health
a bath chair for a growing child
Brazil's public health system supplies a children's shell bath chair that most carers of children with congenital Zika syndrome rate well, but in one unreviewed survey 23 of 26 had back pain after bathing, one therapist said the chairs soon get tight, and a 2010 adjustable prototype was not tested in a real bath
Source: Monteiro, “Usabilidade de cadeiras de banho infantil para crianças com a…” Open ↗source: secondaryLast updated: 2026-11-17
Problem statement
Most of the children born with congenital Zika syndrome in Brazil's 2015–2016 epidemic have severe motor impairment. Many cannot hold up their head or trunk, so a carer, most often the mother, bathes them every day, often twice a day. Brazil's public health system (SUS) supplies a children's shell-type bath chair ("cadeira de rodas para banho em concha infantil"). The national technology-assessment body (CONITEC) recommended its inclusion in its report no. 53, and a health-ministry order of 7 May 2013 made the decision (a 2020 master's dissertation dates the report to October 2015). The dissertation says that before then the SUS offered only the standard adult commode chair, which CONITEC judged not recommended for these users. The main evidence here is that dissertation, from the design programme at the Federal University of Pernambuco. It was examined by a committee but not peer-reviewed. It ran an online survey of 26 carers (all women, nearly all mothers) of children with the syndrome at the most severe motor levels, and interviewed 10 occupational therapists who prescribe bath chairs. Twenty-five of the 26 carers used the SUS shell chair, and most were satisfied with it. Yet 23 of the 26 (88.5%) reported pain after bathing the child, all of them in the back. Only 57.7% judged the chair suitable for both the child and themselves. The author's own survey of nine children's bath chairs sold in Brazil found that most Brazilian-made models come in one size, with fixed frames and few or no height or tilt adjustments. The therapists said seat depth and width almost never fit these children without adaptation. One said (our translation): "the Zika children often put on a lot of weight and the chair soon ends up tight, but … many still have no trunk control … and will use [it] for a long time." Therapists in public services said they can prescribe only the SUS models. When those do not fit, they recommend a plastic chair and adapt it. By 2020 most of the children weighed 15 to 20 kg. A peer-reviewed 2026 interview study reports that the children's weight gain brought new care demands for their mothers, and one mother said, "The greatest difficulty today is his weight" (the journal's own English translation). Peer-reviewed surveys of mothers and other carers of children with the syndrome in north-east Brazil also find musculoskeletal pain or discomfort in more than nine in ten, most often in the lower back, though they do not single out bathing. The unsolved problem is a bath chair, provided at public-system cost, that keeps fitting a growing child with no trunk control and lets one carer bathe the child without back pain.
Why this matters
Bathing was the activity of daily care that carers most often rated as heavy effort in the 2020 survey, although most rated it as moderate effort. In the 2020 survey 69.2% of the families lived on up to one minimum wage, so the free SUS chair is in practice the only one they can get. Imported chairs, which have more adjustments, have in the author's words "an exorbitant price" (our translation): R$ 2,680 to R$ 25,820, against R$ 1,100 to R$ 2,771 for Brazilian-made chairs. In the 2026 study (20 mothers from several Brazilian states), mothers describe bathing among daily tasks done largely alone, and some mothers had left paid work to give care. The problem reaches beyond Zika. Children with other kinds of severe cerebral palsy face the same chairs; a 2010 study in Natal found that only 4 of 58 people with severe spastic cerebral palsy (most aged 3 to 6) had a bath chair made for their needs.
