patent quotation was replaced with the patent's own words, the long title now says toddlers stopped wearing the brace 'as prescribed', the Toronto prototype's breakages and pinch risk were added, and the user protocol now names a coupling built by a qualified brace maker, never the team's model.

Separate check of specific claims: A randomised trial and a record review in which two-boot dynamic bars did no better, two results that point against the one-leg finding, and two existing spring-free couplings were added; the bench starting point now compares the existing designs.

Separate check of specific claims: The entry points now open with a safety line (no student-made part is ever worn by a child), the parent starting point uses a doll with adults only, and the child starting point became a protocol for an orthopaedic team to run.

Earlier full check: The titles were toned down (display title 'The Brace That Holds the Foot Loses the Child' → 'The Brace That Holds the Foot, and the Toddlers Who Stop Wearing It'), positive results for two-boot dynamic bars were added, and each country's result was restated as its paper states it.