Loading
Loading
Perspectives
A problem description is never neutral — it carries the perspective of whoever wrote it. Here we pair two briefs about the same problem, one written by an institution inside the system and one from outside, and compare them side by side. The differences are systematic: insider institutions consistently surface different root causes, different constraints, and different measures of success.
In South Africa, 2.7 million households live in informal settlements where every solar energy product on the market assumes something that doesn't exist: a permanent, legally recognized dwelling. CSIR South Africa identifies a design paradigm mismatch rooted in apartheid-era spatial planning. A US Department of Energy report, looking at the same equity gap in EV charging, proposes redistributing existing infrastructure more fairly.
Two institutions. Same structural failure. Completely different diagnoses.
CSIR South Africa
Binding constraint: Every solar model assumes permanent, legally recognized dwellings
Root cause: Apartheid-era spatial planning created permanently informal settlements
DOE / DOT (US)
Binding constraint: Demand-driven placement algorithms allocate to affluent areas
Root cause: Market logic: chargers go where current owners are
18 Matched Pairs
External Source
WHOException
SA institution (ICMR) is a technical research body that frames MORE narrowly than the external source (WHO). Institutional type moderates the shift.
7-Dimension Comparison
External
Delivery system — antivenom requires hospitals victims cannot reach
SA
Product mismatch — antivenom made from wrong regional venoms
External
Treatment architecture designed for hospitals, not communities
SA
Regulatory standards that do not require geographic venom representativeness
External
Community (victims, healers, CHWs)
SA
Regulators (CDSCO) and manufacturers
External
Active — cultural frameworks, care-seeking decisions, first-response capacity
SA
Passive — patients who receive (or fail to receive) correct product
External
Visible — traditional healers, community health structures
SA
Invisible — no mention of community capacity
External
New product architecture + community co-designed interventions
SA
Regulatory mandate for representative venom panels + national venom biobank
External
Structural driver — market collapse, poverty spiral
SA
Context — geographic inequity mentioned but not analyzed as causal
Shift Coding