What’s been tried and why it hasn’t worked
(1) A public-system children's chair. The shell chair was added to the SUS list alongside the commode chair already supplied, not in place of it. This worked in part: the therapists reported no problems with the children's chairs (their complaints were about rusting, fragile adult chairs), and seven of the ten rated the shell chair the best they knew. Carers rated it well on most of eleven items, including ease of cleaning and storage, height and tilt. They split on ease of transport: 26.9% totally dissatisfied and 26.9% satisfied. But the SUS offers only two chair options for these children, the two SUS shell models in the dissertation's market survey come in one size with a fixed height, CONITEC's report says the shell chair is to be prescribed for children aged 0 to 4, and carers still report back pain. One carer no longer used it for lack of space at home, and the author reports that bathrooms too small for the chair led some families not to get one or to abandon it. (2) Therapist adaptations. Nine of the specialists said they adapt chairs when needed: belts, head and trunk supports, inserts that reduce seat width and depth, tilt changes, non-slip surfaces (the polyethylene shell gets slippery with soap). One said she cannot adapt chairs because her service has no workshop and suitable bath-safe materials are hard to find. Most specialists follow up through what carers tell them and reassess the chair when a carer raises a complaint or a doubt; some also ask for photos and videos. The author notes that follow-up matters most for children, whose weight and height keep changing. (3) Prescription. The specialists said there was no prescription protocol for bath chairs, and seven of the ten used the wheelchair form. The 2020 study drafted one. But a protocol cannot widen the range of chairs on offer. Nine of 10 specialists who answered said bath chairs are not designed for the different needs of disabled people. Most specialists knew very few bath-chair models. (4) An adjustable prototype (2010). A peer-reviewed engineering study at the Federal University of Rio Grande do Norte surveyed carers of 58 people with spastic quadriplegic cerebral palsy (most aged 3 to 6) and built a steel prototype with adjustable seat depth and head-support height "so that the product can be used as the user grows" (our translation), adjustable tilt, and overall height adjustment for the carer's posture. The study stopped there. The authors say it "was not tested in a real bathing situation" for lack of time, its fit, durability and efficiency could not be measured, and its cost and serial manufacture were left for future study (our translations). Nothing in the 2020 dissertation shows it reaching the SUS list or the market. (5) Other design studies. The dissertation's literature review found few studies of bath chairs, design and usability. A 2019 Brazilian design project built a support chair for respiratory physiotherapy in young children with the syndrome, not for bathing. (6) A commercial adjustable chair. An adjustable children's bath chair, the Anchor by Loh Medical, is sold in three sizes and listed as available in Brazil. Its seat depth, back angle and height adjust, its head support can be placed anywhere along the chair, and it folds; its seat width is fixed within each size. Its pages give no price (only a request for a quote) and report no testing with children or carers.
What would unlock progress
The 2010 prototype already shows the main adjustments. What is missing is a version that has been tried in real baths and costed for public purchase. A bath chair that grows: adjustable seat width, depth, back angle and head support over years of growth, using bath-safe materials, at a cost the public system will buy. It should also fit small bathrooms and fold or come apart for transport. The carer is the second user. The chair's height, tilt and transfer path should let one adult wash and lift a 20 to 30 kg child without bending over a low shell. The dissertation's planned in-person usability study (with thermography of the children) was cancelled because of COVID-19, so it could measure only satisfaction; its posture appraisal was of one carer in an internet video. A 2025 peer-reviewed pilot filmed children and carers in the support home of a rehabilitation centre, but it scored carers' posture only during feeding, not bathing; its living-room filming, of activities such as watching television, scored the children's posture. No source we read measured carers' posture while bathing a child in these chairs.
How we’d know it’s being solved
(a) Carer pain or discomfort after bathing, on the 2020 survey's questions (88.5% with pain at baseline). (b) The carer's back flexion and lifting during a bath, timed and scored with a standard posture method, against the SUS shell chair. (c) How many years and how many kilograms of growth one chair fits without hand adaptation. (d) Cost at the public system's price level (the CONITEC report behind the 2013 decision gives a suggested public-system price of R$ 739.00 for the shell chair; today's price was not checked). (e) Fit in a small bathroom and ease of transport, the item with the most dissatisfaction.
Where to start
Facility-free door (make a thing): do not rebuild the 2010 prototype. Its published adjustments (seat depth, head-support height, tilt, overall height) are the starting point. Work on what it left open: use in a wet bath, durability, cost and serial manufacture, and the small bathroom. A commercial chair with most of those adjustments is already sold (item 6), so do not re-make it either: its seat width is fixed within each size and its pages give no price. Make either a bath-safe chair whose seat width also resets as a child grows, costed at the public system's price level, or an adjustable insert or frame that fits inside the standard shell bath chair families already have and can be reset for width, depth and head support as a child grows. Use only bath-safe parts such as polyethylene, aluminium, closed-cell foam and stainless fasteners. Bench-test it with a weighted manikin (sandbags at 15, 20 and 30 kg) for stability, drainage and slip on wet, soapy surfaces, and for wear after many cycles of re-adjustment while wet. Cost its bill of materials against the R$ 1,100 to R$ 2,771 of the Brazilian-made chairs in the dissertation's market survey. Check that it folds or comes apart and fits a small bathroom. Rehearse a bath with student volunteers for the carer's posture. No partner or data is needed. Carer door: the real users, children with congenital Zika syndrome and their mothers in Brazil, cannot be reached from a campus abroad. A nearer group is parents of children with cerebral palsy or other severe motor disability (the 2010 study's group), reached through a special-education school or a parent support group. They can review mock-ups and try the transfer and the adjustments with the manikin. What transfers: lifting and washing a heavy child with no trunk control, the carer's bending and back strain, and whether one adult can re-adjust the chair. What does not transfer: the SUS chair and its two options, Brazilian bathrooms and incomes, the weight gain one therapist describes in children with the syndrome, and these mothers' research fatigue. Ethics review is needed for interviews; no child takes part. Design-the-test door: write the in-person usability protocol the 2020 study had to cancel: the carer's posture and effort, the child's position, time per bath, and satisfaction, comparing the new design with the SUS chair. It is handed to a rehabilitation service, not run. Any test with children needs ethics review (in Brazil, a research ethics committee) and parental consent, and the protocol should allow for carers' research fatigue, which the dissertation reports. Relevant skills: product design, ergonomics, materials, occupational therapy input.
Genes
Related problems
Stuck the same way, in other fields.
field: the built worldcement can't quit fossil heatCement kiln electrification blocked by refractory and scale-up barrierstested in the wrong worldsource: secondaryfield: society & learningon top of paskettiSpeech recognition now works on eight-to-eleven-year-olds and still struggles with four-year-olds and noisy classrooms — exactly where early-literacy screening would pay offtested in the wrong worldsource: secondaryfield: digital & spacedocking uninvited at twenty-eight thousand km/hOn-orbit satellite servicing autonomous rendezvoustested in the wrong worldsource: secondaryfield: digital & spaceno ruler fits every machineQuantum computing cross-platform benchmarking gaptested in the wrong worldsource: primarySources
- Monteiro MOQ. "Usabilidade de cadeiras de banho infantil para crianças com a Síndrome Congênita do Zika Vírus." Dissertação (Mestrado), Programa de Pós-Graduação em Design, Universidade Federal de Pernambuco, Recife, 2020 (orientadora: Laura Bezerra Martins), accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
- Fonseca LCMMD, Silva-Rodrigues FM, Pereira-Caldeira NMV, Okido ACC, Nascimento LC, Carlos DM, Gomes-Sponholz FA, Barbosa NG. "Maternal adaptation to caring for a child with congenital Zika virus syndrome." Revista brasileira de enfermagem 2026;79:e20250475, doi:10.1590/0034-7167-2025-0475, accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
- Dutra, F. C. M.; Gouvinhas, R. P. "Desenvolvimento de protótipo de cadeira de banho para indivíduos com paralisia cerebral tetraparética espástica." Produção, v. 20, n. 3, jul./set. 2010, p. 491-501, doi:10.1590/S0103-65132010005000048, accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
- Ministério da Saúde, Comissão Nacional de Incorporação de Tecnologias no SUS (CONITEC), Relatório nº 53, "Cadeira de rodas para banho em concha infantil, cadeira de rodas para banho com encosto reclinável e cadeira de rodas para banho com aro de propulsão na tabela de órtese, próteses e materiais especiais do SUS" (Internet Archive copy), accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
- Gregório JGR, Santino TA, Souza de Azevedo G, et al. "The burden of musculoskeletal symptoms in caregivers of children with congenital Zika syndrome: a cross-sectional study." Journal of Tropical Pediatrics 2025;71(5):fmaf039, doi:10.1093/tropej/fmaf039 (full text read through library access), accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
- Araújo LMC, Guimarães‐do‐Carmo VJ, Andrade TGVS, Claudino SC, Soares DM, Melo RS. "Musculoskeletal pain and quality of life in mothers of children with microcephaly, due to congenital Zika virus syndrome." Child: Care, Health and Development 2023;49(2):268-280, doi:10.1111/cch.13039 (full text read through library access), accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
- Tavares JS, Regis TS, Gama GL, et al. "Postural assessment of children with congenital Zika syndrome and caregivers in the home environment: a cross-sectional pilot study." Sao Paulo Medical Journal 2025;143(5):e2023354, doi:10.1590/1516-3180.2023.0354.r2.29042025, accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
- Sargeiro MAP, Pinto LRS, Bittencourt JM, Oliveira GA (names as printed on the paper; the journal's index lists them as Almeida M, Pinto L, Bittencourt JM, Amado G). "DESENVOLVIMENTO DE PRODUTO DE AUXÍLIO À FISIOTERAPIA RESPIRATÓRIA E DE ESTIMULAÇÃO VISUAL DE CRIANÇAS COM A SÍNDROME CONGÊNITA ASSOCIADA AO VÍRUS ZIKA." Ergodesign & HCI 2019;7(Especial):14-23, doi:10.22570/ergodesignhci.v7iEspecial.1302, accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
- Loh Medical, "Anchor Bath Chair" (maker's product page), accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
- Loh Medical, "ANCHOR Bath chair" (maker's spec sheet, ver_2025.11.11E), accessed 2026-11-17. Link ↗
Revision notes
This brief gets checked against its sources and contains the following revisions. Future revisions get added here.
Worth knowing
- The carer and therapist figures from Brazil's public health system come from one master's dissertation that was not peer reviewed.
Full check
Sources read
- Monteiro, master's dissertation on bath chairs for children with congenital Zika syndrome (2020): full text (read in the original Portuguese)
- Dutra and Gouvinhas, adjustable bath chair prototype (Produção, 2010): full text (read in the original Portuguese)
- CONITEC report no. 53, Brazil's assessment of the children's bath chair: full text (read in Portuguese from an archived copy)
- Fonseca and others, mothers of children with congenital Zika syndrome (2026): full text
- Tavares and others, filmed posture of children and carers (2025): full text
- Coelho and others, environmental needs of children with congenital Zika syndrome (2022): full text
- Sargeiro and others, chair for respiratory physiotherapy (2019): full text
- Gregório and others, carers' musculoskeletal symptoms (2025): full text
- Araújo and others, mothers' musculoskeletal pain (2023): full text
- Livingstone and Field, bathing devices for children with disabilities (2026): abstract only
What changed
- Not found in the sources, removed: the country given for one study, which its abstract does not name.
- Not found in the sources, replaced with what they say: that the shell chair does not adjust to growth; the dissertation's market table lists the two shell models the public system supplies in one size with a fixed height, and the government report says the chair is for children aged 0 to 4; that adaptations are not revisited as the child grows; the dissertation says follow-up runs through what carers report, with the chair reassessed when a carer raises a complaint; the filmed carers' posture was said to be scored during feeding and play; it was scored only during feeding, and the living-room filming scored the children.
- Contradicted by the source, corrected: the shell chair was said to have replaced the adult commode chair; the government report says it was added alongside it.
- Numbers: the therapists using wheelchair forms to prescribe are now seven of the ten, not all.
- Dates: the public system's decision to supply the chair is now dated to 2013 from the government report itself, which was read for the first time; the page notes that the dissertation dates that report to 2015.
- Title: the full title and the body now say the 2010 prototype was not tested in a real bath, rather than never, since the study ended there and no source follows it further (display title unchanged).
Left open
None noted in this check.
Separate check of specific claims: The government assessment report was added to the source list, a success measure now gives its suggested price for the shell chair (R$ 739) and says today's price was not checked, and 'almost always the mother' became 'most often the mother'.
Separate check of specific claims: A commercial children's bath chair sold in three sizes, with adjustable seat depth, back angle and height and listed as available in Brazil, was added; the make-a-thing door now starts from what it leaves open: seat width as the child grows, cost at the public system's prices, and an insert for the shell chairs families already have.
Earlier full check: Five fixes: 'the children are heavier now' became the 2026 study's finding that their weight gain brought new care demands; the pain surveys covered mothers and other carers and recorded pain or discomfort; the filmed carers were in a rehabilitation centre's support home, not their own homes; a related chair project was redated to 2019; and Brazil is now called middle-income.
Separate check of specific claims: The make-a-thing door now says not to rebuild the 2010 prototype and adds wet-surface and wear tests and costing against Brazilian chair prices; the carer door names a nearer group of parents to reach and what carries over.
Earlier full check: The full title now credits the point about chairs getting tight to one therapist, not therapists in general (display title unchanged); the page now says the main source is an unreviewed master's dissertation, an unsourced sentence was replaced, the source's positive findings were added, and a peer-reviewed design study and two pain surveys were added in support.